Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Cary Edmondson-USA TODAY Sports

Four 49ers youngsters who could thrive in their new starting roles

Jun 22, 2015 at 11:47 AM8

The San Francisco 49ers' OTAs and the team's mandatory minicamp are well in the books. Training camp looms and - along with preseason - will be the final barometer for coaches to determine team roles on offense and defense prior to the start of the regular season.

The 49ers had a number of losses during the offseason. We've already heard about all of the retirements and free agent losses, which have led the media to predict nearly certain doom for San Francisco's 2015 campaign. Whether they are correct or not is yet to be determined. Sealing the team's fate before even one snap has taken place is a bit premature.

There have indeed been losses to the team, which has forced others into starting roles. The most interesting of those players are those that have never been full-time starters before. They will suddenly become "the guy" at their position and how they perform could make or break the 49ers' season. While this is a tough task for any player, it is an even tougher task for players that don't have a good deal of experience within the league.

Let's take a look at four such players who, barring injury, have the best chances to thrive in their new situations.

Running back Carlos Hyde, who is entering his second year after being selected in the round two of the 2014 NFL Draft, will be taking over the starting role once held by the team's all-time rushing leader, Frank Gore. Much to the dismay of many fans, Gore signed with the Indianapolis Colts as a free agent. This may be the most obvious choice on this list because Hyde has the most playing experience. He was thrust into the backup role in 2014 after Gore's scheduled backup, Kendall Hunter, missed the season with an ACL injury.

For the fourth straight season, Gore had surpassed 1,000 yards rushing. In fact, his 1,106 yards in 2014 was the eighth time in nine years that Gore had surpassed the millennium mark. Last season, he accounted for over 72% of the team's carries by running backs. Hyde accounted for only about 24% so to compare their numbers really isn't fair. What's to say that had Hyde contributed more, that his numbers might have exceeded Gore's? Of course, what's to say that they wouldn't have? We are certainly going to find out this season, but even that comparison will be like apples and oranges due to the amount of change that has taken place.

During his 83 carries in 2014, Hyde averaged exactly 4 yards per rushing attempt in relief of Gore. Gore averaged 4.3. Similar numbers, yet very different runners. The team was frequently using Gore in the middle and restricting his runs to the outside. Hyde on the other hand, proved to be effective in both areas.

Hyde averaged over 9 yards per carry in the team's second matchup against the Seahawks. Although, a 28 yard scamper, his longest run of the season, contributed to much of that inflated number. On the other hand, the Seahawks, who finished the season with the third best run defense in the league, were not known for giving up such long runs. However, in games where Hyde was handed the ball at least 10 times, he averaged only 2.7 yards per carry.

The positive for Hyde is that he will have some help. Kendall Hunter has averaged 4.6 yards per carry throughout his career. In 2012, he averaged 5.2 in 72 attempts. Competing behind him are former USC star Reggie Bush and Australian rugby star turned football player Jarryd Hayne. The team also drafted Mike Davis out of South Carolina in May. Whatever the final roster looks like, putting in some relief for Hyde should not be an issue.

When the 49ers kick off against the Minnesota Vikings on September 14, Hyde will be the starter for the team. One problem for Hyde is that he will be running behind an offensive line that has lost guard Mike Iupati, who signed as a free agent with the Arizona Cardinals, and tackle Anthony Davis, who abruptly retired. While both had their issues in pass protection, they were instrumental in the running game. For example, in the seven games that Davis played in 2014, the 49ers offense averaged 173 rushing yards per game. In the nine games that he missed, they averaged just 107 yards per game.

When Iupati left for NFC West rival Arizona, Brandon Thomas was the natural choice to succeed him. Preparing for Iupati's departure was complete when the 49ers selected the massive Clemson guard in the third-round of the 2014 NFL Draft. Formerly rated by many as a first-round caliber, Thomas was considered a bargain when his stock fell due to an ACL injury that occurred prior to the draft. He was not going to make an immediate impact for anyone, but if a team like the 49ers, who didn't have a pressing need at guard could hold onto him until he recovered, it was believed that he had the potential to solidify the position.

