49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 798 users in the forums

🏈 2026 NFL ENTRY DRAFT 🏈-Do not tip picks!

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Slept on it and I f**king hate this draft. I mean I think Height is a solid pick but it doesn't make up for the f**king stupidity with the other two picks.

Everyone is roasting them and rightfully so. I'm so done with Lynch and this whole scouting department. Why do they have to make this s**t so hard

This isn't the scouting department I don't think. It's Kyle prioritizing his guys and positions. The scouting department is what has gotten the team all the value adds over the years.

I disagree there. Kyle isn't in a dark room watching everything and making all the decisions. He absolutely depends on his scouting department and coaching staff during the process.

Again I don't "hate" the players they drafted, I just hated where they were taken and who else they passed on. Everyone top to bottom in SF is part of the issue with consistently not giving a f**k about value and reading the rest of the league. It clearly doesn't work given who they've taken in those scenarios.

I knew as soon as they started trading down that they had "a guy" that they KNEW no one was gonna take anywhere close to where they would so they could just grab picks and overdraft him. For whatever reason they think that's smarter than getting the higher rated talent.
At this rate, the only way they can make me hate this draft even more is by drafting a punter and Genesis Smith at safety. It wouldn't shock me in the slightest if they did both.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Slept on it and I f**king hate this draft. I mean I think Height is a solid pick but it doesn't make up for the f**king stupidity with the other two picks.

Everyone is roasting them and rightfully so. I'm so done with Lynch and this whole scouting department. Why do they have to make this s**t so hard

This isn't the scouting department I don't think. It's Kyle prioritizing his guys and positions. The scouting department is what has gotten the team all the value adds over the years.

I disagree there. Kyle isn't in a dark room watching everything and making all the decisions. He absolutely depends on his scouting department and coaching staff during the process.

Again I don't "hate" the players they drafted, I just hated where they were taken and who else they passed on. Everyone top to bottom in SF is part of the issue with consistently not giving a f**k about value and reading the rest of the league. It clearly doesn't work given who they've taken in those scenarios.

I knew as soon as they started trading down that they had "a guy" that they KNEW no one was gonna take anywhere close to where they would so they could just grab picks and overdraft him. For whatever reason they think that's smarter than getting the higher rated talent.
I'm sure he depends on them in certain areas but he absolutely calls the shots and gets his guys no matter what value be damned.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
I disagree there. Kyle isn't in a dark room watching everything and making all the decisions. He absolutely depends on his scouting department and coaching staff during the process.

Again I don't "hate" the players they drafted, I just hated where they were taken and who else they passed on. Everyone top to bottom in SF is part of the issue with consistently not giving a f**k about value and reading the rest of the league. It clearly doesn't work given who they've taken in those scenarios.

I knew as soon as they started trading down that they had "a guy" that they KNEW no one was gonna take anywhere close to where they would so they could just grab picks and overdraft him. For whatever reason they think that's smarter than getting the higher rated talent.

You got it right about their trading philosophy and selecting their guys. They simply don't care about the positional value. Problem with this is I think they ignore much better talent that might have dropped.
Where I disagree is about your comment on Kyle. I absolutely believe Kyle is making the call and he is watching film.
I'll give you proof. Look at the day 2 press conference when we selected Renardo Green. Pearsall, who was drafted on day 1, walked into Kyle's office in the morning of Day 2 (prior to the draft starting) . And Kyle was watching film of Green and coincidentally Pearsall was the guy he was defending. Kyle felt bad and didn't want Pearsall to think he was watching flaws of him on tape.
What does this tell you? 1) Pretty clear Kyle watched tape 2) further evidence that Niners pick their guys, this time it was Green.
I actually think our scouts are pretty good. I constantly like the players we draft. Even the underperformers. Loved Pearsall. LOVED Renardo Green. LOVVVEEEDDDD Drake Jackson. (Cant say I loved any of the RBs tho lol)

But here's the constant problem

"Man, I really like Stribling. He'd make an awesome 3rd round contingency pick if we miss out on a guy like Omar Cooper. He makes me feel comfortable waiting on WR if we wanna invest in a more shallow impact position like edge rusher or OL early. Heck. Hes so good, cant rule out pick 58. But if we get sniped, WR pretty deep and we did well in FA, I wouldnt mind Skyler Bell or something later."

