49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 751 users in the forums

🏈 2026 NFL ENTRY DRAFT 🏈-Do not tip picks!

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by ritz126:
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
I actually think our scouts are pretty good. I constantly like the players we draft. Even the underperformers. Loved Pearsall. LOVED Renardo Green. LOVVVEEEDDDD Drake Jackson. (Cant say I loved any of the RBs tho lol)

But here's the constant problem

"Man, I really like Stribling. He'd make an awesome 3rd round contingency pick if we miss out on a guy like Omar Cooper. He makes me feel comfortable waiting on WR if we wanna invest in a more shallow impact position like edge rusher or OL early. Heck. Hes so good, cant rule out pick 58. But if we get sniped, WR pretty deep and we did well in FA, I wouldnt mind Skyler Bell or something later."

Proceeds to take Stribling, over Cooper, with essentially a 1st round pick. Edge and OL thins out completely. Skyler Bell and others still available.

"Man, Romello Height is pretty good. We really need pass rush help..as a designated pass rush guy, he'd make a fine contingency plan if we miss out on guys like Howell or Barham. If we get to the 4th round without a pass rusher, hes definitely in play. If we somehow trade for a late 3rd rounder, say...pick 90, id be game."

Proceeds to pass on Howell and Thomas. Barham still available.

"Man, Kaelon Black might just be the best late round value at RB in this entire class. People are sleeping. He'd be a phenomenal 6th round pick, id even use a 5th. If we cant get one, RB isnt the hugest need, but if hes BPA with our last pick In the 4th, he wont be a UDFA, so why not?"

Proceeds to draft him in the 3rd.

Look, my evaluations of Barham vs Height could be wrong. Consensus of Stribling vs Omar Cooper could be wrong. But this is constant.
You are comparing them 1:1 they are different types of players and you have to look at team make up

Stribling has unreal upside i said in a thread somewhere i wouldnt be surprised if he was picked in 2nd round because he has everything you want and honestly is a perfect fit for this offense. Cooper is more lets call it pro ready runs a better route tree and recognizes soft spots of zones better. Stribling on the other hand (and this is why 49ers loved him) is he has great hands and his size to speed ratio is insane .Hes only dropped like 2 passes in his career or something crazy like that has great ball tracking and most importantly has 4.3 speed which shows up on tape to take the top off the defense. He can play slot and X. He needs to work on his release package and route running but i think he was drafted as our deep threat at the slot position to clear out space

The Barham vs Height. Height is a better pure pass rusher i dont think thats debatable. The issue is Barham is someone who will see the field every play and is much better against the run but i think 49ers wanted a DPR and imo Height is one of the best in the draft. On top of that Height is a pretty complete prospect already has multiple move elite first step and bend. He is a guy who can come in and contribute day 1 in a specialized role.

I evaluate prospects through one specific lense: how do they help the 49ers.

Obviously, yes, same position, different prospects with different roles.

But I don't have an immediate need for a X / Big Slot vertical WR any more than I have an immediate need for a Z, or a true slot. But i do have a need to get younger and deeper at WR. And Cooper is a better WR.

Again, I like Stribling. Was in many of my mocks. But would other teams have taken him over Boston or Bernard if we moved down? And even if so, and hes gone, is he 30-40 picks better than Malachi Fields, Ted Hurst or Chris Brazzel? 60 picks better than Chris Bell? 100 picks better than the receivers still on the board?

Same with Height vs Barham.Yes, different archetypes. But Height is a 25 year old size outlier. Barham is a versatile violent SOB who can produce in 3rd downs right now, and develop into an actual star.

Id be surprised if Stribling ever becomes a true #2 let alone #1. You dont use your first pick on a WR because the can block. Id be surprised if Height ever becomes a household name.

Ironically enough, the team loved Stribling cus he can block. Team loved Black because he can pass protect. But team doesn't love anyone who has blocking as their primary responsibility
  • bud49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,046
Drafting best player available or need? My opinion need and when I say need just a body to backup who's on the field.
[ Edited by bud49 on Apr 25, 2026 at 8:03 AM ]
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
I evaluate prospects through one specific lense: how do they help the 49ers.

Obviously, yes, same position, different prospects with different roles.

