Originally posted by sacniner:Originally posted by ZRF80:Originally posted by sacniner:Originally posted by ZRF80:Originally posted by sacniner:Originally posted by ZRF80:Originally posted by sacniner:Originally posted by ZRF80:Originally posted by sacniner:Originally posted by ZRF80:Originally posted by sacniner:Originally posted by Shaj:Originally posted by ads_2006:
yeah, noodles would be killing right now
"noodles" is a better QB than "wonderlic-man", so I'm not sure where you're going with that.
that's why he can't benched in Houston for Smith? I guess everyone has their own opinions, but I just like QBs that are capable of at least attempting all the NFL throws. Hill's arm was too weak. But, he is a good stopgap backup. They shouldn't have traded him.
Attempting (as in capable of) vs. Attempting (actually making the throws) are 2 different things. The fact that Smith can do the first, but not the latter is a telling-tale of why this offense blows......
We've all seen him have flashes of being good. I'm not saying he is all that, but he's a better option than Carr and the mancrush Shaun Hill.
Are people forgetting how terrible Hill looked before he got benched? I think so.
How come no one makes the same excuses for Hill like they do for Smith ? Didnt he also have a poor oline ? Didnt he also have Raye calling plays for him ? How come no one was crying for the spread when Hill was behind center ?
People did make excuses. Hill was the webzone mancrush for a while. Hill is a backup, it's not his fault. He isn't good enough to be a starter. A spread with Hill? His arm can't handle that. He is good at getting rid of the ball quickly and throwing short.
Oh yeah, how did your whole "with alex out our D will play better" theory pan out? Not too good...
Sorry, I never said without Alex our D would play better. Ive said all along that with an efficient offense, our defense would play better because they wouldnt have to play with a chip on their shoulder (eg pressure because we're losing or trying to play from behind). Our offense is inept, and Alex is a big reason for it. Too bad Sing didnt want any competition for Alex, and signed someone just as bad. If we have a good offense, our defense will play better.
Nice try though.....
i was in the gameday thread when you said that. you said with smith out, our d is playing better. it's not a shocker considering all you do is hate on him.
You mean where I said, "Smith's out ! Our D is playing better !" ? Two independent statements that you interpreted as, "Smith's out, THEREFORE our D is playing better !"
No, it was before that. It's okay, I wouldn't admit to it either.
Link please. Of course, Im sure you're too "tired" to find it right now, but if you do....Id love for you to post it for everyone to see..........
Yeah, let me good find it in the 200 page gameday thread. I know it's hard to believe that you would have said that.
Exactly. Nice try though........