Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 649 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by gold49digger:
If there isn't a qb in this draft then no need for force draft one. kyle should be here for a while, find a bridge qb (maybe even keep kap) and wait until next year. should be a better draft class.

We need to address the position but it doesn't mean we have to draft someone we think isn't worth the pick just due to need.

Trubisky to me is the only guy I'd be excited about at #2 but would still have reservations. Watson slightly below that.

If we could get Peterman in round 3/4 I'd rather that option but it's hard to play that game because you never know who will be available when you're off the clock.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
If there isn't a qb in this draft then no need for force draft one. kyle should be here for a while, find a bridge qb (maybe even keep kap) and wait until next year. should be a better draft class.

We need to address the position but it doesn't mean we have to draft someone we think isn't worth the pick just due to need.

Trubisky to me is the only guy I'd be excited about at #2 but would still have reservations. Watson slightly below that.

If we could get Peterman in round 3/4 I'd rather that option but it's hard to play that game because you never know who will be available when you're off the clock.

Trubisky is more my type of QB but I was very impressed by Watson's game against Alabama. He is a guy with high character and came up big in a huge game! Hard to ignore that game.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
If there isn't a qb in this draft then no need for force draft one. kyle should be here for a while, find a bridge qb (maybe even keep kap) and wait until next year. should be a better draft class.

We need to address the position but it doesn't mean we have to draft someone we think isn't worth the pick just due to need.

Trubisky to me is the only guy I'd be excited about at #2 but would still have reservations. Watson slightly below that.

If we could get Peterman in round 3/4 I'd rather that option but it's hard to play that game because you never know who will be available when you're off the clock.

Trubisky is more my type of QB but I was very impressed by Watson's game against Alabama. He is a guy with high character and came up big in a huge game! Hard to ignore that game.
You were certainly impressed by Russell's bowl game back then similar to Al Davis.
Originally posted by communist:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
If there isn't a qb in this draft then no need for force draft one. kyle should be here for a while, find a bridge qb (maybe even keep kap) and wait until next year. should be a better draft class.

We need to address the position but it doesn't mean we have to draft someone we think isn't worth the pick just due to need.

Trubisky to me is the only guy I'd be excited about at #2 but would still have reservations. Watson slightly below that.

If we could get Peterman in round 3/4 I'd rather that option but it's hard to play that game because you never know who will be available when you're off the clock.

Trubisky is more my type of QB but I was very impressed by Watson's game against Alabama. He is a guy with high character and came up big in a huge game! Hard to ignore that game.
You were certainly impressed by Russell's bowl game back then similar to Al Davis.

No but I was impressed with Montana's bowl game!
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by communist:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
If there isn't a qb in this draft then no need for force draft one. kyle should be here for a while, find a bridge qb (maybe even keep kap) and wait until next year. should be a better draft class.

We need to address the position but it doesn't mean we have to draft someone we think isn't worth the pick just due to need.

Trubisky to me is the only guy I'd be excited about at #2 but would still have reservations. Watson slightly below that.

If we could get Peterman in round 3/4 I'd rather that option but it's hard to play that game because you never know who will be available when you're off the clock.

Trubisky is more my type of QB but I was very impressed by Watson's game against Alabama. He is a guy with high character and came up big in a huge game! Hard to ignore that game.
You were certainly impressed by Russell's bowl game back then similar to Al Davis.

No but I was impressed with Montana's bowl game!


OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHH no he didn't!
After seeing Ryan choke away the SB, I hope if we pick a QB we choose one who doesn't s*#t the bed when it matters in a game. Watson seems to have the "It" factor. Trubisky seems to as well in that Pitt game and almost made that comeback against Stanford.
Funny seeing the Patriots win superbowls with a group of day 3 and undrafted wide receivers and running backs. Lol
[ Edited by Heroism on Feb 5, 2017 at 9:56 PM ]
  • Karma
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,190
Originally posted by ninerAxe:
After seeing Ryan choke away the SB, I hope if we pick a QB we choose one who doesn't s*#t the bed when it matters in a game. Watson seems to have the "It" factor. Trubisky seems to as well in that Pitt game and almost made that comeback against Stanford.

While I am a believer in the intangible "it" factor, my first thoughts after that Bowl Game were: Vince Young. One play, one game, or even one season does not foretell the "it" factor. Watson does not appeal to me.
Originally posted by Heroism:
Funny seeing the Patriots win superbowls with a group of day 3 and undrafted wide receivers and running backs. Lol

Well if you have the best QB to ever play, that makes it possible.
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Well if you have the best QB to ever play, that makes it possible.

It's more than having the best QB ever, but yes, having a quarterback is the focal point. Other teams find success with similar approach. There's this misconception around here that you have to invest high draft picks into your skill positions.

It's about having a philosophy and vision, finding players with traits and qualities that fit that vision and philosophy, and coaching them up. Patriots do this, Steelers do this, Seahawks do this, etc.
[ Edited by Heroism on Feb 6, 2017 at 11:27 AM ]
Originally posted by Karma:
While I am a believer in the intangible "it" factor, my first thoughts after that Bowl Game were: Vince Young. One play, one game, or even one season does not foretell the "it" factor. Watson does not appeal to me.

Seriously? Watson displayed that "it" factor from the day he stepped on that campus. One play, one game and one season absolutely does not foretell anything. It also absolutely does not apply when speaking about Watson
  • Karma
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,190
Originally posted by 49ers808:
Originally posted by Karma:
While I am a believer in the intangible "it" factor, my first thoughts after that Bowl Game were: Vince Young. One play, one game, or even one season does not foretell the "it" factor. Watson does not appeal to me.

Seriously? Watson displayed that "it" factor from the day he stepped on that campus. One play, one game and one season absolutely does not foretell anything. It also absolutely does not apply when speaking about Watson

Sure, he has been a successful college quarterback, but most of this season he has been consider a notch below a future franchise QB. He has never been that Luck/Manning(s) kind of prospect but many people believe that his National Championship performance changed that. He doesn't share much else with Vince Young, but I saw him as a Teddy Bridgewater type before that game and that's how I see him now. He could be a good pro, but probably not a great one.
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Well if you have the best QB to ever play, that makes it possible.

It's more than having the best QB ever, but yes, having a quarterback is the focal point. Other teams find success with similar approach. There's this misconception around here that you have to invest high draft picks into your skill positions.

It's about having a philosophy and vision, finding players with traits and qualities that fit that vision and philosophy, and coaching them up. Patriots do this, Steelers do this, Seahawks do this, etc.

Great post
Even if the Niners drafted Andrew Luck this year, they still have massive holes throughout this roster. I say they use this draft and FA to build the team, draft a developmental QB in the 4th or 5th, and then try to trade up next year when the QB class is stronger.
Originally posted by Butter:
Even if the Niners drafted Andrew Luck this year, they still have massive holes throughout this roster. I say they use this draft and FA to build the team, draft a developmental QB in the 4th or 5th, and then try to trade up next year when the QB class is stronger.

If you can get a stud QB(or who you think will be one) you do it. Hell if you get a chance at a once in a blue moon type prospect the following season and you think he's better you can still draft him. The position is that important/franchise changing and the rookie scale makes it possible to do that if need be.

This team isn't that devoid of talent that we should be afraid to bring in a QB to play here. If it's that bad then he can sit and learn as we build the team around him.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone