Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by GhostofFredDean74:
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Originally posted by dj43:
I see absolutely no reason the 49ers should extend Harbaugh between now and the end of the 2014 season. He has done a mediocre job with a loaded roster that is capable of winning the Super Bowl. A coach should only be rewarded when he makes the most of the situation he has been given, not when someone stirs up a big stink about something that might have happened. Harbaugh has been a huge improvement over Singletary who was one of the worst coaches in history. Need to keep things in perspective.
I agree Jim had his shortcomings in the super bowl and this past NFCCG but the fact is we have arguably been the best team over the last three years under Jim. Now the problem is we have zero chips to show for it
Yes, that IS the problem. When you have the best talent 3 years in a row, or 2 out of the last 3 years, and have no chips to show for it, you don't deserve a raise. In fact, it is fair to call in question just how good a coach one is.
So the standard now is 3 years without a SB and you're now called into question? I mean, go ahead if you feel indignant enough about it, but stop and think how realistic is it to win a SB in 3 years after taking over a deeply dysfunctional team. Now, if we were still struggling at 8-8 or 6-10, then yes, questioning makes perfect sense. But after winning 36 games in 3 years, 2 NFC West titles, 3 NFC championship appearances in a row with one NFC Championship leading to one SB that we came within 5 yards of winning, most people would call that an incredible success.
Think about it...most teams in the league would KILL for those kinds of "chips" and I would hope most fans would appreciate that kind of ongoing success, especially after going a decade in utter shame and humility.
Ok, so he many not be Bill Walsh great yet (or maybe never), but if all of the above doesn't qualify as "good" in your book, than the problem is with your expectations, not with Harbaugh. It took John Harbaugh 5 years to get his ring, and Carroll just got his first after 20 years of NFL coaching and everyone thinks he's a genius now.
We need to keep the entire team situation in perspective. The franchise had been in purgatory for 10 years. Erickson/Nolan/Singletary were the worst string of coaches the team has ever had (Fred Meyer and Pete McCully excepted). Prior to Singletary's last season, the 49ers were the sexy choice to win the division. Years of weak seasons had yielded lots of high draft choices that looked like high quality. Many were predicting as many as 11 or 12 wins. The talent was here. We all know and recognize that. What Harbaugh took over was poised to do exactly what they did - win. Harbaugh did what was expected from a good coach with excellent talent.
For all us fans, we were ecstatic when Harbaugh delivered what many had expected before his arrival. He was made the messiah and he did a good job. Now, three years later, we see the offense still struggling in critical situations, the young handpicked QB plateaued this past season, and the coaching staff is still struggling with game management issues that are as bad or worse than the Singletary years. Indeed, the team led the league in delay of game penalties 2 years. However, because JH has been SO MUCH better than Singletary, many here still want to anoint him messiah. I am not one of those.
I believe Harbaugh is a good coach, not a great one. ESPN anonymously polled 320 current NFL players prior to the Super Bowl as to which coach in the NFL they would most like to play for. Jim Harbaugh finished 8th. That is just about where I rate him among current NFL coaches.
There's a place in between "messiah" as you call it and just a "good coach" as you believe him to be. It takes a great coach to take a group of talented players who didn't know how to play winning football, and elevate them to perennial SB contenders. For all the issues our offense has had (and there are many), the defense has been pretty spectacular since he took over.
I seriously can't believe you just said that our QB, who just finished up his FIRST FULL season as a starter has "plateaued." Kap was the 10th rated QB in the league last year (91.6) and 7th in QBR (68.6) ahead of such notables as Andrew Luck, Tom Brady, Tony Romo, Russell Wilson, Newton, Dalton and even Alex Smith (49.4). By all measure, he had a great first full year and (IMO) only the pessimist can't see him getting even better with a healthy WR corps.
IMO, people see what they want to see, and not always what's really going on. When a coach fails to win a SB, they definitely open themselves up to intense scrutiny, so I get that. But when you see the entire picture (not just snippets of the bad stuff, which every team deals with), Harbaugh by most objective observers qualifies as a "great coach."