Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:

Originally posted by boast:
nah it's 100% ok to point out the randumb posters who post stupid things like "Jimmy doesnt have a handle on the offense"

who said that?

No one. But Boast gonna Boast.

random already reposted his comment. claiming Jimmy doesn't have command of the offense. which is just another way of saying he doesn't have a grasp or handle of the offense.

I suppose command and grasp are the same thing. Ok so one poster. Who else?

"stupid things like..."

reading is fundamental SWH

I read it just fine. There was one poster who you can sort of stretch to say what you are claiming.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by boast:
"stupid things like..."

reading is fundamental SWH

Enough about posters.

Any opinions on the 49ers?

there are no rules about pointing out and critiquing dumb comments by posters. it's a public forum. if you dont want your posts commented on, people might want to refrain from posting dumb comments or posting altogether.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:

Originally posted by boast:
nah it's 100% ok to point out the randumb posters who post stupid things like "Jimmy doesnt have a handle on the offense"

who said that?

No one. But Boast gonna Boast.

random already reposted his comment. claiming Jimmy doesn't have command of the offense. which is just another way of saying he doesn't have a grasp or handle of the offense.

I suppose command and grasp are the same thing. Ok so one poster. Who else?

"stupid things like..."

reading is fundamental SWH

I read it just fine. There was one poster who you can sort of stretch to say what you are claiming.

another related stupid post was 5GR's rants about Jimmy's brain and the lack of its plasticity inhibiting him from improving.

is jimmy g going to struggle like tom brady?

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by boast:
"stupid things like..."

reading is fundamental SWH

Enough about posters.

Any opinions on the 49ers?

there are no rules about pointing out and critiquing dumb comments by posters. it's a public forum. if you dont want your posts commented on, people might want to refrain from posting dumb comments or posting altogether.

Who said anything about rules?? I asked u if you had any opinions related to you know, the team?

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by fropwns:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Remember when you had a whole ton of people calling for Garoppolo to get straight up cut?



Good thing Shanahan and Lynch don't pay any attention to this fanbase.

My man, the niners are going to have a big decision on their hands if Jimmy G takes us back to the top of the mountain. And by decision, I mean what to do with Trey Lance because Jimmy GQ won't be going anywhere.

The decision is easy: if we don't win the Super Bowl, let Jimmy go. If we do, offer him a contract with outs for the team and have him compete with Trey. Either way, Trey goes NOWHERE because he's on a rookie contract.

if Jimmy wins the Super Bowl and is resigned, he's not going to compete for the starting position. he'll be the starter.

I think that will depend on how he plays during his playoff run if we make it.

he either plays well enough to be re-signed or won't be re-signed. pretty sure that idea is baked into my comment.

My bad, read it wrong. If he is resigned I would think he played well in the playoff run and super bowl to win it all and I would totally be in support for him to be the starter again. Only problem is I would think he would want a new contract.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by boast:

Originally posted by Sanfran_chrisco:

Originally posted by boast:
nah it's 100% ok to point out the randumb posters who post stupid things like "Jimmy doesnt have a handle on the offense"

who said that?

posted in the thread a few weeks back.

Wayminn!? You talkin bout dis???

Originally posted by random49er:
...I don't see a QB out there that has command of this offense....

He's had a handle of the offense for years! But when did having a handle on something and having COMMAND of it become synonymous?

When you have command of the offense when immense gameplanning doesnt seem necessary and throwing for 40 or so times a game is no big deal.

FWIW,....completely changing someone's words for attention is the very definition of trolling. Lol but your name is in gold so have at it.

Oh....my.....lord. Did you just say Kyle shouldn't/wouldn't have immense game-planning if we had, say, Josh Allen? WTF LOL. Mike Shanahan made Steve Young go through all 300 plays of the Super Bowl they had installed TWICE with flashcards, the reads and answers for every defense. That was HOF QB, Steve effing Young.

If you don't think Kyle is immensely game-planning no matter who is out there at QB.....I don't even know what to tell you.

