There are 136 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Do You Support The Signing Of Harbaugh?

Do You Support The Signing Of Harbaugh?

This poll is intended to save us from all of the hindsight that is regularly used on this board.

Please vote and also state your choice in the thread so that you may be held accountable for your opinion in the future.


Rules:

1) If you do support the signing of Harbaugh and he fails, you accept that you cannot use his failing as a reason down the line to argue that Jed is a bad owner or Baalke is a bad GM. You can still make these arguments in the future, but you cannot use Harbaugh's failures to justify them.

2) If you do not support the signing Harbaugh and Harbaugh succeeds, you have to say that you were wrong and thought Harbaugh would fail before listing all of your reasons for why you think Harbaugh isn't the one responsible for our success under his tenure.

Of course, if you do support the signing and he succeeds, or if you don't support the signing and he fails, well, you have it on record and you get to gloat!

I think this thread is valid as it may save us from a lot of silliness down the line.

If you're curious about the definition of success, let's consider success to be measured as two consecutive playoff appearances, or reaching the NFC championship game at least one time.


I'll go first: Yes. I think Harbaugh will succeed.
I don't even support my kids.
Yes, he was best coach available that would take the job.




Also want to note that Gruden was and is still my first choice.


at first I didnt want a college coach but i was happy with the decision
[ Edited by valrod33 on Jan 12, 2011 at 2:49 PM ]
okay. there have been three votes (one of which was mine).

PLEASE STATE YOUR VOTE IN THE THREAD as there's no point to this unless you record your position.
He was the best college coach available. Wouldn't have minded an NFL coach, but I'm happy.
Originally posted by PopeyeJonesing:
okay. there have been three votes (one of which was mine).

PLEASE STATE YOUR VOTE IN THE THREAD as there's no point to this unless you record your position.

  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 20,063
Next great 49ers coach. Glad we snagged him.
Yes.

But he has several things that can derail him.

~ Yorks.
~ Baalke.
~ Paarage.

Other factors can drag him down so I'm not sure if he will succeed.
Originally posted by mayo49:
Next great 49ers coach. Glad we snagged him.

mayos still jacked
Yes I support Harbaugh.

I hope he drafts a QB like Mallett and we win the west next year.
Originally posted by RonRon:
Yes I support Harbaugh.

I hope he drafts a QB like Mallett and we win the west next year.

I'd rather have Dalton
  • Envy
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,382
Yes.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 20,063
Originally posted by mr2324jgf:
Originally posted by mayo49:
Next great 49ers coach. Glad we snagged him.

mayos still jacked

I support the hire. I think Jed made a good move and swung for the fences.

It could still fail miserably, but it was worth the risk.
Search Podcast Draft Forum Commentary News Shop Home