Proceeds to take Stribling, over Cooper, with essentially a 1st round pick. Edge and OL thins out completely. Skyler Bell and others still available.

"Man, Romello Height is pretty good. We really need pass rush help..as a designated pass rush guy, he'd make a fine contingency plan if we miss out on guys like Howell or Barham. If we get to the 4th round without a pass rusher, hes definitely in play. If we somehow trade for a late 3rd rounder, say...pick 90, id be game."

Proceeds to pass on Howell and Thomas. Barham still available.

"Man, Kaelon Black might just be the best late round value at RB in this entire class. People are sleeping. He'd be a phenomenal 6th round pick, id even use a 5th. If we cant get one, RB isnt the hugest need, but if hes BPA with our last pick In the 4th, he wont be a UDFA, so why not?"

Proceeds to draft him in the 3rd.

Look, my evaluations of Barham vs Height could be wrong. Consensus of Stribling vs Omar Cooper could be wrong. But this is constant.
[ Edited by adrianlesnar on Apr 25, 2026 at 7:26 AM ]
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
I'm sure he depends on them in certain areas but he absolutely calls the shots and gets his guys no matter what value be damned.

Completely disagree, Mac Jones would have went 2nd overall if true.

they aren't gonna draft a guy without Kyle agreeing on it but overall that's probably true for most legit HCs in the league,

I think the problem with it is their big board is drastically different than draft analysts and other teams…and they seem not to factor any of that in regards to value,
Originally posted by Rice-a-Ronnie:
You got it right about their trading philosophy and selecting their guys. They simply don't care about the positional value. Problem with this is I think they ignore much better talent that might have dropped.
Where I disagree is about your comment on Kyle. I absolutely believe Kyle is making the call and he is watching film.
I'll give you proof. Look at the day 2 press conference when we selected Renardo Green. Pearsall, who was drafted on day 1, walked into Kyle's office in the morning of Day 2 (prior to the draft starting) . And Kyle was watching film of Green and coincidentally Pearsall was the guy he was defending. Kyle felt bad and didn't want Pearsall to think he was watching flaws of him on tape.
What does this tell you? 1) Pretty clear Kyle watched tape 2) further evidence that Niners pick their guys, this time it was Green.

I'm not saying he doesn't watch the film. But it's physically impossible for him to do it all. He's not the only guy grinding film on a day 3 RB. He has Bobby Turner doing that. He has his WR coaches doing all the draft info on WRs. Coach K for DL. They talk about how KJ wright was heavily involved with Height etc etc,

Yes him and lynch have final say on picks….that's true for every NFL team.

again I don't really hate the guys they got, I hate the process of how they got them and the talent they passed up to get them.

we gotta stop acting like they don't have a FO full of a staff that makes a ton of money to evaluate players. We need to understand that his coaching staff is there to just hold his nuts all day. They are heavily involved in the process all the same.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Completely disagree, Mac Jones would have went 2nd overall if true.

they aren't gonna draft a guy without Kyle agreeing on it but overall that's probably true for most legit HCs in the league,

I think the problem with it is their big board is drastically different than draft analysts and other teams…and they seem not to factor any of that in regards to value,

I don't think Kyle liked Mac more than Trey. Never bought that for a second. Kyle wanted his Josh Allen.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
I'm sure he depends on them in certain areas but he absolutely calls the shots and gets his guys no matter what value be damned.

Completely disagree, Mac Jones would have went 2nd overall if true.

they aren't gonna draft a guy without Kyle agreeing on it but overall that's probably true for most legit HCs in the league,

I think the problem with it is their big board is drastically different than draft analysts and other teams…and they seem not to factor any of that in regards to value,
Kyle admitted himself Mac Jones was his guy when they traded up but had to much time to think about or some BS like that.

Kyle fell in love with Stribling according to the article on the front page do you think that is irrelevant to where they took him?
Originally posted by DaleGribble:
Kyle admitted himself Mac Jones was his guy when they traded up but had to much time to think about or some BS like that.

Kyle fell in love with Stribling according to the article on the front page do you think that is irrelevant to where they took him?

All these day 2 skill players being over drafted doesn't speak to a failure of the personnel department to me. When it's the same positions brewing repeated over and over that's the choice at the top.