Also, if you don't think Kyle wants a balanced, 50/50 attack - you don't actually read or listen to any of his pressers or interviews. How can you actually expect any of us to listen when you don't even listen to Kyle?

Originally posted by picklejuice:

.@49ers @JimmyG_10 with the proper timing. The precision timing to go from @CMC_22 to @THE2ERA for the TD. #BaldysBreakfowns pic.twitter.com/FQ8ZOPKSW6

— Brian Baldinger (@BaldyNFL) November 22, 2022

Great execution and great design. Echos of the WCO there, back when routes and progressions were timed with hitches .

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by dj43:

Originally posted by Waterbear:
I like how in all these hypothetical scenarios in which we win the Super Bowl that Jimmy's quality of play never gets mentioned.

We've won playoff games while completing 8 passes. We probably have the most versatile offensive skill group in the history of the NFL.

It would be much more impressive to me if Jimmy learns how to consistently throw deep passes on time, escape the pocket/improve off schedule plays (like he has somewhat recently),and eliminate turnovers (much better this year) than it would be to solely lead this team to a SB.

Of course, his value will be greatly affected by how he plays in the playoffs. Going against the best defenses in the league and doing well is what earns the highest salaries.
As Kyle noted last week, Jimmy and the team have elevated their play. Now the test of consistency will be the next measure. As of this morning, he has the 6th highest passer rating. Keep that up and we all

Absolutely. I'd love for Jimmy to win us #6. He'd easily become my favorite player at that point. He's a very likable player unlike the rest of the NFC West QBs in previous years. I've always remained consistent with that feeling and I promised I will buy a Jimmy poster and keep it in my room forever if he wins it all.

Overall this season I don't think Jimmy's played close to the 6th best. I prefer QBR over QB rating, Jimmy was 24th I believe in QBR last week and jumped up to 19th this week. I think Jimmy's been about average as he's consistently inconsistent.

Ironically I could see me wanting to keep Jimmy where he jumps up into the top 5-10 in QBR but we don't make the Super Bowl, over a season in which he remains in that 15-25 range but he wins it all. Essentially I'm saying Jimmy could prove to me that he should be our starter without winning the super bowl and he could win the super bowl without playing that well. I don't think that's too far fetched.

That's because he's played very well and very poorly this year. But his best this year has been spectacular.

Originally posted by picklejuice:

I can't wait til Sunday. 49ers fans think they're going to win. Jimmy G is same as Tom Brady. What happens when we play Brady. Average arm. Not mobile at all. SACK!!! That's what happens 😆

— Kellum⚜️ (@KellumCollins) November 23, 2022

is jimmy g going to struggle like tom brady?

I don't think so. New Orleans just has voodoo magic on Brady lol. Doesn't help too that Jimmy G had one of his best game as a 49er against them.

Originally posted by jonnydel:
Oh....my.....lord. Did you just say Kyle shouldn't/wouldn't have immense game-planning if we had, say, Josh Allen?

No. That's not what I said. My comments were on the abilities of Josh Allen compared to Jimmy G.

You can literally gameplan around Josh Allen's talents. He's the kind of QB that's developing into a player you can ask to go win you the game. Carry the load.

With Jimmy....you give him everything and you generally ask him to get the ball to his playmakers and not f**k up.

Another failed spin, btw.

These are 2 players that are just in completely different categories. If you have some ideas on Kyle's gameplanning abilities you should share them with NC.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by NinerBuff:
At 15:4, he's now almost 4:1 TD/INT ratio, which is pro-bowl level. He is playing well above his career best to date.

The man knows how to get a max contract!!

Last year he played really well too, for him. His CAY/A was off the charts compared to his career highs (7th in the NFL, while he's usually in the high 20s). However, he was still throwing dumb INTs. That number is down this year, to a career low of 1.5%. His CAY/A is back to his career mean, however, in the past it was similar except he was throwing twice as many interceptions. It's bad when you're throwing short passes while also throwing a lot of INTs. But when you're NOT throwing INTs, and you're throwing lots of touchdowns (his TD% is at the moment the best he's had since 2019), that's a winning formula. Moreover, as is usually for Jimmy G, he's 6th in the NFL in 3D%.