The 49ers were making a habit of selecting injured players in the draft that the team would stash for a year, allowing them to learn and recover. They could do this because of the depth they had at the time. Even now, when depth has become a larger concern, general manager Trent Baalke continued the practice with his selection of wide receiver DeAndre Smelter, who joins their All-ACL team. He, like Thomas, has the potential to be an eventual starter. The gamble did not work on running back Marcus Lattimore, who never fully recovered and retired, but the 49ers hope Thomas' situation is different.

Thomas is not an Iupati clone. Despite his massive size, he is considered to be very athletic, has quick feet, and uses those attributes to win positioning against defenders rather than simply using brute strength to shove them around. This could be a huge asset to anyone running behind him - like Carlos Hyde.

The other key advantage that Thomas has over Iupati is his ability to pass block. Playing some tackle in college gave him the experience needed to learn to move with defenders and keep them from the quarterback. His long arm reach, a trait that has become popular with Baalke selections, will be an additional asset when he attempts to shift defenders' directions and recover if needed.

All of this is assuming that the 49ers don't bring in a free agent to compete along the offensive line. That scenario would give the team more personnel options as they attempt to better protect quarterback Colin Kaepernick and continue to open holes for the running backs. He is definitely someone to be excited about and could shock a number of team critics with his ability to step right in and take over.

Let's shift over to the defensive side of the ball, where defensive end Tank Carradine hopes to be primed to make an impact along the line. Like Hyde, Carradine does have some actual NFL game experience. After spending 2013 fully recovering from an ACL injury that he suffered at Florida State, he appeared in nine games in 2014 where he had 17 tackles and three sacks. The three sacks came within the final three games of the season, which included two against the Seattle Seahawks. With last year's departure of Ray McDonald and this offseason's retirement of Justin Smith, the 2013 second-round selection will look to book-end the line with free agent acquisition Darnell Dockett.

It wasn't until the loss of McDonald that Carradine started to see more playing time in 2014. A lot of that was his self-admitted inability to master the playbook. While some have criticized his play, his explosiveness at the line during the end of the season made others believe that he could be a solid pass rusher in the future.

Of course, it is possible that the team could see Carradine and Dockett as players to bring in on passing downs, and allow them to split time with others like Quinton Dial and Glenn Dorsey. Especially if Dockett, who missed all of last season due to an ACL tear, misses significant practice time prior to the start of the season. He has yet to practice with the 49ers. Dial impressed during minicamp and played with the first-team. He looks primed to move to end after filling in at tackle last season. Dorsey may play at end as well because Ian Williams is penciled to start at nose tackle for the team. It is a position that Dorsey is familiar with due to his time with the Kansas City Chiefs.

The defensive line will begin to take shape once training camp begins and better evaluations can be made. It should have some pretty interesting training camp battles. The team also spent their 2015 first-round selection on Arik Armstead, who also hasn't practiced with the team yet due to NFL rules regarding school obligations.

Last but not least is the team's fifth-round selection in this year's draft, Bradley Pinion, the punter out of Clemson. How much confidence does the team have in the rookie? Enough to ship the team's longest tenured player and Pro Bowler, punter Andy Lee, to the Cleveland Browns. They saw enough from Pinion during OTAs to consider the much older and more expensive Lee expendable.

The learning curve for Pinion will be less than any of the other youngsters on this list because ... well ... he's a punter.

He had a net punting average of 39.2 yards during his career at Clemson. Add to that the 55 punts inside the 20 with only two touchbacks and there is no reason to believe that he will not perform well for the 49ers. He will hopefully only get better with time.

The added bonus for the team is that Pinion has experience kicking field goals, which could be an asset if kicker Phil Dawson hits a slump or the need arises for an emergency kicker. He has bragged about a 65-yard field goal that he made while training for the draft. Impressive, although it was unlikely to have had the same pressure as the same feat in an actual game. He also considers himself to be a good kickoff specialist. Maybe Dawson should watch his back too.

