Originally posted by WestCoastForever:
That's the thing, you're sold on "the massive overreach," I think that conclusion is premature because he's new and he blew out his knee.
Of course fans can have whatever opinion they want, but I don't share your low view about the competence of the team's brain trust for the draft. They've made miscalculations, but the team's sitting mostly pretty because of their overall success in the draft and with other personnel actions.
Can you name me one player that most would have considered a massive reach that turned into a good quality player?
the only guy that we can objectively say that's true for is a Wishnowsky a punter
I mean I would even give you Banks BUT IMO if you're burning a top 50 pick on a guard only prospect, he better be f**king really good and looked at as a guy they will man that position past his rookie deal. So far neither of those things are true with him.
Also I'm not saying they suck at drafting…I'm saying they do have a tendency to overdraft a guy or two every yr. They rely too much on coaches input on draft picks and misread how the rest of the league feels about certain players.
Latu and a dozen others fall in this category.