There are 399 users in the forums
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick was a one man wrecking crew against the Niners. Against the Chiefs you didn't hear his name.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by JoseCortez:
So what is the excuse for having 4 qbs knocked out? Just wondering what your thoughts are. Is it just bad luck? Is it the blocking scheme? Is it just a coincidence? Do all our qbs have injury issues? It cant be the oline, because they prioritized it. Or maybe they prioritized it, and they just sucked at it? Maybe prioritizing the oline with jouneymen centers, late round picks and mediocre right right guards isnt the best way to prioritize?
And how do you rank an oline? Clearly keeping the qb healthy is not a factor, because theyd be dead last.
Every other team knows that to keep a qb healthy you have to a good oline. Tom Brady was never touched when he was at New England. But us? 4 qbs get destroyed, and we have people claiming this is a top 10 oline.
I said the oline would be the death of this team during the preseason. Heres to hoping they "prioritize" better.
If you think every QB injury or hit is solely because of OL play then we have no conversion here. I'm not gonna break it all down (again) for you.
it's lazy an simple minded to think that's the only reason.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by YACBros85:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by YACBros85:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by genus49:
You have a point but hilarious you kept Aiyuk off the list to make your point.
That's just a list of the 1st rounders that didn't work out or play up to expectation. Bosa isn't on the list either.
His 2 and 4 comment presumably is a 'record' of their success, with Bosa and Aiyuk being the successful two, and Trey not included because it's too early to grade.
How does the 2 and 4 compare to the rest of the league? Is it average or below average? Its hard to judge something without something else to compare it to.
Be my guess. But I think it would throw this thread off topic.
But you're missing the point of why I posted Lynch and Shanahan's picks in the 1st round.
(Edit)
What was the point of the statement other than to take a jab at the FO for their 1st round picks? How they have faired compared to the rest of the league is very relevant.
Like others have said. Its not very honest of you to throw MM on the bad pick side when he will be signing a second contract for more than we can afford to offer him. That would actually make the FO 3-3 in the 1st round with Trey Lance still being an unknown at this point.
Yes the point was they have done more bad than good in the 1st round. And not how has Lynch compare to the rest of the league that wasn't the point.
As for McGlinchey, there were other ways they could've went besides RT, 49ers definitely could've used Minkah Fitzpatrick or Derwin James. I thought McGlinchey was being groomed to be the future LT, which IMO would've made the pick deemed worthy. You and I know McGlinchey wasn't worth the #9 overall pick, he's a horrible pass blocker and commits tons of penalties, not to mention has only managed to start 3 full seasons outta the 5 he's been in SF. Sure he'll most likely get a pretty solid contract, but that's because of inflation, demand and not how well he's performed.
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
You could blame every RB injury on the O line as well if you want to blame someone. Who gets blamed for the defensive players who get hurt? We've has seasons where every DB or every LB has been injured at one time or another. Who's fault is that?
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick was a one man wrecking crew against the Niners. Against the Chiefs you didn't hear his name.
QB play is a massive part of it. Being able to have good pocket awareness. Avoid guys and extend is massively underrated by a handful of people in here.
Originally posted by JoseCortez:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by fan49:
There only issue is they don't prioritize oline
Posts like this drive me insane. Fake news.
-traded for the best LT in football made him the highest played player at his position.
-drafted a RT top 15
-trade for a former 1st rd pick at LG and developed him into a pro-bowler
-spend elite money at center a couple years ago
-spent a top 50 pick on a LG.
-spent numerous picks on the OL.
They just came off a season where they were ranked top 10 all over the place at offensive line.
So what is the excuse for having 4 qbs knocked out? Just wondering what your thoughts are. Is it just bad luck? Is it the blocking scheme? Is it just a coincidence? Do all our qbs have injury issues? It cant be the oline, because they prioritized it. Or maybe they prioritized it, and they just sucked at it? Maybe prioritizing the oline with jouneymen centers, late round picks and mediocre right right guards isnt the best way to prioritize?
And how do you rank an oline? Clearly keeping the qb healthy is not a factor, because theyd be dead last.
Every other team knows that to keep a qb healthy you have to a good oline. Tom Brady was never touched when he was at New England. But us? 4 qbs get destroyed, and we have people claiming this is a top 10 oline.
I said the oline would be the death of this team during the preseason. Heres to hoping they "prioritize" better.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Right, blame this blame that…there's nuance in every single injury that happens.
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick was a one man wrecking crew against the Niners. Against the Chiefs you didn't hear his name.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick was a one man wrecking crew against the Niners. Against the Chiefs you didn't hear his name.
QB play is a massive part of it. Being able to have good pocket awareness. Avoid guys and extend is massively underrated by a handful of people in here.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by JoseCortez:
So what is the excuse for having 4 qbs knocked out? Just wondering what your thoughts are. Is it just bad luck? Is it the blocking scheme? Is it just a coincidence? Do all our qbs have injury issues? It cant be the oline, because they prioritized it. Or maybe they prioritized it, and they just sucked at it? Maybe prioritizing the oline with jouneymen centers, late round picks and mediocre right right guards isnt the best way to prioritize?
And how do you rank an oline? Clearly keeping the qb healthy is not a factor, because theyd be dead last.
Every other team knows that to keep a qb healthy you have to a good oline. Tom Brady was never touched when he was at New England. But us? 4 qbs get destroyed, and we have people claiming this is a top 10 oline.
I said the oline would be the death of this team during the preseason. Heres to hoping they "prioritize" better.
If you think every QB injury or hit is solely because of OL play then we have no conversion here. I'm not gonna break it all down (again) for you.
it's lazy an simple minded to think that's the only reason.
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick was a one man wrecking crew against the Niners. Against the Chiefs you didn't hear his name.
QB play is a massive part of it. Being able to have good pocket awareness. Avoid guys and extend is massively underrated by a handful of people in here.
Hmm. That explanation is like going around the equator to borrow a cup of sugar from your neighbor.
You don't see this as a wylie vs mcg issue? Wylie literally sat on reddick at least one play. Brute force should make it on our draft board occasionally.
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick is 240.
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Hmm. That explanation is like going around the equator to borrow a cup of sugar from your neighbor.
You don't see this as a wylie vs mcg issue? Wylie literally sat on reddick at least one play. Brute force should make it on our draft board occasionally.
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick is 240.
So was fred dean
Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Reddick was a one man wrecking crew against the Niners. Against the Chiefs you didn't hear his name.
