We all know that a true grade on any draft will take 3 years at a minimum.
We all have opinions and some of us like MadDog get ripped for daring to express a non-consnsus opinion.
Here is a partial list of "Initial Draft Grade" criteria that may be useful. Please add - subtract and weigh-in. I've read some outstanding ideas and opinions over the years here in the Zone. I think it would be solid if we could evaluate selections on the same criteria.
All the clone experts give us is ther opinion without real analysis.
Her's what I've come up with so far - maybe after your input we could come up with a point value system of what = an "A", "B" etc.
1). The selection address an immediate need
2). Te selection addresses a future need
3). Selection fills a starting position
4). Selection fits our system
5). Selection has enough skill sets: Speed, Strength, Explosion, Agility, Quickness, Balance, Leverage
6). The selection had few if any major injuries in college
7). Selection has demonstrated durability and production
8). Selection has physical requisites: Height, Weight, Arm Span, Hands,