There are 87 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

2007 Draft Revisited

Looking back not a bad draft by McCloughan. Three starters in the Pro Bowl, one alternate and a solid starter at CB in Brown. can we still bash McCloughan?

1 11 Patrick Willis ILB 6-1 240 Mississippi
1 28 Joe Staley OT 6-6 306 Central Michigan
3 34 Ray McDonald DT 6-3 276 Florida
4 27 Dashon Goldson FS 6-2 202
5 10 Tarell Brown CB 5-11 192 Texas
Still, f**k McClueless.
We need justification to bash him?
Wasn't Nolan still technically the GM that year?
Originally posted by skibeerski:
Looking back not a bad draft by McCloughan. Three starters in the Pro Bowl, one alternate and a solid starter at CB in Brown. can we still bash McCloughan?

1 11 Patrick Willis ILB 6-1 240 Mississippi
1 28 Joe Staley OT 6-6 306 Central Michigan
3 34 Ray McDonald DT 6-3 276 Florida
4 27 Dashon Goldson FS 6-2 202
5 10 Tarell Brown CB 5-11 192 Texas

Good draft, but yes. Look at the next year.

1 29 San Francisco 49ers Kentwan Balmer
2 39 San Francisco 49ers Chilo Rachal
3 75 San Francisco 49ers Reggie Smith CB
4 107 San Francisco 49ers Cody Wallace C
5 – San Francisco 49ers selection forfeited as penalty for violating anti-tampering rules
6 174 San Francisco 49ers Josh Morgan WR
7 214 San Francisco 49ers Larry Grant (who became a starter on the Rams team after being plucked from the practice squad - glad he's back).
Originally posted by blunt_probe:
Wasn't Nolan still technically the GM that year?

He did okay with his 6th and 7th round picks there..but yeah, the rest were a miss. Reggie isn't horrible..but not worth a 3rd round.
Originally posted by Jakemall:
He did okay with his 6th and 7th round picks there..but yeah, the rest were a miss. Reggie isn't horrible..but not worth a 3rd round.

Plus he flamed out at corner
Good draft, no doubt. But what did we trade for Staley? I would say that trade up pick was just ok.
Originally posted by skibeerski:
Looking back not a bad draft by McCloughan. Three starters in the Pro Bowl, one alternate and a solid starter at CB in Brown. can we still bash McCloughan?

1 11 Patrick Willis ILB 6-1 240 Mississippi
1 28 Joe Staley OT 6-6 306 Central Michigan
3 34 Ray McDonald DT 6-3 276 Florida
4 27 Dashon Goldson FS 6-2 202
5 10 Tarell Brown CB 5-11 192 Texas

Can't bash him for that draft. It was great.
Originally posted by danimal:
Good draft, no doubt. But what did we trade for Staley? I would say that trade up pick was just ok.

traded the next years number 1 which ended up being a top 10 pick, then later in the 07 draft we acquired indys 08 #1 in a trade where indy took our 07 2nd pick and took tony ugoh, the staley move basically cost us about 20 slots in the first round of 08
[ Edited by crabman82 on Dec 28, 2011 at 11:06 AM ]
Originally posted by danimal:
Good draft, no doubt. But what did we trade for Staley? I would say that trade up pick was just ok.

Sedrick Ellis or Jerod Mayo.
Originally posted by 12b6demurrer:
Good draft, but yes. Look at the next year.

1 29 San Francisco 49ers Kentwan Balmer
2 39 San Francisco 49ers Chilo Rachal
3 75 San Francisco 49ers Reggie Smith CB
4 107 San Francisco 49ers Cody Wallace C
5 – San Francisco 49ers selection forfeited as penalty for violating anti-tampering rules
6 174 San Francisco 49ers Josh Morgan WR
7 214 San Francisco 49ers Larry Grant (who became a starter on the Rams team after being plucked from the practice squad - glad he's back).
Besides Larry Grant, not a good draft at all. Rachal is a human turnstile, Balmer sucks in Seattle and Morgann cant stay on the field.
Originally posted by skibeerski:
Originally posted by 12b6demurrer:
Good draft, but yes. Look at the next year.

1 29 San Francisco 49ers Kentwan Balmer
2 39 San Francisco 49ers Chilo Rachal
3 75 San Francisco 49ers Reggie Smith CB
4 107 San Francisco 49ers Cody Wallace C
5 – San Francisco 49ers selection forfeited as penalty for violating anti-tampering rules
6 174 San Francisco 49ers Josh Morgan WR
7 214 San Francisco 49ers Larry Grant (who became a starter on the Rams team after being plucked from the practice squad - glad he's back).
Besides Larry Grant, not a good draft at all. Rachal is a human turnstile, Balmer sucks in Seattle and Morgann cant stay on the field.

No love for Josh?
Originally posted by English:
No love for Josh?

I would if he could stay healthy. The guy has skills when he's on the field.