Grade the 49ers 2010 Draft [3 years later]

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Maybe this helps Amp...

1. Anthony Davis-A
1. Mike Iupati-A
2. Taylor Mays-F
3. Navorro Bowman-A
6. Anthony Dixon-C+
6. Nate Byham-C-
6. Kyle William-B
7. Phillip Adam-C-

Ted Ginn acquisition-B+

comes out to a 2.67........B-

Except it doesn't work like that. What you're essentially saying is missing on Taylor Mays hurts the team as much as Bowman helps the team, so their net value is 0, which is a ridiculous position to take. The value of the 3 players outweighs anything else done. Think of it like this; if we only had 3 draft picks and got the big 3, it would've been a good draft. Drafting the other players didn't "hurt" the team at all, it just didn't necessarily help us. Those players were just dropped or retained as depth.

Originally posted by cindy8559:

Originally posted by Disp:

Originally posted by jreff22:
Maybe this helps Amp...

1. Anthony Davis-A
1. Mike Iupati-A
2. Taylor Mays-F
3. Navorro Bowman-A
6. Anthony Dixon-C+
6. Nate Byham-C-
6. Kyle William-B
7. Phillip Adam-C-

Ted Ginn acquisition-B+

comes out to a 2.67........B-

Except it doesn't work like that. What you're essentially saying is missing on Taylor Mays hurts the team as much as Bowman helps the team, so their net value is 0, which is a ridiculous position to take. The value of the 3 players outweighs anything else done. Think of it like this; if we only had 3 draft picks and got the big 3, it would've been a good draft. Drafting the other players didn't "hurt" the team at all, it just didn't necessarily help us. Those players were just dropped or retained as depth.

should have at least gpa calculator 3.0. :(

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
Still wouldn't apply. If you get three good starters out of a draft, it's a solid draft. If any GM did that every year, they'd stay employed. Anything more makes a good draft, whether its other players or players earning accolades like All-Pro, outright voted to a Pro-Bowl, being a top-5 or -10 player at their position, etc.

Originally posted by phatbutskinny:
Like they say, give it 3 years and then you can really grade a draft

1. Anthony Davis
1. Mike Iupati
2. Taylor Mays
3. Navorro Bowman
6. Anthony Dixon
6. Nate Byham
6. Kyle Williams
7. Phillip Adams

I'd definitely say this was a solid draft. Shored up our Oline, got another great ILB and depth at RB & WR.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
That was an excellent draft. We actually picked offensive linemen then too. Very good ones also. I wish we would draft like that again.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
That was an excellent draft. We actually picked offensive linemen then too. Very good ones also. I wish we would draft like that again.

Neither of those guys pass blocked well. Iupati was particularly bad at it.