Redskins release QB Colt Brennan

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

cut NATE Davis



































jk

im slightly shocked, i thought he had potential.

i thought he was going to be the next joe montaniaaaa

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

I know your argument and I think I've debated that with you over and over back in 2008. I thinks that's why I never replied to your first post. So I'mma break it down quick style for you:

Sugar Bowl - No O-line, or O-line was getting beat like a step child, not to mention Hawaii's defense was over-whelmed by Georgia's O and Knowshon Morena.


Senior Bowl - From what I recall, fared well in practices, but looked anything but spectacular in the game. Given only a week to learn a new offense, not to mention Martz' reworked his mechanics.

Now apply that to Alex Smith and I bet you, you see a totally different situation where its the receivers fault, defense and very little chemistry with the offense.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

I know your argument and I think I've debated that with you over and over back in 2008. I thinks that's why I never replied to your first post. So I'mma break it down quick style for you:

Sugar Bowl - No O-line, or O-line was getting beat like a step child, not to mention Hawaii's defense was over-whelmed by Georgia's O and Knowshon Morena.


Senior Bowl - From what I recall, fared well in practices, but looked anything but spectacular in the game. Given only a week to learn a new offense, not to mention Martz' reworked his mechanics.

Now apply that to Alex Smith and I bet you, you see a totally different situation where its the receivers fault, defense and very little chemistry with the offense.

I will give blame where it is due. The big issue at the Senior Bowl was strength, he didn't have it taking snaps from under center. And regarding his mechanics they sucked from the get go, that sidearm crap was bad. Yes some guys can do it but they do it with power, Brennan didn't have it.

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

I know your argument and I think I've debated that with you over and over back in 2008. I thinks that's why I never replied to your first post. So I'mma break it down quick style for you:

Sugar Bowl - No O-line, or O-line was getting beat like a step child, not to mention Hawaii's defense was over-whelmed by Georgia's O and Knowshon Morena.


Senior Bowl - From what I recall, fared well in practices, but looked anything but spectacular in the game. Given only a week to learn a new offense, not to mention Martz' reworked his mechanics.

Now apply that to Alex Smith and I bet you, you see a totally different situation where its the receivers fault, defense and very little chemistry with the offense.

I will give blame where it is due. The big issue at the Senior Bowl was strength, he didn't have it taking snaps from under center. And regarding his mechanics they sucked from the get go, that sidearm crap was bad. Yes some guys can do it but they do it with power, Brennan didn't have it.

If you dont remember he did have the flu before that I believe where he lost a ton of weight, he has the strength I have seen it in college and in his preseason games.

And to criticize him about the Georgia game isnt fair at all, he was killed had zero time.

I think someone will pick him up.

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

I know your argument and I think I've debated that with you over and over back in 2008. I thinks that's why I never replied to your first post. So I'mma break it down quick style for you:

Sugar Bowl - No O-line, or O-line was getting beat like a step child, not to mention Hawaii's defense was over-whelmed by Georgia's O and Knowshon Morena.


Senior Bowl - From what I recall, fared well in practices, but looked anything but spectacular in the game. Given only a week to learn a new offense, not to mention Martz' reworked his mechanics.

Now apply that to Alex Smith and I bet you, you see a totally different situation where its the receivers fault, defense and very little chemistry with the offense.

I will give blame where it is due. The big issue at the Senior Bowl was strength, he didn't have it taking snaps from under center. And regarding his mechanics they sucked from the get go, that sidearm crap was bad. Yes some guys can do it but they do it with power, Brennan didn't have it.

Now this is with a full off-season:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

I know your argument and I think I've debated that with you over and over back in 2008. I thinks that's why I never replied to your first post. So I'mma break it down quick style for you:

Sugar Bowl - No O-line, or O-line was getting beat like a step child, not to mention Hawaii's defense was over-whelmed by Georgia's O and Knowshon Morena.


Senior Bowl - From what I recall, fared well in practices, but looked anything but spectacular in the game. Given only a week to learn a new offense, not to mention Martz' reworked his mechanics.

Now apply that to Alex Smith and I bet you, you see a totally different situation where its the receivers fault, defense and very little chemistry with the offense.

I will give blame where it is due. The big issue at the Senior Bowl was strength, he didn't have it taking snaps from under center. And regarding his mechanics they sucked from the get go, that sidearm crap was bad. Yes some guys can do it but they do it with power, Brennan didn't have it.

Now this is with a full off-season:

Were any of the actual starters playing in that game by the time he went in....?

Originally posted by jreff22:
I called that kid garbage at the Senior Bowl and got flack for it.....guess I was right.

Join da club.. I always have to remind our "resident experts" how right I was.

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by BobS:
When Brennan finally played a real team and was made to look like crap against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl, it was obvious he was nothing more than a big fish in a small pond, and didn't have much of a future. Time to try the CFL and then the AFL for him him.

So if its OK to play with a s**tty offensive line than Alex Smith should have no excuses from the start. Obviously you really didn't watch the Sugar Bowl, did you??

Brennan's Preseason in his rookie year>>>>>>>>Alex Smith's rookie year Preseason.

Do I sense a Hawaii homer

Yes sir, but am I wrong???

I never liked Brennan at all, he played in a VERY gimmicky offense. I wasn't impressed when he played against GA but when I could really watch him at the Senior Bowl it was obvious....he wasn't that good. To be honest the level of competition he faced in college was low.

I know your argument and I think I've debated that with you over and over back in 2008. I thinks that's why I never replied to your first post. So I'mma break it down quick style for you:

Sugar Bowl - No O-line, or O-line was getting beat like a step child, not to mention Hawaii's defense was over-whelmed by Georgia's O and Knowshon Morena.


Senior Bowl - From what I recall, fared well in practices, but looked anything but spectacular in the game. Given only a week to learn a new offense, not to mention Martz' reworked his mechanics.

Now apply that to Alex Smith and I bet you, you see a totally different situation where its the receivers fault, defense and very little chemistry with the offense.

I will give blame where it is due. The big issue at the Senior Bowl was strength, he didn't have it taking snaps from under center. And regarding his mechanics they sucked from the get go, that sidearm crap was bad. Yes some guys can do it but they do it with power, Brennan didn't have it.

Now this is with a full off-season:

Were any of the actual starters playing in that game by the time he went in....?

What difference does that make, he was a 3rd stringer going into the game. And the talent of the Colts 2nd and 3rd stringers is far better than what he played against in the Sugar Bowl. Which was the point I was trying to make, given a full offseason and equal talent, he can play.

Originally posted by toppdogg32:

Originally posted by jreff22:
I called that kid garbage at the Senior Bowl and got flack for it.....guess I was right.

Join da club.. I always have to remind our "resident experts" how right I was.

So quick to call players trash, when they haven't even played a regular season game yet. Than by your logic, Phillip Rivers should be a "bust" and even Alex Smith.