Giants trade ?

That'd be hilarious if niners were to pick DK Metcalf, which would go against all that Kyle Shannahan values in a receiver. Fans would be so shocked.

It's becoming more ovious to me that you have to take Bosa at 2 since he's one of the most pro ready pass rushers to come out in last several years. His family injury history scares me though.

Originally posted by pwillis52beasty:
That'd be hilarious if niners were to pick DK Metcalf, which would go against all that Kyle Shannahan values in a receiver. Fans would be so shocked.

It's becoming more ovious to me that you have to take Bosa at 2 since he's one of the most pro ready pass rushers to come out in last several years. His family injury history scares me though.

Injury history?

hes a niner for sure

Raiders or Giants (all their first rounders and 2nd round)...

With all those picks and our own picks...Snag edge rusher, Greedy Williams, Hakeem Butler, DBs, oline depth and one more LB.

If they want Haskins do 2 for 6, 17, and their 2nd.

I honestly think the Giants are trying to load up to move to #1 for Murray. But wanted OBJ out of the NFC. Now they have the ammunition to move up

Originally posted by pd24:

If they want Haskins do 2 for 6, 17, and their 2nd.

Who would you chose then ? Or hope to..

Originally posted by jersey49er:

Originally posted by pd24:
If they want Haskins do 2 for 6, 17, and their 2nd.

Who would you chose then ? Or hope to..

Burnes or Sweat, and at 17 Devin Bush or Greedy Williams if they are there.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

I honestly think the Giants are trying to load up to move to #1 for Murray. But wanted OBJ out of the NFC. Now they have the ammunition to move up

I agree, I honestly think Kyler and A Haskins might go top 5

With the FA haul Lynch has acquired, I think chances of a trade down are considerably less now. I'd bet the Cards take Murray...who's the guy Kingsbury wants to run his Air Raid offense. Rosen's not the guy. They'll trade him. The #2 spot will be wide open...and Lynch will take Williams, not Bosa.

If I'm the Giants I try to flip a 2nd rounder for Rosen. See if AZ bites. Wishful thinking to think Gettleman will give up all those draft picks for to move up from 6 to 2. I'd want more than #17 in return. I'd want 2 1s (with one of them in 2020).

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by jersey49er:

Originally posted by pd24:
If they want Haskins do 2 for 6, 17, and their 2nd.

Who would you chose then ? Or hope to..

Burnes or Sweat, and at 17 Devin Bush or Greedy Williams if they are there.

I like it. I like Bush a lot, but we could really use Greedy in our (very) questionable secondary.

Originally posted by jersey49er:
Assuming Bosa is gone this is Move I wouldn't mind considering Edge, WR, S, G have to basically be taken care of through the draft..

2nd overall pick to the Giants for 6th, 17th, their 1st next year..

Now who are your picks at 6th and 17th ?

6th- DK Metcalf
17th- Brian Burns
36th- Nassir Adderley or Taylor Rapp

It is a creative way to go if we want Metcalf.

I feel like after what we have done in free agency, at the very least we need to give Jimmy G a legit weapon.

I like Metcalf, there are no two ways about it, I think he can be a match-up nightmare. I also concur there is risk involved, but the upside can be considerable.

At the same time, I have had some time to look at the film again and I am beginning to think Quinnen Williams is the best player in this draft over Nick Bosa. But, equally, I also believe pass rush from the edges is a bigger need than generating interior pressures as it stands since we have DeFo. So, say if either Bosa is gone or if we don't think Bosa is worth the 2 pick, the Metcalf move can be a very interesting alternative way to go and it will be a huge statement too. It is like announcing to the whole world the 9ers is not only in the business of beefing up our D which is what we have been doing, but you better believe Jimmy G will be taking our offense to the next level with a true No.1 WR talent as well as a much enhanced running game with McKinnon being back and the addition of a more physical back in Tevin Coleman.

I would totally applaud such a move because it would be an exceedingly bold, brave and creative route to take.

Do I think Lynch and Shanny will do it? Probably not. But, I think they have a huge dilemma in front of them between picking Q vs Bosa.

It is also worth saying as far as Lynch and Shanny go, sometimes you just need to think out of the box.

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
6th: Montez Sweat, Edge
17th: Johnathan Abram, Safety
36th: Garrett Bradbury, Center

You lost me at Bradbury.

riginally posted by Hysterikal:
I honestly think the Giants are trying to load up to move to #1 for Murray. But wanted OBJ out of the NFC. Now they have the ammunition to move up

I think they'd rather trade for Rosen.

Originally posted by Hysterikal:

I have 0 interest in Metcalf

Right. Why are we even talking about this guy.