Of course, there are other young players competing for spots that could surprise in 2015. One of which may be wide receiver DeAndrew White, an undrafted free agent out of Alabama who, if he continues to impress as he has during the offseason, may give Jerome Simpson some competition for the slot receiver spot. Perhaps it is a long shot, but he has yet to show any signs of slowing down and has proven to be one of the favorite quarterback targets during OTAs and minicamp.

Dontae Johnson, the 49ers' 6-2 and 200 pound cornerback, looks to compete for the starting spot opposite Tramaine Brock. Having recorded a 4.45 40 and a 38.5 inch vertical jump at the 2014 NFL Combine, he certainly has the size and athleticism to excel. Like Hyde, the 2014 fourth-round pick has some good experience already, having played in all 16 games last season and even starting three. Although, he had an abysmal showing in the team's week 17 matchup against the Cardinals. Baalke seems to have confidence in his young cornerbacks because he passed on addressing the position in this year's draft.
The opinions within this article are those of the writer and, while just as important, are not necessarily those of the site as a whole.


  • Marty
    49ers offense had to be totally frustrated in 2014. In 2013 Davis had 13 TDs & Gore had 9. In 2014 Davis had 2 & Gore had 4. Everyone talked about Gore's good season, rushing for over 11 hundred yards. But the 49ers offense could not score. It is bad having to play in Harbaugh's system. It was like a day off for most defenses when playing the 49ers. It was even worst because the offense was so obvious. After 4 seasons with the same offense defenses knew the plays & they knew 49ers did not use their play makers. It was impossible to watch those good players stuck in that idiotic system. And those dozen offensive coaches never tried to correct the problems. Everyone ? MacDonald. He had just 8 targets all year. The problems were not the players. It was Harbaugh's system. The 49ers will use their players talents. The offense should be able to pressure the defenses. This will help the defense even more. They will not be on the field as much & just maybe they will have leads to protect. Those were never Harbaugh's objectives.
    Jul 12, 2015 at 6:43 AM
  • Kyle WG
    I like Baalke's gambles on injured guys in the draft. It seems to go well with his way of stockpiling picks. So far, to my knowledge, he's 1-1 with these risks... Latimore retired & Carradine played well in limited time. Hopefully Thomas & Smelter turn out to be gems worth waiting for. But I like that approach & I'm glad that Baalke does it.
    Jul 1, 2015 at 1:36 PM
  • MauiMike
    Hyde will obviously be given every opportunity to win the starting job but I really want to see a healthy Kendall Hunter get some carries and some targets in the passing game. I think there is a lot of playmaking ability there. Very Darren Sproles like.
    Jun 23, 2015 at 1:54 PM
    Response: Hunter is one of my favorite underrated players on the team. It is funny how people forget about him because of all of the Hyde hype. If he returns to form, Hunter will be fantastic coming in to relieve Hyde.
  • Rob
    Really enjoy reading this article. "All-ACL team" :)
    Jun 23, 2015 at 8:04 AM
  • Marty
    As DL coach Tomsula stated he had no DL starters. Everyone knew all the position & were used equally. Dial & Tank played the whole pre season in 2014. They played sound football. How the forgot the playbook during the season is beyond me. It was just an excuse for Vic to play his guys. The old coaching staff was known to prefer vets. only. They care less about coaching up the young players. Only young players that got on the field was to replace & fill veteran position. Many of these young players are going to surprise people. Just to bad the old coaches were idiots. And maybe cost the players some SB rings.
    Jun 23, 2015 at 7:14 AM
  • BolivarTrask
    I dont think Tank will be starting. He may be inserted into subpackages, but he is not an every down DE. I think the youngsters who shine will be Reaser, Blake Bell, and the WR from Bama whose name escapes me at this moment.
    Jun 22, 2015 at 10:39 PM
    Response: The possibility of him being inserted on passing downs is mentioned in the article. Reaser and Bell won't start. White is also mentioned in the article as competition for the slot receiver spot. Thanks for the comment.
  • RishikeshA
    Thanks David, We've been waiting for Tank and this should be his time. Dockett and Tank could puts lots of pressure on opposing qb's. Pinion looks like a sure thing, he's the only punter drafted, and the 5th round at that. This team will play fast.
    Jun 22, 2015 at 10:02 PM
  • Tim
    Hyde already won the RB competition I guess. Don't tell Kendall Hunter who had a higher YPC and overall yardsin each of his first three years than Hyde did in his rookie season.
    Jun 22, 2015 at 7:57 PM
    Response: Hyde was drafted in the second-round last year to eventually replace Gore. He has proven that he deserves the job. While the team may say that it is a competition, I doubt many believe that the job isn't Hyde's to lose. Hunter, coming off of an ACL injury, will certainly push Hyde, but the real competition is likely for the guys behind him. The job became his to lose the second Gore signed his contract with the Colts. Thanks for the comment.