But I don't have an immediate need for a X / Big Slot vertical WR any more than I have an immediate need for a Z, or a true slot. But i do have a need to get younger and deeper at WR. And Cooper is a better WR.

Again, I like Stribling. Was in many of my mocks. But would other teams have taken him over Boston or Bernard if we moved down? And even if so, and hes gone, is he 30-40 picks better than Malachi Fields, Ted Hurst or Chris Brazzel? 60 picks better than Chris Bell? 100 picks better than the receivers still on the board?

Same with Height vs Barham.Yes, different archetypes. But Height is a 25 year old size outlier. Barham is a versatile violent SOB who can produce in 3rd downs right now, and develop into an actual star.

Id be surprised if Stribling ever becomes a true #2 let alone #1. You dont use your first pick on a WR because the can block. Id be surprised if Height ever becomes a household name.

Ironically enough, the team loved Stribling cus he can block. Team loved Black because he can pass protect. But team doesn't love anyone who has blocking as their primary responsibility

Maybe maybe not but i think with them talking in offseason they wanted guys who can seperate early. Boston and Bernard are not those guys. I was never high on Bernard but Boston i liked but he isnt a separator he is a endzone contested catch guy. I was a bit high on Stribling once i saw him just cause the size/speed/hands combo was so enticing i didnt have him this high obviously but i think i mentioned it in the other thread i definitely get it. He is one of those high floor high ceiling guys. The worst case he is a vertical threat who has great hands and tracking ability. The best case is he can be a #1 Wr if he gets better at beating press coverage and work on his fluidity. But if you look at Matt Harmons video on him and see his route running they pretty much highlight how his route tree is a perfect fir for McVay/Shanahan. I agree this was way higher than i had him (more mid to late 2nd round to early 3rd round guy) but i get the pick for sure. I think the team really had PTSD from last year where we lost all our weapons and wanted to get ahead of it in case there are injuries

For Height vs Barham they are just totally different players. If you want a pass rusher who can contribute day 1 its Height it isnt even close. Barham has more upside and is more versatile but we wanted someone who can rush the passer we just got one of the best ones
[ Edited by ritz126 on Apr 25, 2026 at 8:17 AM ]
  • bud49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,046
Chances are none of the picks taken this draft will see the field for extensive playing time this year. That pick at RB the dude looks stiff no fluidity when he runs.
Originally posted by bud49:
Drafting best player available or need? My opinion need and when I say need just a body to backup who's on the field.

We drafted neither, BPA or Need is not in the Shana/Lynch vocabulary. They draft FPA (Favorite Player Available) and there are certain criteria to meet for this. They must be a reach, they cannot be a position of need, and they must be placed in Kyle's doghouse their first 2-4 years.
Originally posted by ritz126:
Maybe maybe not but i think with them talking in offseason they wanted guys who can seperate early. Boston and Bernard are not those guys. I was never high on Bernard but Boston i liked but he isnt a separator he is a endzone contested catch guy. I was a bit high on Stribling once i saw him just cause the size/speed/hands combo was so enticing i didnt have him this high obviously but i think i mentioned it in the other thread i definitely get it. He is one of those high floor high ceiling guys. The worst case he is a vertical threat who has great hands and tracking ability. The best case is he can be a #1 Wr if he gets better at beating press coverage and work on his fluidity. But if you look at Matt Harmons video on him and see his route running they pretty much highlight how his route tree is a perfect fir for McVay/Shanahan. I agree this was way higher than i had him (more mid to late 2nd round to early 3rd round guy) but i get the pick for sure. I think the team really had PTSD from last year where we lost all our weapons and wanted to get ahead of it in case there are injuries

For Height vs Barham they are just totally different players. If you want a pass rusher who can contribute day 1 its Height it isnt even close. Barham has more upside and is more versatile but we wanted someone who can rush the passer we just got one of the best ones

If we wanted a quick separator, Stribling is not that. And you made my point. Hes a great addition to the team. But not over other options at 27, 30 or 33. It doesnt really matter if we like him more than Bernard or Boston, because we aren't bidding vs ourselves. It matters if we move down 8 spots, will someone else draft him with the other players also on the board. And if hes soooo good you cant risk it, then I get it. But id question why they are evaluating Stribling as a must-draft cant miss prospect. And id argue that they didn't anyway, or they wouldn't have risked trading down twice first. Nothing lines up with any logical sense.

