Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Alright, finished reviewing and ranking about 25 QBs. How I have them broken down right now:
Top 10 Pick Worthy
None as of now
First Round
1. Patrick Mahomes*, Texas Tech - The physical tools a GM dreams of
2. Deshaun Watson*, Clemson - A ton of things to like but one red flag to scare you, hasn't shown the ability to go through progressions or read defensive coverage.
3. Mitch Tribusky*, North Carolina - A well rounded prospect that does many things well, but nothing great. Needs to clean up his mechanics.
Second-Third Round 4. Luke Falk*, Wash St - It would not be a surprise if he finds his way into the 1st. His best strength is has ability to make a wide variety of throws. Biggest concern is the offensive system he comes from.
5. Greg Ward Jr., Houston - Note: I didn't see his last game. Biggest concern is he is very undersized and raw. But he may have the best deep ball throw in the draft. I see him as a late 3rd or early 4th round pick
Fourth-Fifth Round
6. Baker Mayfield*, Oklahoma - Love the arm and accuracy, hate the release and feet.
7. Davis Webb, Cal - Good arm and accuracy, from an air raid offense. A rhythm QB that is fortunate that Hanson has made some Sports Center grabs.
6th-7th Round
8. Chad Kelly, Ole Miss - Probably a good chance he ends up in the 5th. But when watching him play it really amazing he doesn't have 15 picks on the year. The WR group in Ole Miss is impressive and won a lot of contested throws.
8. J.T. Barrett*, Ohio State - Needs to clean up his mechanics and improve accuracy on mid-range throws, but a lot to keep an eye on. Should stay another year.
9. DeShone Kizer*, Notre Dame - Most puzzling love for any QB prospect. He has ideal size and a great arm. But his ball placement and decision making are scary bad. I can certainly understand him getting benched. Should stay another year as he has the tools to shoot up the draft board.
10. Brad Kaaya*, Miami - Another prospect I'm a bit puzzled by people liking. The only positives I have is he takes snaps under center, is tall, and a quick decision maker. He is also 75lbs and one hit from dying, and rarely makes an NFL quality throw.
11. Nathan Peterman, Pittsburgh - Quick release, strong arm, great ball placement. But its hard to really judge him in the offense he is in. He looks to me like an ideal game manager at the next level.
UDFA Waivers to keep in mind: Logan Woodside, Toledo. Ryan Higgins, LA Tech. Zach Terrell, Western Michigan.
To be reviewed: Cooper Rush, Central Michigan. C.J. Beathard, Iowa. Seth Russell, Baylor.
Originally posted by ninerAxe:
He likely won't declare
Would be a mistake for Falk. I don't think staying another year will help him and will only put him in jeopardy of injury. Problem for a pocket passer in an air-raid is there is little protection, if the ball isn't out fast you are getting hit. I think he has 2 concussions already?
Falk walked that back yesterday but realistically, what else is he supposed to say? "I can't wait to get the f**k out of here!" They still have some big games left to play.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Falk walked that back yesterday but realistically, what else is he supposed to say? "I can't wait to get the f**k out of here!" They still have some big games left to play.
Yeah i don't take anything guys have to say about declaring this early on unless of course they say they're declaring(who the hell does that mid season though)
Caught the tail end of a weekly interview that Tolbert and Lund of KNBR did this afternoon regarding college match ups this weekend. Sorry didn't catch the guest's name. Anyway as they were going some of the matchups, John Lund curiously asked him who are his top QB prospects for the upcoming draft. The interviewee basically said he talked to Gilbert Brandt about the QB prospects and the top 3 QB in their eyes are: Trubisky, Kizer and Falk. Falk is making some noise and Davis Webb is intriguing. What about Watson asked Lund. The guy said the rumblings around the NFL teams is Watson is plummeting big time. Like I said I wasn't able to catch the guest's name and I just want to share what I heard today.
Originally posted by frankieuc68:
Caught the tail end of a weekly interview that Tolbert and Lund of KNBR did this afternoon regarding college match ups this weekend. Sorry didn't catch the guest's name. Anyway as they were going some of the matchups, John Lund curiously asked him who are his top QB prospects for the upcoming draft. The interviewee basically said he talked to Gilbert Brandt about the QB prospects and the top 3 QB in their eyes are: Trubisky, Kizer and Falk. Falk is making some noise and Davis Webb is intriguing. What about Watson asked Lund. The guy said the rumblings around the NFL teams is Watson is plummeting big time. Like I said I wasn't able to catch the guest's name and I just want to share what I heard today.
Watson's play this season hasn't been bad but it's been very concerning as far as his draft prospect status goes IMO.
I wouldn't be devastated if we drafted him but I'd much rather we avoid him and go with someone else. You don't want to see a guy regressing while still in college.
I will be surprised if Trubisky goes back to school if he continues his rise going to the draft. He may very well be a top 3 pick and the first QB taken when all said and done. Factor in what some of you guys had already mentioned, he will lose a few teammates next year and also a better QB class next year. Look what happened to Watson. Even though it's completely different circumstances,he regressed from last year to this year.When Trubisky is the hottest draft eligible QB name right now, he should declare. Like many of you, I will be shocked if he doesn't.
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
This is not a strong draft class considering Qbs but its not the weakeast.
Trubinsky will probably stay in school.
The best QBs in this class are Falk, Kelly and Webb(underrated).
Wild cards are Beathard, Kiel(back to starting job) and Rush.
I'm not buying on Watson, Kaaya nor Kizer
Kaaya needs to stay in school. I'm hoping Trubisky comes out as he has a very good shot at being the 1st QB off the board. I agree that it's not the strongest class but being at the top of each round will certainly give us the luxury of having very good options round 1-3, the most important rounds for that position. We will be in position to slide up to the bottom of the 1st and/or 2nd if we choose to so Watson, Kizer, Trubisky (if he declares), Falk, Kelly and Mahomes (if he declares) will all be in play for us at some point. More than enough options, IMO
This is not a strong draft class considering Qbs but its not the weakeast.
Trubinsky will probably stay in school.
Trubinsky might stay in school but Mitch Trubisky likely comes out considering he will be losing his RBs, almost all his WRs, most of his OL and potentially his head coach after the season.
What reason does he stick around, this next draft gives him the best shot at being a top pick.