Facebook Comments

More San Francisco 49ers News

Tom Brady on Jimmy Garoppolo starting for 49ers: "You never know when that opportunity's gonna present itself"

By David Bonilla
Sep 20

Jimmy Garoppolo is the San Francisco 49ers' starting quarterback for the remainder of the season, barring unforeseen circumstances. Trey Lance underwent ankle surgery on Monday and will land on season-ending injured reserve. The situation is disappointing for Lance, who finally had an opportunity to gain a significant number of in-game reps, something he has lacked over the last couple of seasons. COVID protocols shortened his 2020 campaign at North Dakota State to one game. Lance started only two games last season as an NFL rookie, with a few plays sprinkled in here and there in other games. Lance's 2022 season ended in less than five full quarters. For Garoppolo, this is an opportunity to prove his worth. There was no trade market for the veteran

49ers QB Trey Lance could make full recovery within 10 to 12 weeks, says surgeon

By David Bonilla
Sep 20

Trey Lance will likely head to injured reserve soon. On Monday, the quarterback underwent what most assumed to be season-ending surgery to repair the damage suffered when he broke his ankle against the Seattle Seahawks in Week 2. On a conference call with reporters this week, head coach Kyle Shanahan sounded pretty confident that Lance would be ready to go for Week 1 of the 2023 season. One expert isn't so sure the injury is season-ending, though. Foot and ankle surgeon Dr. Kenneth Jung, a consultant to the Los Angeles Rams, believes Lance could be fully healed within 10 to 12 weeks. Assuming the lengthier estimated recovery time, that might make him available after Week 14. However, the shorter estimate could mean Lance is healthy after Week

49ers Notebook: Talanoa Hufanga's improvement; Brian Griese's impact; DJ Jones talks 49ers; Why is Jimmy G so loud?

By Kirk Larrabee
Sep 22

Today marked another day of media rounds for the San Francisco 49ers, with quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo, defensive coordinator DeMeco Ryans, and run game coordinator/offensive line coach Chris Foerster being among those to speak to reporters in Santa Clara. Among the topics discussed in those media sessions were the improvement of safety Talanoa Hufanga, the impact of new quarterbacks coach Brian Griese, and where Jimmy Garoppolo gets his vocal power from. There were also some quotes of note to come from outside 49ers facilities, including some thoughts from former 49ers defensive tackle D.J. Jones as he gets set to face his former team when the 49ers face the Broncos in Denver on Sunday night. Here's a rundown of those topics and more in this version of 49ers

49ers Notebook: The Trent Williams effect; Shanahan on his decision to decline key penalty; A familiar face haunts 49ers

By Kirk Larrabee
Sep 26

The sooner everyone moves on from the 49ers' dreadful 11-10 loss to the Denver Broncos on Sunday night the better. But first, let's tie up some loose ends to come from Sunday's postgame interviews. Much of the postgame discussion surrounded the performance of the 49ers' offense, which was poor enough to squander a defensive effort that held the Broncos' offense to just nine points. But there was also some honesty regarding the loss of left tackle Trent Williams, some insight from head coach Kyle Shanahan on why he declined an important first half penalty, and much more. Let's get into a roundup of some of Sunday's postgame comments in this edition of 49ers Notebook. George Kittle's honesty on the loss of Trent Williams and the performance of the


More by David Bonilla

More Articles

Share 49ersWebzone