For Barham, we'll never know, but ill go to the grave saying he will have had an equally or more productive rookie season than Height.

Im a process over results guy. And when go back and realize we haven't drafted a single game changing player since Brock Purdy, you start to realize this process isnt leading to results.
[ Edited by adrianlesnar on Apr 25, 2026 at 8:34 AM ]
Originally posted by Fresno49er:
Originally posted by bud49:
Drafting best player available or need? My opinion need and when I say need just a body to backup who's on the field.

We drafted neither, BPA or Need is not in the Shana/Lynch vocabulary. They draft FPA (Favorite Player Available) and there are certain criteria to meet for this. They must be a reach, they cannot be a position of need, and they must be placed in Kyle's doghouse their first 2-4 years.

They also need to have their hair on fire.
Originally posted by Fresno49er:
We drafted neither, BPA or Need is not in the Shana/Lynch vocabulary. They draft FPA (Favorite Player Available) and there are certain criteria to meet for this. They must be a reach, they cannot be a position of need, and they must be placed in Kyle's doghouse their first 2-4 years.

FPA That's so good. I'm using that moving forward.
  • Giedi
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 35,233
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
I'm sure he depends on them in certain areas but he absolutely calls the shots and gets his guys no matter what value be damned.

Completely disagree, Mac Jones would have went 2nd overall if true.

they aren't gonna draft a guy without Kyle agreeing on it but overall that's probably true for most legit HCs in the league,

I think the problem with it is their big board is drastically different than draft analysts and other teams…and they seem not to factor any of that in regards to value,

I agree, and I think one of the aspects of evaluations is the mental evaluations. Case in point Aiyuk. I don't know what happened between Kyle and Aiyuk but something in Aiyuk's mindset and attitude just shut him down last year and he never recovered. I think their player evaluations have to be affected by that. I also remember Jerry saying everybody in the NFL is physically talented, what sets the great from the good player is the mind side of the equation. Again it's hard to evaluate the mental side - case in point Trey Lance vs Brock Purdy, but I think their Draft Board analysis does factor in more of the mental side than the consensus fan base's evaluations - which for the most part - rely on film and combine results. I'll add in culture. Both Kyle and John are big on the culture side of the ball player - whatever that culture means to them and their mental evaluations - but its again another mental aspect of their evaluations in my opinion that most fans aren't aware of.
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
Originally posted by ritz126:
Maybe maybe not but i think with them talking in offseason they wanted guys who can seperate early. Boston and Bernard are not those guys. I was never high on Bernard but Boston i liked but he isnt a separator he is a endzone contested catch guy. I was a bit high on Stribling once i saw him just cause the size/speed/hands combo was so enticing i didnt have him this high obviously but i think i mentioned it in the other thread i definitely get it. He is one of those high floor high ceiling guys. The worst case he is a vertical threat who has great hands and tracking ability. The best case is he can be a #1 Wr if he gets better at beating press coverage and work on his fluidity. But if you look at Matt Harmons video on him and see his route running they pretty much highlight how his route tree is a perfect fir for McVay/Shanahan. I agree this was way higher than i had him (more mid to late 2nd round to early 3rd round guy) but i get the pick for sure. I think the team really had PTSD from last year where we lost all our weapons and wanted to get ahead of it in case there are injuries

For Height vs Barham they are just totally different players. If you want a pass rusher who can contribute day 1 its Height it isnt even close. Barham has more upside and is more versatile but we wanted someone who can rush the passer we just got one of the best ones

If we wanted a quick separator, Stribling is not that. And you made my point. Hes a great addition to the team. But not over other options at 27, 30 or 33. It doesnt really matter if we like him more than Bernard or Boston, because we aren't bidding vs ourselves. It matters if we move down 8 spots, will someone else draft him with the other players also on the board. And if hes soooo good you cant risk it, then I get it. But id question why they are evaluating Stribling as a must-draft cant miss prospect. And id argue that they didn't anyway, or they wouldn't have risked trading down twice first. Nothing lines up with any logical sense.

