There are 70 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

All TIME MLB Draft: BirdmanJr is UP. Fincham11 is ON DECK

I'll take Mookie Wilson, Mets 1987
James, you're up homeboy.
Man this things still going?

Um..pick coming in a few
1996 Cardinals

SS - Royce Clayton

33SB

With the 572nd pick the Cubs select .... 4 time All Star 2b Davey Lopes
* 4 time All Star
* 1 time Gold Glove winner
* 25th in all time stolen bases with 557 sbs

1979 What If Season - All Star Season
28 homeruns - 8th in league
44 sbs ( out of 48 attempts ) - 3rd in league
109 runs scored - 3rd in league
4th in WAR in NL
versus LHP ( since he would platoon with Morgan) .339 BA and 1.066 OPS
THE CHICAGO CUBS
Lineup:
1) Joe Morgan 2b Hall of Fame 1975
2) Darin Erstad CF 2000
3) Babe Herman RF 1930
4) Lou Gehrig 1b Hall of Fame 1927
5) Al Simmons LF Hall of Fame 1930
6) Mike Piazza C Future HOF 1997
7) Dick Allen 3B 1966
8) Arky Vaughn ss Hall of Fame 1935

Bench:

Outfield:
Heinie Manush OF Hall of Fame 1928
Kiki Cuyler OF Hall of Fame 1925
Tony Oliva OF 1964

Infield:
Vern Stephens SS 1949
Pie Traynor 3b 1923
Davey Lopes 2b 1979


Starting Staff
1) Mordecai Brown Hall of Fame 1909
2) Jack Chesbro Hall of Fame 1904
3) Stan Covaleski Hall of Fame 1918
4) Dave McNally 1968
5) Frank Tanana 1976

Relief Pitching
Closer Bruce Sutter Hall of Fame 1977
rh Brad Lidge 2004
rh Roberto Hernandez 1992
lh Eddie Guardado 2003
lh Al Hrbowsky 1975
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!

I dont really care but the rules were when we started this that you had to take someone who played last season. Dont think you should change the rules in the middle of the thing.
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!

I dont really care but the rules were when we started this that you had to take someone who played last season. Dont think you should change the rules in the middle of the thing.

If it gets the thing to move quicker, I'm all for it.
Originally posted by AmpLee:
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!

I dont really care but the rules were when we started this that you had to take someone who played last season. Dont think you should change the rules in the middle of the thing.

If it gets the thing to move quicker, I'm all for it.

Its not like this thing is ever gonna get to the game stage anyway.
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by AmpLee:
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!

I dont really care but the rules were when we started this that you had to take someone who played last season. Dont think you should change the rules in the middle of the thing.

If it gets the thing to move quicker, I'm all for it.

Its not like this thing is ever gonna get to the game stage anyway.

Exactly just the more reason for him to take Buster and get this damn thing over with so we can all move on from it.
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!

I dont really care but the rules were when we started this that you had to take someone who played last season. Dont think you should change the rules in the middle of the thing.

Hey, I know those were the rules for the NBA gig, but it wasnt stated on this.....if everyone agrees, lets keep it rolling?
Um..no.

Or I would have selected Posey or Heyward already.
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Originally posted by ninerlifer:
Can I take Buster Posey?

He is in What If Sports.

Soooooooooo

Buster Posey!

I dont really care but the rules were when we started this that you had to take someone who played last season. Dont think you should change the rules in the middle of the thing.

Hey, I know those were the rules for the NBA gig, but it wasnt stated on this.....if everyone agrees, lets keep it rolling?

James disagreed so make another pick. Lets keep it moving
What we should do if we finish is tournament format, rather than a full season.

24 teams. Random draw. Each matchup can be a best of 7 series.

That would narrow it down to 3 teams. Maybe a quick round robin from there to figure out the top 2 teams and then a World Series.

Would be easier to sim because you can keep the rosters and just run 7 games, changing the starting pitchers each time.