In other words, he's simply playing winning football.

he's not only checking it down, getting the ball into his playmaker's hands, but that s**t he pulled off with Kittle showed he can also be a playmaker himself. that's some good s**t right there. he's really feeling it.

took him a while, and he kind of got thrown into the fire with 0 offseason reps with the team, but he's in a good place. hard for us fans to truly understand what is involved and what these guys go through in reality.

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:

Originally posted by picklejuice:

I can't wait til Sunday. 49ers fans think they're going to win. Jimmy G is same as Tom Brady. What happens when we play Brady. Average arm. Not mobile at all. SACK!!! That's what happens 😆

— Kellum⚜️ (@KellumCollins) November 23, 2022

is jimmy g going to struggle like tom brady?

I don't think so. New Orleans just has voodoo magic on Brady lol. Doesn't help too that Jimmy G had one of his best game as a 49er against them.

ANY given Sunday, but chalk me up as one of those fans...

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by jonnydel:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Dshearn:
eh.....

have defended Jimmy G in the past.... but...

To me.... he looks like a product of the system.

What made Jimmy special (again I'm my opinion) was his release, and he has never quite returned to that early glimpse of talent that was very very rare.

I can't help but think there are a fair number of QBs, given the same tenor in the system, that can do what Jimmy is doing now.

The problem lies in either needing elite talent to plug and play, or spending time to groom another QB to the point that they are this functional.

"If only we had kept Colt McCoy" ~ 49ersRing

Give Colt McCoy this team and he's probably putting up similar numbers to Jimmy right now.

Not many QBs have the benefit of playing with 3 All-Pro receivers and a consensus top-5 pass blocking o-line.

I've been really impressed with Aiyuk....but are we really calling him all-pro?

Soooo, who's all-pro is he taking? A.J. Brown? Justin Jefferson? Stefan Diggs? Mike Evans? Davante Adams? Tyreek Hill? D-Hop? If not for injuries you could make the argument for a few other guys too.

Deebo, Kittle, and CMC are all former all-pros who are still playing at, or near, that level.

Dude Colt McCoy = Jimmy now? Y'all are trying WAAAY too hard

mccoy7 cant get rid of the ball like jimmy can. with our line, he's a pancake.

With our top 5 o-line?

It's amazing that people here think that having CMC, Deebo, Kittle, Aiyuk, etc. and a top o-line wouldn't make a lot of QBs around the league look good.

Maybe, just maybe, it's a top 5 oline because of jimmys release???

With that said. My jaw dropped at Jimmy's protection yesterday. I haven't seen Jimmy ever have that much time. Probably ever. Shocked.

top 5 oline? that's dry humor right? mcg-burford-brendel. top5? that's rich. I'm chuckling.

There's a reason kyle calls the most 2.5s pass plays in the league. And it's not our top 5 oline

Oh yea, they're awful.

Trent Williams, Jake Brendel, Spencer Burford and Aaron Banks have combined to allow 0 sacks this season, per PFF.

Zero.

— Akash Anavarathan (@akashanav) November 22, 2022

People here act like people try to diminish Jimmy's accomplishments, but that's nothing compared to what people come up with to try to take credit from the o-line.

Call me crazy, but I think if there are zero sacks and you have 3 players average over 5 yards a carry in the run game, the o-line probably had a good night.

Quick release will make your Offensive Line look good. Yup.

This was completed for a first down that kicked off our first scoring drive.

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by picklejuice:

.@49ers @JimmyG_10 with the proper timing. The precision timing to go from @CMC_22 to @THE2ERA for the TD. #BaldysBreakfowns pic.twitter.com/FQ8ZOPKSW6

— Brian Baldinger (@BaldyNFL) November 22, 2022

Great execution and great design. Echos of the WCO there, back when routes and progressions were timed with hitches .

Love it, great execution by everyone! If you look at it, it even seems like Trent and Banks timed to push their defenders out of the way so Jimmy can throw that heat lol. Great progression and throw by Jimmy.