Alex is #4 in Qb rating, #7 in Total QBR
Manning is #1 in Qb rating, #1 in Total QBR
Alex signed a cheap (comparatively) deal that would not kill the 49ers cap if they go in the Kaep direction
Manning signed a huge deal that would have crippled the 49ers cap room to sign guys like Goldson, Bowman, etc.
Manning, despite having a great season, appears to not have the laser rocket arm any more, despite his stats. Plus, you can't ignore the 3 neck surgeries in 18 months / fusions. That HAS to make him more susceptible something permanent given the right hit.
Alex is orchestrating what Roman wants him to
Manning run his owns offense
I think its a wash for now but we will see come playoff time
On an emotional level, however, I want to see Alex bring home #6 and have a Giant drive him in the 49ers parade