Training Camp 2010

Originally posted by HomerJ:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by jreff22:
SF_49ers

Singletary just announced that Alex Smith will not play against the #Chargers. David Carr will "probably" start for the #49ers

That's good because Alex mentioned that they don't plan at all for this game and are using two weeks to install and practice the Game 1 plan, which means if he starts this game, it will be without a plan and winging it off his natural talent...

...and we all know how that works out with Alex Smith. He will be ineffective if he plays this game.

Smith, Staley, Gore and VD should be the only players sitting out on offense as they have the most to lose from this game in terms of possible injury or reps not needed.

wow, really? We get it dude, you don't like Alex Smith. but he is the starter, maybe you should just support him like normal fans

I do. I'm just saying it's better he doesn't play in a game he really doesn't know the plan for.

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by HomerJ:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by jreff22:
SF_49ers

Singletary just announced that Alex Smith will not play against the #Chargers. David Carr will "probably" start for the #49ers

That's good because Alex mentioned that they don't plan at all for this game and are using two weeks to install and practice the Game 1 plan, which means if he starts this game, it will be without a plan and winging it off his natural talent...

...and we all know how that works out with Alex Smith. He will be ineffective if he plays this game.

Smith, Staley, Gore and VD should be the only players sitting out on offense as they have the most to lose from this game in terms of possible injury or reps not needed.

wow, really? We get it dude, you don't like Alex Smith. but he is the starter, maybe you should just support him like normal fans

I do. I'm just saying it's better he doesn't play in a game he really doesn't know the plan for.

ur just hating

Originally posted by phatbutskinny:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by HomerJ:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by jreff22:
SF_49ers

Singletary just announced that Alex Smith will not play against the #Chargers. David Carr will "probably" start for the #49ers

That's good because Alex mentioned that they don't plan at all for this game and are using two weeks to install and practice the Game 1 plan, which means if he starts this game, it will be without a plan and winging it off his natural talent...

...and we all know how that works out with Alex Smith. He will be ineffective if he plays this game.

Smith, Staley, Gore and VD should be the only players sitting out on offense as they have the most to lose from this game in terms of possible injury or reps not needed.

wow, really? We get it dude, you don't like Alex Smith. but he is the starter, maybe you should just support him like normal fans

I do. I'm just saying it's better he doesn't play in a game he really doesn't know the plan for.

ur just hating

No he's not, he's being realistic. "winging it" was never Smith's forte.

Takeo is coming on KNBR at 2PM local

What about defense?

Crabtree should play

They haven't game planned for any pre-season game, and Smith's done fine......

Originally posted by defenderDX:
They haven't game planned for any pre-season game, and Smith's done fine......

In way, yes they have. They worked on the playbook and certain plays that week. These were plays they were going to focus on in the preseason game, plays that they need to work on. This week, it's all about working on exactly what they will be doing during Week 1 which means they will be practicing almost nothing that will be called in preseason game 4. In preseason game 4, Jimmy Raye will be picking anything out of the playbook.

I think it's realistic to think it's better if Smith sits to keep his memory of his last game when prepared, which was good.

Originally posted by NinerBuff:

Originally posted by phatbutskinny:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by HomerJ:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by jreff22:
SF_49ers

Singletary just announced that Alex Smith will not play against the #Chargers. David Carr will "probably" start for the #49ers

That's good because Alex mentioned that they don't plan at all for this game and are using two weeks to install and practice the Game 1 plan, which means if he starts this game, it will be without a plan and winging it off his natural talent...

...and we all know how that works out with Alex Smith. He will be ineffective if he plays this game.

Smith, Staley, Gore and VD should be the only players sitting out on offense as they have the most to lose from this game in terms of possible injury or reps not needed.

wow, really? We get it dude, you don't like Alex Smith. but he is the starter, maybe you should just support him like normal fans

I do. I'm just saying it's better he doesn't play in a game he really doesn't know the plan for.

ur just hating

No he's not, he's being realistic. "winging it" was never Smith's forte.

he winged it for sure against the texans last year unless hes phychic and knew he would play to start the second half

Originally posted by teeohh:
What about defense?

Crabtree should play

with carr at qb? no

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by defenderDX:
They haven't game planned for any pre-season game, and Smith's done fine......

In way, yes they have. They worked on the playbook and certain plays that week. These were plays they were going to focus on in the preseason game, plays that they need to work on. This week, it's all about working on exactly what they will be doing during Week 1 which means they will be practicing almost nothing that will be called in preseason game 4. In preseason game 4, Jimmy Raye will be picking anything out of the playbook.

I think it's realistic to think it's better if Smith sits to keep his memory of his last game when prepared, which was good.

Regardless, they didn't gameplan for the Colts game or Vikings, and hardly the raiders. They only did for the raiders because it's what teams do as the preseason dwindles down.

Originally posted by sincalfaithful:

Originally posted by teeohh:
What about defense?

Crabtree should play

with carr at qb? no

Originally posted by NinerBuff:

Originally posted by phatbutskinny:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by HomerJ:

Originally posted by Joecool:

Originally posted by jreff22:
SF_49ers

Singletary just announced that Alex Smith will not play against the #Chargers. David Carr will "probably" start for the #49ers

That's good because Alex mentioned that they don't plan at all for this game and are using two weeks to install and practice the Game 1 plan, which means if he starts this game, it will be without a plan and winging it off his natural talent...

...and we all know how that works out with Alex Smith. He will be ineffective if he plays this game.

Smith, Staley, Gore and VD should be the only players sitting out on offense as they have the most to lose from this game in terms of possible injury or reps not needed.

wow, really? We get it dude, you don't like Alex Smith. but he is the starter, maybe you should just support him like normal fans

I do. I'm just saying it's better he doesn't play in a game he really doesn't know the plan for.

ur just hating

No he's not, he's being realistic. "winging it" was never Smith's forte.

where the f**k do u get this from??

how do u even know when he's winging it or not lol. silly ninertalk

ummm training camp is over...

Originally posted by WestCoast:
ummm training camp is over...

Originally posted by WestCoast:
ummm training camp is over...

would you rather have somebody start a preseason practice thread? Once the last preseason game is over we can lock this thing.