Kyle the personnel guy wants to give Kyle the coach the most toys possible. That's where the problem lies. Someone has to convince him otherwise going forward.
[ Edited by 9ers4eva on Apr 25, 2026 at 7:41 AM ]
Originally posted by NYniner85:
I'm not saying he doesn't watch the film. But it's physically impossible for him to do it all. He's not the only guy grinding film on a day 3 RB. He has Bobby Turner doing that. He has his WR coaches doing all the draft info on WRs. Coach K for DL. They talk about how KJ wright was heavily involved with Height etc etc,

Yes him and lynch have final say on picks….that's true for every NFL team.

again I don't really hate the guys they got, I hate the process of how they got them and the talent they passed up to get them.

we gotta stop acting like they don't have a FO full of a staff that makes a ton of money to evaluate players. We need to understand that his coaching staff is there to just hold his nuts all day. They are heavily involved in the process all the same.
Yes it's certainly not all Kyle. I think the distinction, and what makes the Niners unique, is it's Kyle and the coaches vs. Front office. I don't think other teams (like Eagles) let their coaches dictate the draft strategy/management as much as the Niners. Maybe I am wrong but that's just my hypothesis to the question of Why the Niners reach in the early rounds.
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
I actually think our scouts are pretty good. I constantly like the players we draft. Even the underperformers. Loved Pearsall. LOVED Renardo Green. LOVVVEEEDDDD Drake Jackson. (Cant say I loved any of the RBs tho lol)

But here's the constant problem

"Man, I really like Stribling. He'd make an awesome 3rd round contingency pick if we miss out on a guy like Omar Cooper. He makes me feel comfortable waiting on WR if we wanna invest in a more shallow impact position like edge rusher or OL early. Heck. Hes so good, cant rule out pick 58. But if we get sniped, WR pretty deep and we did well in FA, I wouldnt mind Skyler Bell or something later."

Proceeds to take Stribling, over Cooper, with essentially a 1st round pick. Edge and OL thins out completely. Skyler Bell and others still available.

"Man, Romello Height is pretty good. We really need pass rush help..as a designated pass rush guy, he'd make a fine contingency plan if we miss out on guys like Howell or Barham. If we get to the 4th round without a pass rusher, hes definitely in play. If we somehow trade for a late 3rd rounder, say...pick 90, id be game."

Proceeds to pass on Howell and Thomas. Barham still available.

"Man, Kaelon Black might just be the best late round value at RB in this entire class. People are sleeping. He'd be a phenomenal 6th round pick, id even use a 5th. If we cant get one, RB isnt the hugest need, but if hes BPA with our last pick In the 4th, he wont be a UDFA, so why not?"

Proceeds to draft him in the 3rd.

Look, my evaluations of Barham vs Height could be wrong. Consensus of Stribling vs Omar Cooper could be wrong. But this is constant.

I'm with you. I hate the overall process not the players they took.

they clearly setup to have the idea of collecting more picks because they KNEW the guys they were cool with would be there after the picks (because they're fine reaching there)…When the board fell the way it did, they still took those guys regardless of who was still there and the needs they had. so they reach and this process has failed time and time again.

At 30 cooper was a fine pick, for me I wasn't a massive fan of him. I thought the value they got in a trade down was dogs**t though.

They can totally redeem themselves with a good day 3 draft….still a ton of solid talent out there. I'm not gonna hold my breath with any of it though
Originally posted by adrianlesnar:
I actually think our scouts are pretty good. I constantly like the players we draft. Even the underperformers. Loved Pearsall. LOVED Renardo Green. LOVVVEEEDDDD Drake Jackson. (Cant say I loved any of the RBs tho lol)

But here's the constant problem

"Man, I really like Stribling. He'd make an awesome 3rd round contingency pick if we miss out on a guy like Omar Cooper. He makes me feel comfortable waiting on WR if we wanna invest in a more shallow impact position like edge rusher or OL early. Heck. Hes so good, cant rule out pick 58. But if we get sniped, WR pretty deep and we did well in FA, I wouldnt mind Skyler Bell or something later."

Proceeds to take Stribling, over Cooper, with essentially a 1st round pick. Edge and OL thins out completely. Skyler Bell and others still available.

