There are 101 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

How good does your QB have to be to win a super bowl w/ a great defense and running game?

Originally posted by nickbradley:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Aikman had a much stronger arm, much greater accuracy, more pocket presense, more clutch at the end of games, could come from behind, more so than Alex Smith.

Because you don't like Smith?

Aikman had a QB rating nearly identical over his super bowl years.

I like Alex and have supported Alex. But come on. LOL. Aikman had a much stronger arm and much greater accuracy.
Originally posted by Tru2RedNGold25:
PLEASE DO NOT compare Troy Aikman to Alex Smith...................the comparisons are not even close

Troy Aikman= 3x Super Bowl Champion

Alex Smith= 7x Captain Checkdown Champion

Sure. Would you like to see Troy Aikman's early career?

Total QB Rating for Aikman's first 38 starts: 70.5
Alex Smtih in his first 38 starts? 71.9

* I chose 38 starts because that's the number of starts Troy Aikman had in 1989 - 1991.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
I like Alex and have supported Alex. But come on. LOL. Aikman had a much stronger arm and much greater accuracy.

Alex Smith, 63% passer under Harbaugh. 7.2 yards per attempt
Troy Aikman in his 'super bowl years' - 1992- 1995: 65% passer rating, 7.5 yards per attempt.

Wow, Troy Aikman is soooo much more accurate, with a much stronger arm.
Troy Aikman was considered a bust after his first two seasons.

Alex Smith's first two seasons were better.

Troy Aikman got better when Norv Turner was hired in his 3rd season.

Alex Smith tore his shoulder and didn't play healthy until 2009 after Norv Turner left.

Alex has his Norv now.
Originally posted by nickbradley:
Originally posted by Tru2RedNGold25:
PLEASE DO NOT compare Troy Aikman to Alex Smith...................the comparisons are not even close

Troy Aikman= 3x Super Bowl Champion

Alex Smith= 7x Captain Checkdown Champion

Sure. Would you like to see Troy Aikman's early career?

Total QB Rating for Aikman's first 38 starts: 70.5
Alex Smtih in his first 38 starts? 71.9

* I chose 38 starts because that's the number of starts Troy Aikman had in 1989 - 1991.

LOOK BRADLEY......................The key word is EARLY in his career Smith is no long a 24 year old QB

Aikman won his 1st Super Bowl at age 26 lets see Smith is already 28 going on 29................within that time frame Smith is STILL trying to grasp how to play at a top level as NFL QB....................NOT GONNA HAPPEN BUD..................Stop dreaming & start thinking straight

dont be naive
Originally posted by nickbradley:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
I like Alex and have supported Alex. But come on. LOL. Aikman had a much stronger arm and much greater accuracy.

Alex Smith, 63% passer under Harbaugh. 7.2 yards per attempt
Troy Aikman in his 'super bowl years' - 1992- 1995: 65% passer rating, 7.5 yards per attempt.

Wow, Troy Aikman is soooo much more accurate, with a much stronger arm.

SHOOT..............Failed like Smith passes down field.........wrong Quote

[ Edited by Tru2RedNGold25 on Oct 19, 2012 at 12:20 PM ]
Originally posted by Tru2RedNGold25:
LOOK BRADLEY......................The key word is EARLY in his career Smith is no long a 24 year old QB

Aikman won his 1st Super Bowl at age 26 lets see Smith is already 28 going on 29................within that time frame Smith is STILL trying to grasp how to play at a top level as NFL QB....................NOT GONNA HAPPEN BUD..................Stop dreaming & start thinking straight

dont be naive

And Alex Smith basically missed two years.
Originally posted by nickbradley:
Originally posted by Tru2RedNGold25:
LOOK BRADLEY......................The key word is EARLY in his career Smith is no long a 24 year old QB

Aikman won his 1st Super Bowl at age 26 lets see Smith is already 28 going on 29................within that time frame Smith is STILL trying to grasp how to play at a top level as NFL QB....................NOT GONNA HAPPEN BUD..................Stop dreaming & start thinking straight

dont be naive

And Alex Smith basically missed two years.

lol,

SB MVP or a 1-1 playoff QB
Originally posted by nickbradley:
Troy Aikman was considered a bust after his first two seasons.

Alex Smith's first two seasons were better.

Troy Aikman got better when Norv Turner was hired in his 3rd season.

Alex Smith tore his shoulder and didn't play healthy until 2009 after Norv Turner left.

Alex has his Norv now.

But JH doesn't have his Aikman.
Originally posted by nickbradley:
Originally posted by Tru2RedNGold25:
LOOK BRADLEY......................The key word is EARLY in his career Smith is no long a 24 year old QB

Aikman won his 1st Super Bowl at age 26 lets see Smith is already 28 going on 29................within that time frame Smith is STILL trying to grasp how to play at a top level as NFL QB....................NOT GONNA HAPPEN BUD..................Stop dreaming & start thinking straight

dont be naive

And Alex Smith basically missed two years.

Alexcuses #4578





ill STOP here.............this thread can go on forever n ever
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
lol,

SB MVP or a 1-1 playoff QB

Kelvin Martin didn't fumble away the NFC Championship game, Bro.
Originally posted by Joecool:
But JH doesn't have his Aikman.

Yes he does - his name is Alex Smith.
Originally posted by nickbradley:
Originally posted by Joecool:
But JH doesn't have his Aikman.

Yes he does - his name is Alex Smith.

  • Axl49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,351
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Aikman had a much stronger arm, much greater accuracy, more pocket presense, more clutch at the end of games, could come from behind, more so than Alex Smith.

MUCH MUCH greater accuracy.
Originally posted by Axl49:
MUCH MUCH greater accuracy.

How so? The data says that in his super bowl years (92-95), he had a completion % of 65.5%. Smith? 63%
Search Podcast Draft Forum Commentary News Shop Home