Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 255 users in the forums

49ers Need to Add a Center!

Originally posted by Alfienator:
Doesn't Shanahan like his Center to be a seasoned vet and not a rookie?

History would say yes since from what others have said is the center makes all the line calls.
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
Originally posted by Alfienator:
Doesn't Shanahan like his Center to be a seasoned vet and not a rookie?

Yep, this is what we've deduced based on the financial investments he's made at the position, the lack of draft investments at the position, and the responsibility he puts on the center in his offense(ie all the calls).

Alex Mack would be a big pickup even if it's just for a season or two.
[ Edited by Heroism on Feb 5, 2021 at 8:31 PM ]
Mack should come here if he wants to win a SB bc we definitely can at least get there with a healthier team and he will help to that end. 2 years 14 mil sounds like a good compromise
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by Alfienator:
Doesn't Shanahan like his Center to be a seasoned vet and not a rookie?

Yep, this is what we've deduced based on the financial investments he's made at the position, the lack of draft investments at the position, and the responsibility he puts on the center in his offense(ie all the calls).

Alex Mack would be a big pickup even if it's just for a season or two.

As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.

Can still draft Meinerz even if we sign Mack no?
Originally posted by Waterbear:
As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.

They can still draft a center and sit 'em behind Mack or play them at right guard.

Kyle has never started a rookie center at any stop. Not in WAS, ATL, CLE or SF.
[ Edited by Heroism on Feb 5, 2021 at 9:16 PM ]
Originally posted by 49ers808:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.

Can still draft Meinerz even if we sign Mack no?

We can sign a Center and draft one that plays C/G in the meantime. Mack knows the system and is still a top 10 C. That's all we need, especially against a team like the Chiefs when we had a backup who had trouble with Jones.
Originally posted by elguapo:
Originally posted by 49ers808:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.

Can still draft Meinerz even if we sign Mack no?

We can sign a Center and draft one that plays C/G in the meantime. Mack knows the system and is still a top 10 C. That's all we need, especially against a team like the Chiefs when we had a backup who had trouble with Jones.

I guess it depends on what Mack wants. If it's reasonable I'm totally fine with it as long as we take advantage of the draft too.

i just think we really need to take advantage of this years interior class like we did last year for the stacked WR group.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by elguapo:
Originally posted by 49ers808:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.

Can still draft Meinerz even if we sign Mack no?

We can sign a Center and draft one that plays C/G in the meantime. Mack knows the system and is still a top 10 C. That's all we need, especially against a team like the Chiefs when we had a backup who had trouble with Jones.

I guess it depends on what Mack wants. If it's reasonable I'm totally fine with it as long as we take advantage of the draft too.

i just think we really need to take advantage of this years interior class like we did last year for the stacked WR group.

I concur. We haven't had good interior pass pro since Jeff Garcia
Alex Mack and Trey Hill, are we go from the weakness on the team to a strength.
I've heard you guys talk about Alex Mack even before the article came out recently talking about him fitting in well on the 49ers. What would his cost be? How many years?

Also, someone even brought up moving Richburg to RG. Would he fit there? I like the idea of shoring up the line with vets in order for any draft picks to sit and learn a bit.
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,284
Originally posted by InfiniteEight:
I've heard you guys talk about Alex Mack even before the article came out recently talking about him fitting in well on the 49ers. What would his cost be? How many years?

Also, someone even brought up moving Richburg to RG. Would he fit there? I like the idea of shoring up the line with vets in order for any draft picks to sit and learn a bit.

I'd love to bring in Mack. Everything he said in that interview suggests he'd like to be in SF if the offer was adequate.

What's sucks is I don't think Richburg's contract is easy to get rid of in 2021 and I have doubts Richburg can hold up at RG.
Originally posted by thl408:
I'd love to bring in Mack. Everything he said in that interview suggests he'd like to be in SF if the offer was adequate.

What's sucks is I don't think Richburg's contract is easy to get rid of in 2021 and I have doubts Richburg can hold up at RG.

They can cut him after June 1st and save around $8 mil while taking about a $3 million hit.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by Heroism:
Originally posted by Alfienator:
Doesn't Shanahan like his Center to be a seasoned vet and not a rookie?

Yep, this is what we've deduced based on the financial investments he's made at the position, the lack of draft investments at the position, and the responsibility he puts on the center in his offense(ie all the calls).

Alex Mack would be a big pickup even if it's just for a season or two.

As much as I like Mack... this is not the center class I would sign an aging FA with one or two years left. We will look back and realize we passed up on some very good prospects like Meinerz who I think can be a cornerstone on our offense for years.

I look at FA to fill in the roster not build it.

When "BPA" matches "position of need" you don't need to spend money on veterans.

They should do both. Take a year or two to develop the rookie and actually have some center depth for once.
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,284
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by thl408:
I'd love to bring in Mack. Everything he said in that interview suggests he'd like to be in SF if the offer was adequate.

What's sucks is I don't think Richburg's contract is easy to get rid of in 2021 and I have doubts Richburg can hold up at RG.

They can cut him after June 1st and save around $8 mil while taking about a $3 million hit.

See ya, Richburg. Bring in Mack, draft a C to develop and take over in 2022/23.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone