There are 96 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Who should be the 49ers QB for the rest of the year?

Who should be the 49ers QB for the rest of the year?

kaep! wtf is this
Alex. Dance with the one who brung ya.
[ Edited by Gzsfreak on Nov 25, 2012 at 10:32 PM ]
Alex should be our starter. He been faithful to our team. He been playing very well. He shouldn't loose his job because of injury.

Tho, Kaep fun to watch and i feel like he can make the big play. After two games I feel kaep ready to be a NFL starter.

I say its Alex job until he loose it from bad play not injury.
Tolzien
I really like watching Kaep play. I also think he is definately our future and perhaps a future star in this league but right now, I think it has to be Alex. Alex almost took us to the big dance last year and here at the end of the season his leadership and big game experience will never be more important. Kaep did great today, going into a hostile environment and making the plays that he had too but the playoffs are even more hostile. Kaep is young and the odds of him making mistakes are pretty probable when considering the history of young qbs before him and I don't want to chance the playoffs being that time.
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
I really like watching Kaep play. I also think he is definately our future and perhaps a future star in this league but right now, I think it has to be Alex. Alex almost took us to the big dance last year and here at the end of the season his leadership and big game experience will never be more important. Kaep did great today, going into a hostile environment and making the plays that he had too but the playoffs are even more hostile. Kaep is young and the odds of him making mistakes are pretty probable when considering the history of young qbs before him and I don't want to chance the playoffs being that time.

Ben Roethlesberger and Tom Brady won their first superbowls in their second season so I see no reason why Kap should have a chance to dominate the playoffs.
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Ben Roethlesberger and Tom Brady won their first superbowls in their second season so I see no reason why Kap should have a chance to dominate the playoffs.

Ben started the whole season and Tom came in at game 3. They had pretty much an entire season to get acclamated to the game. Tom went through his struggles with a couple of games, posting passer ratings of 79 and 58. Ben had pretty much played the most of the previous season and had experienced that big game experince losing out in the playoffs the previous season.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not debating Kaepernick's ability with you. I am very impressed with him. I just don't want those young qb mistakes to show up at the wrong time.
KAPPER all the way.... for sure... i dont think alex would of won this game... sorry dude... goodbye
CK7 Bayby
CKWon has beat one of the hottest defenses in the nfl, and the hottest team at their place. The kid exudes confidence. I prefer CKWon to AS.
Originally posted by danarez49:
KAPPER all the way.... for sure... i dont think alex would of won this game... sorry dude... goodbye


Not sure how you can say that. Alex beat perhaps a better Saints team last year and it isn't like Kaepernick won this game all by himself. We won the way we win most of our games, regardless of who our qb is. With the best defense in the league. Did Kaepernick make his fair share of plays...heck yes but has Alex made his fair share as well, I reiterate that with another heck yes.
[ Edited by Willisfn4life on Nov 25, 2012 at 11:13 PM ]
Love Alex Smith. True Nine warrior.

Smith is pissed and he should be.

Niners changed the plan.

Bill Walsh Lives On !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Kaep
Originally posted by danarez49:
KAPPER all the way.... for sure... i dont think alex would of won this game... sorry dude... goodbye

How?

I think we win either way
Originally posted by Willisfn4life:
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Ben Roethlesberger and Tom Brady won their first superbowls in their second season so I see no reason why Kap should have a chance to dominate the playoffs.

Ben started the whole season and Tom came in at game 3. They had pretty much an entire season to get acclamated to the game. Tom went through his struggles with a couple of games, posting passer ratings of 79 and 58. Ben had pretty much played the most of the previous season and had experienced that big game experince losing out in the playoffs the previous season.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not debating Kaepernick's ability with you. I am very impressed with him. I just don't want those young qb mistakes to show up at the wrong time.

You bring up a good point with Ben but even if Tom had from week 3 to begin with, playoffs is a whole different story. Intense atmosphere and youre not going against teams like the browns in the playoffs. He also had the game winning drive against a heavily favored Rams team.