49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 769 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by titan:
I would take any QB that resembles a form of hope!

Falk

I like mitch trubisky

He's good too, I'd be happy with him as well.
So is it going to be better off trading the #2 pick for a first next year and move down this year? Then would have 2 1st round picks to get one of the 2018 QB's and a solid defender from this years draft like Rueben Foster.
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
So is it going to be better off trading the #2 pick for a first next year and move down this year? Then would have 2 1st round picks to get one of the 2018 QB's and a solid defender from this years draft like Rueben Foster.

That would be one option. We should aim imo to pick up one of the qb's this year as well, maybe in the 2nd.
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
So is it going to be better off trading the #2 pick for a first next year and move down this year? Then would have 2 1st round picks to get one of the 2018 QB's and a solid defender from this years draft like Rueben Foster.

Might be...and every year certain QB's are touted, taken and don't pan out, while others less agreed upon as franchise QB's like Carr come out of nowhere. We have to draft a QB soon. If there is one there that looks solid you have to take him and then do everything to bring him along. Next year might look better but each year seems to shift, change and evolve. It's almost impossible to predict.
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
So is it going to be better off trading the #2 pick for a first next year and move down this year? Then would have 2 1st round picks to get one of the 2018 QB's and a solid defender from this years draft like Rueben Foster.

First of all you'd need a partner to make that deal...we may like to do that but doesn't mean someone else is willing to make a Rams/Eagles like trade.

I think a lot will depend on what happens with Cleveland...and we're assuming we maintain the #2 overall pick(not a sure thing since we're playing Chicago and Jets)

If we're assuming it goes that way then yes i think given what we know about this draft class i'd rather see us trade down to say 15 while picking up a 1st next year(perhaps another 2nd rounder this year as well, that Eagles trade was crazy) then grab an impact defender and hopefully Luke Falk in the 2nd round and use the other picks to add talent on both sides of the field. Let Falk sit a year and learn then have a lot of options in 2018.
I like Trubisky and falk so far. not really a fan of anyone else. hoping they declare and we can get one of them in the 2nd or 3d
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I like Trubisky and falk so far. not really a fan of anyone else. hoping they declare and we can get one of them in the 2nd or 3d

yep
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I like Trubisky and Falk so far. not really a fan of anyone else. hoping they declare and we can get one of them in the 2nd or 3d
I'm on the same boat for now. If I have to choose between Trubisky at top 5 or Falk at bottom of first, I'll take Falk for value if the 2 are fairly close talent wise. An impact defender at the top or a trade down like some of you have suggested, then select Falk is something I agree with as well.
Originally posted by frankieuc68:
I'm on the same boat for now. If I have to choose between Trubisky at top 5 or Falk at bottom of first, I'll take Falk for value if the 2 are fairly close talent wise. An impact defender at the top or a trade down like some of you have suggested, then select Falk is something I agree with as well.

The only way this makes any sense is if you think they're about the same caliber prospect. If one is better, you take him 1st overall if you can.

I think they're about the same at this point, so I'm all for your strategy. I want Myles.
[ Edited by NinerSickness on Nov 13, 2016 at 11:23 PM ]
People are all hoping we lose out to ensure we get one of the top QBs. The only thing losing out gets us is a chance at Myles Garrett. Outside of that, we can win 4 games and still have a shot at a top QB. The 4 best players in this draft are Garrett, Fournette, Allen and Peppers. That means we can realistically drop to 5 and STILL get a QB or one of the top 4 players in this draft. We nor our GM will be able to mess this up unless we win out and that ain't happening. We will add one of the following players:

Garrett
Fournette
Allen
Peppers
Trubisky
Watson
Kizer

I'll take any of them
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
People are all hoping we lose out to ensure we get one of the top QBs. The only thing losing out gets us is a chance at Myles Garrett. Outside of that, we can win 4 games and still have a shot at a top QB. The 4 best players in this draft are Garrett, Fournette, Allen and Peppers. That means we can realistically drop to 5 and STILL get a QB or one of the top 4 players in this draft. We nor our GM will be able to mess this up unless we win out and that ain't happening. We will add one of the following players:

Garrett
Fournette
Allen
Peppers
Trubisky
Watson
Kizer

I'll take any of them

I think anyone banking on a QB not being taken #1 and probably #2 are fooling themselves. You can have everything else, but if you have mediocre or worse play at QB it doesn't matter what else you have.....

I guess I could see the Browns passing on a QB 1st, but only because they have another pick in the 1st.
[ Edited by WINiner on Nov 14, 2016 at 4:13 PM ]
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
People are all hoping we lose out to ensure we get one of the top QBs. The only thing losing out gets us is a chance at Myles Garrett. Outside of that, we can win 4 games and still have a shot at a top QB. The 4 best players in this draft are Garrett, Fournette, Allen and Peppers. That means we can realistically drop to 5 and STILL get a QB or one of the top 4 players in this draft. We nor our GM will be able to mess this up unless we win out and that ain't happening. We will add one of the following players:

Garrett
Fournette
Allen
Peppers
Trubisky
Watson
Kizer

I'll take any of them

I would too, but I'd be much happier with Garrett than Fournette, Allen, or Peppers because I think he's the BPA, pass rusher is a more valuable position than RB and S, and he fills a bigger need than those guys. Fournette would push Hyde to a #2 RB, Peppers would ensure Tartt never starts (not that Tartt is good anyways), and Allen would either make Armstead a rotational player or force us to switch to a 4-3.

I'm not completely sold on any of the QB's, but it would be nice for our front office to have their pick of QB's if that's the direction they decide to go. Don't sleep on picking earlier in every subsequent round even if we end up with a solid player in the first round - picking #2 overall could net us a good QB with our 2nd round pick or make it easier to trade back up into the first.
Originally posted by WINiner:
I think anyone banking on a QB not being taken #1 and probably #2 are fooling themselves. You can have everything else, but if you have mediocre or worse play at QB it doesn't matter what else you have.....

I guess I could see the Browns passing on a QB 1st, but only because they have another pick in the 1st.

Browns have a ton of OLBs to include their new addition Jamie Collins. They could certainly pass on Garrett at #1 and go with Fournette, Allen, Peppers or a QB
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,400
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
Originally posted by WINiner:
I think anyone banking on a QB not being taken #1 and probably #2 are fooling themselves. You can have everything else, but if you have mediocre or worse play at QB it doesn't matter what else you have.....

I guess I could see the Browns passing on a QB 1st, but only because they have another pick in the 1st.

Browns have a ton of OLBs to include their new addition Jamie Collins. They could certainly pass on Garrett at #1 and go with Fournette, Allen, Peppers or a QB

Hey, I would not be surprised if the Browns would feel like they finally found a RB in L4.. He's that good and I would not hesitate..

and if this happens, then I expect a lot of teams to start dialing 4949 and ask if we would consider drafting between 6 to 12..
  • GEEK
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 19,435
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
Originally posted by WINiner:
I think anyone banking on a QB not being taken #1 and probably #2 are fooling themselves. You can have everything else, but if you have mediocre or worse play at QB it doesn't matter what else you have.....

I guess I could see the Browns passing on a QB 1st, but only because they have another pick in the 1st.

Browns have a ton of OLBs to include their new addition Jamie Collins. They could certainly pass on Garrett at #1 and go with Fournette, Allen, Peppers or a QB

Actually, Collins could flex inside to ILB. He may actually be a better fit there.

They moved Ogbah to DE in their 3-4. Looks like he's doing the reverse of Carradine. They can't go wrong with either Allen or Garrett, and I think Garrett would be the pick.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone