There are 119 users in the forums

Would McCarthy make a good GM?

Would McCarthy make a good GM?

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Would he do a good job in this position?

Probably about as good as Mike Holmgren did.
no
McCarthy not gonna be an alternative job / minor role coach. He has enough credentials to be hired as HC and likely choose the better fit on his system such as CLE, DEN,CAR or TB.
Who knows...I've never heard his name mentioned in that light. Just a comment WRT Lynch...when you consider only a handful of players on the roster when he & Lynch took over are still there, it's very hard to critique him. Like any new GM, he's made some mistakes. He's also acquired Garoppolo, Kittle, Mullens, Breida, McGlinchey, Richburg, Person, Tomlinson, Pettis, Sherman, Juszczyk, Day, Goodwin, Gould, Mitchell, Moore, Harris, Warner, Thomas, et al. That's a lot of heavy lifting for any new GM.
Originally posted by wailers15:
Oh hell no!!! Need to remember when he was our OC and led us to an at the time the worst offense in NFL history , then bolts the next year to GB. Came in here as this offensive guru my ass. Don't want him back here

Absolute Truth!
I think he could end up in Denver as HC.
Originally posted by LasVegasWally:
I think he could end up in Denver as HC.

Or Falcons
He still has plenty of coaching left in him.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Would he do a good job in this position?

Probably about as good as Mike Holmgren did.

That's a good point.
Why? He picked Alex Smith over Rodgers when he was w niners.

Walked into Rodgers in GB

Originally posted by Mertonschickendance:
Why? He picked Alex Smith over Rodgers when he was w niners.

Walked into Rodgers in GB

Well he didn't pick Alex. Dude was oc. That's on Nolan.
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Well he didn't pick Alex. Dude was oc. That's on Nolan.

One of the reasons that Nolan took Smith was that McCarthy was all in on him.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
One of the reasons that Nolan took Smith was that McCarthy was all in on him.

Well he liked Rodgers enough to go to GB too. We know Nolan was turned off by AR's attitude.
Is this a serious thing? lol good lord.
McCarthy isn't a great coach, he was solid but had Aaron Rodgers. Lol without Rodgers his teams didn't do a damn thing.
Share 49erswebzone