There are 112 users in the forums

Would McCarthy make a good GM?

Would McCarthy make a good GM?

Would he do a good job in this position?
Oh hell no!!! Need to remember when he was our OC and led us to an at the time the worst offense in NFL history , then bolts the next year to GB. Came in here as this offensive guru my ass. Don't want him back here
better than lynch.
Originally posted by pdizo916:
better than lynch.

Where's your proof of that … and if you answer, please do with facts and not opinion ?!
I have no clue to be honest. He scored with Rodgers.

Other then that 🤷🏻‍♂️
  • Homer
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 945
Originally posted by 49erWill:
I have no clue to be honest. He scored with Rodgers.

Other then that 🤷🏻‍♂️

He preferred Smith out of college
Originally posted by Homer:
Originally posted by 49erWill:
I have no clue to be honest. He scored with Rodgers.

Other then that 🤷🏻‍♂️

He preferred Smith out of college

Great resume. So clearly he can pick QBs...
Originally posted by 49erWill:
I have no clue to be honest. He scored with Rodgers.

Other then that 🤷🏻‍♂️

He didnt draft Aaron Rodgers. Ted Thompson would be the guy who gets credit for that. McCarthy has zero qualifications to be GM
Ixnay on that . What was the biggest problem for A Rodgers? Having talent around him. That was the story the entire time he was there, except for the SB. But most other yrs, what went wrong with AR was not enough talent around him. So no, ixnay on McCarthy as GM.
Wow! First time I have seen a unanimous vote! No by 24 to 0.

Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by 49erWill:
I have no clue to be honest. He scored with Rodgers.

Other then that 🤷🏻‍♂️

He didnt draft Aaron Rodgers. Ted Thompson would be the guy who gets credit for that. McCarthy has zero qualifications to be GM

I meant as far as the success he had coaching. This wouldn't be a topic if he was a bad coach all those years. This discussion is happening because he had Rodgers.
Originally posted by English:
Wow! First time I have seen a unanimous vote! No by 24 to 0.

Look again...

Sorry I had to
He'll get another head coaching gig. Former SB winner with a .618 record + over 500 in the playoffs. Yeah he had Rodgers but someone is going to roll the dice on him.
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Originally posted by Homer:
Originally posted by 49erWill:
I have no clue to be honest. He scored with Rodgers.

Other then that 🤷🏻‍♂️

He preferred Smith out of college

Great resume. So clearly he can pick QBs...

He didn't draft Rodgers, he was OC under Nolan in 2005.
we don't need a rookie GM ...again
Share 49erswebzone