There are 158 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

49ers should be hall of famers

I was comparing the hall of fame players between the Steelers and Niners, and in particular, i was comparing the stats between Swann and Taylor. They had very similar stats and I was wondering how come Taylor isn't considered a hall of famer but Swann is? Even though Swann had 7 more rec. touchdowns, everything else is even. (even though Taylor did more punt returns)


Also, how could Haley be left out? I mean, with the argument of judging a player's greatness is how many rings does he have, (which i think it's a cowardly argument) how could the players with the most SUPERBOWL rings not be in the hall of fame? It's straight ludicrous.

Listed below are players that should be in the HOF IMO.


Eddie D. (of course, no doubt)
Roger Craig
Bryant Young-if Cortez kennedy can get in, he should be considered


I know they're others, but I'm too brain dead to think of any. Do you guys agree with the players above? Also, what other 49ers players do you think belongs in the HOF that is currently is not?
  • IT21
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 12,023
Alex Smith
Originally posted by InconvenienTTruth21:
Alex Smith

#fail.
Thought you were talking about Brett swain in there
In all seriousness, Sammy Davis
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by InconvenienTTruth21:
Alex Smith

#fail.

Originally posted by marshniners24:
Thought you were talking about Brett swain in there
In all seriousness, Sammy Davis

u go on ninertalk, bro? Don't let the parking lot wolves see you on here!
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by marshniners24:
Thought you were talking about Brett swain in there
In all seriousness, Sammy Davis

u go on ninertalk, bro? Don't let the parking lot wolves see you on here!

First time ever

I only post here at night when the traffic is way down
Originally posted by marshniners24:
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by marshniners24:
Thought you were talking about Brett swain in there
In all seriousness, Sammy Davis

u go on ninertalk, bro? Don't let the parking lot wolves see you on here!

First time ever

I only post here at night when the traffic is way down

Ha ha...good idea!! In all seriousness though, I'm surprised Roger Craig isn't in yet.
  • IT21
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 12,023
I know he's not eligible yet
but do you guys think TO will make the hall of fame?

TO is 3rd all time in TDs behind Jerry and Moss. 2nd all time in receiving yards behind Jerry. 6th all time in receptions.
No rings and was a headcase on the field, but him and Moss were the best WRs in the league for a good 10 years


a little off topic.. but I was wondering what people think
I think TO will get in...or at least he should. That is if he hasn't pissed off the wrong people over the years. That being said, voting shouldn't be based on that.
T.O will get in.


I do think; however, that the nfl voters committee are the dumbest people on earth.
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

I remember seeing this. just dam awkward.
  • IT21
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 12,023
Originally posted by pdizo916:
T.O will get in.


I do think; however, that the nfl voters committee are the dumbest people on earth.


Originally posted by GBNinerFan:
I think TO will get in...or at least he should. That is if he hasn't pissed off the wrong people over the years. That being said, voting shouldn't be based on that.

I think he should too
but Cris Carter hasn't been voted in.. just makes you wonder
Originally posted by 49rz4Life:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

I remember seeing this. just dam awkward.

If they just scored a TD, why would he need his mouthguard if the D is coming out next? Makes sense that he's putting it down.
  • dugo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,038
Of course these choices are biased but ...
All three that were mention..Eddie D, Roger Craig, not sure if B.Y. is eligible yet..but for sure should get in the other two should be there.Others are:
Harris Barton
Brent Jones
John Tayor
(questionable)
Keena Turner
Bubba Paris
Michael Carter
Eric Wright
George Seifert
I'm sure theres others just can't remember them ..
Search Podcast Draft Forum Commentary News Shop Home