There are 148 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Mid season grades

All F. We got a lot of talent and we are not playing in to our full potential.
Originally posted by Axl49:
Troy Smith-SS lol jk. Willis A, Justin Smith A, Gore B+, Iupati B, Lawson B. Only ones worth mentioning

Gore has been our best play despite every defense knowing he is getting the ball. He gets an A
Originally posted by northvan49erman:
anyone feel like posting their player by player grades? I would post mine, but I i'm not from sanfran and I don't know as much as you guys.

Frank Gore - A
Justin Smith - A
Patrick Willis - B-

Everyone else combined - D
  • A-R-S
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,832
Coaching -F-
Offense -F
Defense -D
Originally posted by 49erRider:
Originally posted by northvan49erman:
anyone feel like posting their player by player grades? I would post mine, but I i'm not from sanfran and I don't know as much as you guys.

Frank Gore - A
Justin Smith - A
Patrick Willis - B-

Everyone else combined - D

but but alex has [insert alexcuse here] his whole career
OK, you wanted grades for all our guys.. I can do that.

______________________________

OFFENSE

QBs:
Alex Smith -- D
David Carr -- F
Troy Smith -- B (so far)

RBs:
Frank Gore -- A
Brain Westbrook -- B- (when given his chances)
Anthony Dixon -- B (holding penalty and predictable play calling ruining his numbers)

FB:
Moran Norris -- F

TEs:
Vernon Davis -- B-
Delanie Walker -- C+
Nate Byham -- B- (considering his job is to block, not catch)

WRs:
Michael Crabtree -- C+
Josh Morgan -- C
Ted Ginn, Jr. -- D
Dominique Zeigler -- C+ (when given a chance)

OL:
Joe Staley -- C
Mike Iupati -- B-
David Baas -- B-
Chilo Rachal -- F
Anthony Davis -- D
Adam Snyder -- B (at RG)

DEFENSE

NTs:
Aubrayo Franklin -- D
Ricky Jean-Francois -- D+

DEs:
Justin Smith -- A
Isaac Sapoaga -- C-
Ray McDonald -- C+

MLBs:
Patrick Willis -- B- (anybody that says 'A' is delusional)
Takeo Spikes -- B-
Navorro Bowman -- C

OLBs:
Manny Lawson -- B
Parys Haralson -- C-
Travis LaBoy -- C (when given a chance)
Ahmad Brooks -- C- (when given a chance)

CBs:
Nate Clements -- D+
Shawntae Spencer -- C+
Tarell Brown -- D

SS:
Michael Lewis -- F (when he was here)
Taylor Mays -- C+

FS:
Dashon Goldson -- D
Reggie Smith -- D

SPECIALISTS

Kicker:
Joe Nedney -- D

Punter:
Andy Lee -- B+

Returners:
Ted Ginn, Jr. -- B
Philip Adams -- D+
Kyle Williams -- C-

COACHING

Mike Singletary -- F-
Jimmy Raye -- F- (when he was here)
Mike Johnson -- C
Greg Manusky -- D+

______________________________

I guess I was a little too harsh on the other guys in my last post. People must understand, however, that any good grades or decent grades you see up there by players are negated by the grade of the head coach.

EDIT: forgot OL grades.
[ Edited by 49erRider on Nov 7, 2010 at 6:17 PM ]
I will try !

offense

Gore B+
Alex Smith C-
Norris C-
Crabtree B
Morgan C
Ginn B- counting returns
Ziegler C+
Staley C-
Iupat C
Baas B-
Rachel C-
Davis C-
Vernon Davis B
Walker C+
Dixon C+
Westbrook--incomplete

defense

Willis B
Lawson B
Haralson C-
Spikes B
Clements C-
Goldson C-
Mays C-
Spencer C+
Bowman C-
Justin Smith B
Franklin C
Soapoaga C
McDonald C+
Terrel brown C-
Will James C

Nedney C+
punter B

coaching

Singletary D
Raye D-
Johnson C+
Manusky C
gotta take a look at the film first
Originally posted by Lott49ersFan:
Coaching: F
Safeties - F....how can we have no picks, Goldson is absent in pass coverage. I wanna see Reggie Smith play FS I bet he'd have 3 or 4 by now.
Originally posted by Grigga2021:
Safeties - F....how can we have no picks, Goldson is absent in pass coverage. I wanna see Reggie Smith play FS I bet he'd have 3 or 4 by now.

I doubt Reggie Smith would have 3 or 4 INTs. Maybe 1 or 2. Maybe.

We don't blitz, therefor we get little pressure on the QBs, which results in less INTs. Goldson, however, has just been getting burned every week and is making very little impact. Taylor Mays is already better than the clown he replaced, so maybe we do need to see what Reggie can do as a full-time starter instead of wasting time on Goldson. I have to laugh at the fact he wants top money for a safety and he's now having an awful year. He won't get what he wants and if another team is stupid enough to give in, good riddance.
  • rob28
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 561
qb alex smith F, thats all that matters.
Originally posted by northvan49erman:
anyone feel like posting their player by player grades? I would post mine, but I i'm not from sanfran and I don't know as much as you guys.

Not sure what your lack of Niner knowledge has anything to do with you not being from SF?

Some of the brightest posters on this blog don't even live in CA.
[ Edited by Oakland-Niner on Nov 7, 2010 at 6:32 PM ]
  • Wodwo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 8,104
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
Originally posted by northvan49erman:
anyone feel like posting their player by player grades? I would post mine, but I i'm not from sanfran and I don't know as much as you guys.

Not sure what your lack of Niner knowledge has anything to do with you not being from SF?

Some of the brightest posters on this blog don't even live in CA.

I know! I'm, like, totally the smartest on the forum and I don't live in CA. Maybe it's cuz I were born in CA. Momma's teats had teh water of CA in dem. Tru storie.

Cowboys are funny. Lulz.


This is the fourth year running that property owner Vornado Realty Trust (http://www.vno.com) has sponsored a tree lighting event at 555 California, reinstating a holiday tradition that was last celebrated in the late 1990s.

The tree lighting ceremony this year will benefit the Blue Bear School of Music.

This year's event takes place on the plaza in front of 555 California and will feature live music from the children of the Blue Bear School of Music (http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000427921473&v=info)

This year's celebrity participants will be NFL Pro-Bowler and San Francisco 49er Tight End VERNON DAVIS and Grammy-nominated artist NATASHA BEDINGFIELD.

See you there!

For More Information, Visit:

(http://www.vnooffice.com/spotlight/555-tree-lighting-10-info-page/)

Vernon Davis:

Website: http://www.vernondavis85.net/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/VernonDavis85
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/vernondavis85?v=wall
MySpace: http://www.myspace.com/beastman18


Natasha Bedingfield:

Website: http://www.natashabedingfield.com/global/frontpage?cmdr=ip2country/detected
Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/natashabdnfield
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/natashabedingfield
MySpace: http://www.myspace.com/natashabedingfield