For Barham, we'll never know, but ill go to the grave saying he will have had an equally or more productive rookie season than Height.

Im a process over results guy. And when go back and realize we haven't drafted a single game changing player since Brock Purdy, you start to realize this process isnt leading to results.

oh i agree for sure. I think we wanted someone to take the top of defense that was really missing from the team last year. I agree with rest of your post for sure he probably would've been available 8-10 picks later but this guy is just a system fit i think the scouting and coaching fell in love with him and felt they couldnt risk it. I also get why people wont like the pick.

Height though i loved i think he was also a 2nd round prospect when it comes to the DPR role. With us trading winters if we can get Perkins in the 4th or 5th round our pass rush is going to be night and day from last year. Barham is more fun to watch as a chess piece but Heightis just a complete pass rusher already

Not having impact players is fustrating for sure but i honestly really liked what i saw from Williams (who is still only 21) and Persall. Its jsut a matter of both being healthy
Okay let's stop b***hing for a min…day 3! Let's flip this f**ker around and land some solid talent.

who do we want?

Keionte Scott
Dennis-Sutton
Connor Lew
Gracen Halton
Travis Burke
Sam Hecht
Kaleb Proctor
Malik Muhammad
Jalon Kilgore
Jalen Farmer
Joshua Josephs
VJ Payne
Febechi Nwaiwu
Kamari Ramsey
Michael Trigg
Beau Stephens
Brian Parker II
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Apr 25, 2026 at 8:48 AM ]
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
Therein lies the problem. The players that the team thinks makes them better, havent. The idea that "this player isnt likely to start over who we currently have" has led us to drafting kickers. Punters. Tight ends and RBs that dont get single snaps. Zero leverage contract disputes with players because we have zero depth behind them. Reliance on old players who completely derail offensive or defensive efficiency when they go down because we dont draft depth that "wouldn't start over the current starter anyway"

Im not saying this team is devoid of talent. Im not one of those posters screaming WE NEED OL just for OL sake. But the proof is already in the pudding that there is something fundamentally wrong with how this team approaches the draft.

To go back to the FB example, you can still draft him later. If no one uses a FB, then why use a 4th when the bidding wouldn't start til the 6th? There are ZERO other players that can fit your team? And if the 6th comes around, and the one other team who likes the player snipes him, there are ZERO contingencies? Talk about a shallow board and hyper focusing on draft crushes.

This is a great take. Not good, but GREAT! Completely explains why this team has waisted drafts and lacks depth. This whole "wouldn't start over the current starter anyway" approach has been ruinous to the roster.

Indeed there is something fundamentally wrong with this team's approach to the draft. It's called Shanny having too much of a say on personnel decisions and the team not having a real talent evaluating roster building GM who knows how to work the draft.

The Yorks (not Jed) are gonna have to put their foot down, fire Lynch, bring in a true talent evaluating roster building GM who knows how to work the draft, and demand that Shanny focuses on coaching the final 53 and gameday roster. It should be clear to all by now that Shanny is the best at scheming but horrible at personnel decisions.
we should draft

QB - Pavia
RB - Washington

with out two next picks, cause "why not". Would go right along with what we've been doing.
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by Fresno49er:
We drafted neither, BPA or Need is not in the Shana/Lynch vocabulary. They draft FPA (Favorite Player Available) and there are certain criteria to meet for this. They must be a reach, they cannot be a position of need, and they must be placed in Kyle's doghouse their first 2-4 years.

FPA That's so good. I'm using that moving forward.

I mean they're not wrong!! We do not care how anyone would or might have graded anyone, we just pick our favorite people, sometimes not even based on talent! We just like the person and wanna make them rich!
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by Fresno49er:
We drafted neither, BPA or Need is not in the Shana/Lynch vocabulary. They draft FPA (Favorite Player Available) and there are certain criteria to meet for this. They must be a reach, they cannot be a position of need, and they must be placed in Kyle's doghouse their first 2-4 years.

FPA That's so good. I'm using that moving forward.

I mean they're not wrong!! We do not care how anyone would or might have graded anyone, we just pick our favorite people, sometimes not even based on talent! We just like the person and wanna make them rich!

It will be funny if these guys become all pros and H.O.F's

LOL

We would all look silly
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone