There are 103 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Who should start Sunday, Hill, Smith or Davis?

Who should start Sunday, Hill, Smith or Davis?

Originally posted by backontop:
Originally posted by LeadFarmer:
Originally posted by backontop:
Start Hill but if his crappy play continues and I say pull him at the half.

But he plays his best in the second half

Doesn't matter. The team can't win games with a QB that can only perform in the 4th quarter.

The team is 3-2 with that QB (and 12 sec. from 4-1).
Originally posted by backontop:
Start Hill but if his crappy play continues and I say pull him at the half.

Damon Huard
Originally posted by leolion:
Hill moves around better than Smith. Davis isn't ready.

And Smith and Hill are ready?
I want Smith to start, but idunno, i wanna see Crabtree and Gore with Hill.
Originally posted by LeadFarmer:
Originally posted by leolion:
Hill moves around better than Smith. Davis isn't ready.

And Smith and Hill are ready?




I'll give it a shot.

Layman's term: Davis a rookie. Hill and Smith have starting experience, Hill and Smith took most of the snaps with the first string offense.

Yes, they are more ready than Davis at this moment.
"I'm not a big Alex Smith guy. I think he has limited skills and I think he's got limited understanding." quote from Greg Cosell from MM's Blog
Originally posted by LeadFarmer:
"I'm not a big Alex Smith guy. I think he has limited skills and I think he's got limited understanding." quote from Greg Cosell from MM's Blog

He also goes on to state that Hill is not a QB that you can count on winning games for you, he pretty much said we don't have a QB, but then again, what the hell does he know?
If Hill struggles early, I would bring in Alex Smith at least for a series to see what he can do. I actually would play Alex a series or two a game just to give the D a differen't look (someone who can actually throw the ball down the field). BW did this a lot with Montana and Young. Not that we have Montana or Young
Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:
Originally posted by backontop:
Start Hill but if his crappy play continues and I say pull him at the half.



Yea cause my ideology doesn't make sense Stop swinging on Hill's nutsack and realize that he is nothing but a 3rd string QB. I am not saying that Smith is the answer or that if Smith is put in the game there will be any improvement. But what I am saying is that maybe Hill is getting to comfortable and needs his boat rocked a little bit. If I remember right it worked for Garcia. Didn't he get pulled out of a game and when he came back he realized that his starting role wasn't set in stone and if he didn't perform he might as well just sit down and watch the game. Maybe something like this will work for Hill as well. So before you go around making yourself look like an a** at least know what you are talking about.
I have a connection who works for the 49ers front office.

He sent me a message that I will share with you guy if you promise not to repeat it.

Word from the inside is "Hill will Start"
Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:
Originally posted by LeadFarmer:
Originally posted by leolion:
Hill moves around better than Smith. Davis isn't ready.

And Smith and Hill are ready?




I'll give it a shot.

Layman's term: Davis a rookie. Hill and Smith have starting experience, Hill and Smith took most of the snaps with the first string offense.

Yes, they are more ready than Davis at this moment.

Thanks Captain Obvious. I simply said none of our qb's are ready, but if we have to rank them Ya the guy thats been in the league might have more experience.
Originally posted by dirtysouthniner:
I have a connection who works for the 49ers front office.

He sent me a message that I will share with you guy if you promise not to repeat it.

Word from the inside is "Hill will Start"

word from EVERYWHERE is hill will start.
there is NO qb controversy within the 49ers HQ.
in 3 weeks if we get blown out by the texans and colts and Hill looks like he did vs. ATL, then we will have something brewing on our hands.
Doesn't matter who starts. Our Oline sucked the big one for some time now. I'm confident that any of them will struggle in this offense. Because I don't think it'll matter, stay with the starter, Hill.
I don't feel confident when Smith plays, put Davis in there damnit
Search Podcast Draft Forum Commentary News Shop Home