Free agent QB or rookie? what are our choices?

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:

Originally posted by TheNef77:
DO NOT waste the #7 pick on the QB's in this years draft. (They all are 2nd round talent at best)
DO NOT pickup Palmer (No loyalty = no respect)
DO NOT resign Alex Smith (No accuracy 10+ yards)

1) McNabb and develop 3nd pick or Josh Johnson (Trade)
2) Trade for Kolb
3) Hasselbeck and develop 3rd pick or Josh Johnson (Trade)


Sleepers
1) Seneca Wallace FA
2) Kapernick 4th round
3) Caleb Hanie FA
4) Colt Brennan FA

alex has great accuracy from 10+ yards its his 10- yards thats the problem lol

anyway i dont want kolb (unless its for a 3rd or something) his numbers are not much better than smith and he had a better coaching stability and better weapons

Are you kidding? Alex was Capt. Checkdown. If he wasn't throwing to Gore, he mostly wasn't completing a pass down field.

Originally posted by TheNef77:

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:

Originally posted by TheNef77:
DO NOT waste the #7 pick on the QB's in this years draft. (They all are 2nd round talent at best)
DO NOT pickup Palmer (No loyalty = no respect)
DO NOT resign Alex Smith (No accuracy 10+ yards)

1) McNabb and develop 3nd pick or Josh Johnson (Trade)
2) Trade for Kolb
3) Hasselbeck and develop 3rd pick or Josh Johnson (Trade)


Sleepers
1) Seneca Wallace FA
2) Kapernick 4th round
3) Caleb Hanie FA
4) Colt Brennan FA

alex has great accuracy from 10+ yards its his 10- yards thats the problem lol

anyway i dont want kolb (unless its for a 3rd or something) his numbers are not much better than smith and he had a better coaching stability and better weapons

Are you kidding? Alex was Capt. Checkdown. If he wasn't throwing to Gore, he mostly wasn't completing a pass down field.

he did throw the ball less than 10 yards a lot but he is most accuarte from the 10-20 yard throws

if u dont see that im not sure ur watching the games look at his passes to vernon davis and morgan he may not throw downfield a lot but when hes does hes pretty accurate

I have a feeling the #2 will be free agent Seneca Wallace

He can start and win games if needed.
Many years of WCO experience,
If the CBA causes a short window of free agency, He should be able to learn the system quickly,
His Mom lives in Sac, Ive read he wants to be closer to family

#3, the Rookie
Undecided, maybe even pass on drafting a QB, and pick up a #3 like Stanton
Get your "Rookie" in 2012 (A.Luck, R.Lindley, Landry Jones among others)

Side note- If Gabbert is there at 7, Washington may want to trade up infront of Tenn to get him, Niners could use an extra pick in 2012 to have some bargaining power to move up and get the QB they want

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:

Originally posted by TheNef77:

Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:

Originally posted by TheNef77:
DO NOT waste the #7 pick on the QB's in this years draft. (They all are 2nd round talent at best)
DO NOT pickup Palmer (No loyalty = no respect)
DO NOT resign Alex Smith (No accuracy 10+ yards)

1) McNabb and develop 3nd pick or Josh Johnson (Trade)
2) Trade for Kolb
3) Hasselbeck and develop 3rd pick or Josh Johnson (Trade)


Sleepers
1) Seneca Wallace FA
2) Kapernick 4th round
3) Caleb Hanie FA
4) Colt Brennan FA

alex has great accuracy from 10+ yards its his 10- yards thats the problem lol

anyway i dont want kolb (unless its for a 3rd or something) his numbers are not much better than smith and he had a better coaching stability and better weapons

Are you kidding? Alex was Capt. Checkdown. If he wasn't throwing to Gore, he mostly wasn't completing a pass down field.

he did throw the ball less than 10 yards a lot but he is most accuarte from the 10-20 yard throws

if u dont see that im not sure ur watching the games look at his passes to vernon davis and morgan he may not throw downfield a lot but when hes does hes pretty accurate

Okay, the post down the middle to VD, yeah he hit's that. Not on a regular basis though. The Morgan throws, please JM has to make crazy catches because those throws are so bad. Open your eyes, Smith isn't accurate past 10 yards. Sure he'll complete 1-3 10+ passes a game but that's like giving credit to a retarded 8th grader for saying his ABC's.