"Man, Romello Height is pretty good. We really need pass rush help..as a designated pass rush guy, he'd make a fine contingency plan if we miss out on guys like Howell or Barham. If we get to the 4th round without a pass rusher, hes definitely in play. If we somehow trade for a late 3rd rounder, say...pick 90, id be game."

Proceeds to pass on Howell and Thomas. Barham still available.

"Man, Kaelon Black might just be the best late round value at RB in this entire class. People are sleeping. He'd be a phenomenal 6th round pick, id even use a 5th. If we cant get one, RB isnt the hugest need, but if hes BPA with our last pick In the 4th, he wont be a UDFA, so why not?"

Proceeds to draft him in the 3rd.

Look, my evaluations of Barham vs Height could be wrong. Consensus of Stribling vs Omar Cooper could be wrong. But this is constant.
You are comparing them 1:1 they are different types of players and you have to look at team make up

Stribling has unreal upside i said in a thread somewhere i wouldnt be surprised if he was picked in 2nd round because he has everything you want and honestly is a perfect fit for this offense. Cooper is more lets call it pro ready runs a better route tree and recognizes soft spots of zones better. Stribling on the other hand (and this is why 49ers loved him) is he has great hands and his size to speed ratio is insane .Hes only dropped like 2 passes in his career or something crazy like that has great ball tracking and most importantly has 4.3 speed which shows up on tape to take the top off the defense. He can play slot and X. He needs to work on his release package and route running but i think he was drafted as our deep threat at the slot position to clear out space and that isnt something Cooper provides ( in hindsight i think our top choice was KC in first round because thats what he provided)

The Barham vs Height. Height is a better pure pass rusher i dont think thats debatable. The issue is Barham is someone who will see the field every play and is much better against the run but i think 49ers wanted a DPR and imo Height is one of the best in the draft. On top of that Height is a pretty complete prospect already has multiple move elite first step and bend. He is a guy who can come in and contribute day 1 in a specialized role.
[ Edited by ritz126 on Apr 25, 2026 at 7:50 AM ]
It's frustrating that they talk themselves into picks... that is a sign of bad drafting philosophy. When they remove thought in the later rounds they seemingly end up finding better talent than their first 3 rounds.
At the end of the day, barring injury we walked away from the first 3 rounds with a contribution of about 10-20 plays a game from these 3 guys. Thats pathetic knowing that Seattle can push our sh*t in by just rushing 4 and our safeties cant track the ball. I'll take any pass rush help tbh regardless of who so at least they leaned into that for a pick and he will probably see the most time.

I get that the talent after 15-20 is all the same yada yada yada, at the same time its another draft where they make questionable moves while talent at positions that could contribute fall off the board.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Rice-a-Ronnie:
You got it right about their trading philosophy and selecting their guys. They simply don't care about the positional value. Problem with this is I think they ignore much better talent that might have dropped.
Where I disagree is about your comment on Kyle. I absolutely believe Kyle is making the call and he is watching film.
I'll give you proof. Look at the day 2 press conference when we selected Renardo Green. Pearsall, who was drafted on day 1, walked into Kyle's office in the morning of Day 2 (prior to the draft starting) . And Kyle was watching film of Green and coincidentally Pearsall was the guy he was defending. Kyle felt bad and didn't want Pearsall to think he was watching flaws of him on tape.
What does this tell you? 1) Pretty clear Kyle watched tape 2) further evidence that Niners pick their guys, this time it was Green.

I'm not saying he doesn't watch the film. But it's physically impossible for him to do it all. He's not the only guy grinding film on a day 3 RB. He has Bobby Turner doing that. He has his WR coaches doing all the draft info on WRs. Coach K for DL. They talk about how KJ wright was heavily involved with Height etc etc,

Yes him and lynch have final say on picks….that's true for every NFL team.

again I don't really hate the guys they got, I hate the process of how they got them and the talent they passed up to get them.

we gotta stop acting like they don't have a FO full of a staff that makes a ton of money to evaluate players. We need to understand that his coaching staff is there to just hold his nuts all day. They are heavily involved in the process all the same.

We didn't show them. The only team during the draft that had a bunch of little kids bouncing around instead of scouts doing their thing.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone