There are 65 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Ed Dickson's Hold on Anthony Dixon in the End Zone

Originally posted by NinerGod:
It would have been a safety. time would have been put back on the clock.

No, that's just plain wrong. I don't know where you got that notion from?


Baltimore's approach was just smart strategy, in that situation, there's literally NO downside to holding like crazy.
kind of a weird situation. They could have held our entire line for the rest of the clock and we would have been SOL. If they were coached to hold, then it is just good coaching.
How can an announcer call a safety before the play happens but our own coaching staff didn't even think about it? We weren't prepared for it hold or not. We wanted Teddy Ginn to get a big return and have one last play. Weren't expecting a safety.
The "safety punt" is undoubtedly something they practice occasionally. You're not going to run a play of that magnitude without your players being comfortable with it. I would bet you anything that the coaches instructed them to blatantly hold, because there are no repercussions for it! It's brilliant strategy. It's an exploit, but it's still technically within the rules. And besides, at that point in the game, who cares anyway? It's not like we were going to complete a hail mary and win the game anyway.

Again, if people want something to complain about here, don't complain about the refs. Complain about Kaepernik taking a time out on FIRST down with 10 minutes to go in the 3rd quarter. Complain about him being slow to distribute the play call late in the 4th, forcing Harbaugh to take a timeout to avoid a delay of game. Had we preserved all three timeouts, we could've had about 1:30 left when we got the ball back. Both of those timeouts stemmed from Kaep's inexperience (by the way, I full endorse the change to Kaep at QB). This fact had MUCH more to do with us losing than the refs did.

You see the pattern here?
The "no call" on the helmet-to-helmet against Crabs or the holding of Crabs in the end zone is not why we lost. The terrible playcalling was.
A lack of a holding penalty on Anthony Dixon was not a factor in us losing -- horrible clock management by Kaep is much more to blame.
[ Edited by theduke85 on Feb 4, 2013 at 8:47 AM ]
That play was just another example of the Ravens coaching staff out coaching the Niners staff plain and simple. We should have had 10 guys rushing that punt. Even if it wasnt blocked, the punter wouldnt have been able to run around for 10 seconds.
Search Podcast Draft Forum Commentary News Shop Home