Cam Newton? Von Miller? Patrick Peterson? Prince Amukamara? Blaine Gabbert?
If all of these guys were still there who would you pick?
If it were left up to me, I would take Cam Newton.
On talent alone is a specimen at the QB position. Will Harbaugh coaching this kid, the sky is the limit. I would let him sit behind a vet, someone like McNabb or Palmer, a player with a bit tread on the tires but knowing that they are a stop gap until Newton is ready. If you draft Newton, you cannot bring back Smith because the fans would kill what little confidence that he has left.