Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by fakers23:
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by fakers23:
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by nickbradley:
With Alex Smith, we know what we get at this point: an average starter with a QB rating of 80 - 85 when mature and healthy: (385/641/4159/30/21 in '09 and '10)
Now, that's good enough to win some games with a good defense and running game, but it isn't enough to take you all the way...think Jake Delhomme in Carolina. This will be even more true in the future, with rule changes enhancing the role of the quarterback (QB rating has been going up over the last few years).
So, let's re-sign Alex for 2 -3 years and draft a rookie in the first or second round ...my preference at this point would be to draft a QB in the second (or third) round like Stanzi or Ponder. But if we have a shot at Locker or Cam Newton in the middle of the 1st, that works for me too.
If the rookie pans out and is a 90+ QB rating guy, then great. But if he's a bust, we still have Alex Smith to give you decent production.
Thoughts?
Alex is the best we have..so yeah, we should re-sign him. We should draft a rook.
Ugh,NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I don't want The Bust back period! Why can't you Alex lovers accept reality! He's not welcome in San Fran!
Lover? Tell me who is better on this team at QB? no one...so we keep the best and try to get something better. I don't see your logic...you'd rather just suck next year while we throw another inexperienced QB up against the wall to see if he sticks?
My logic?? How about 6 years of failure! How's that for logic!
So your logic says Smith is the only reason this team has failed? I think I will side with Jake on this one. I would only upgrade if it is a real upgrade, but I guess you guys that just like to blame Smith for all the teams woes cannot see past your irrational emotions to see there might not be anything better to be had on the FA market. Draft a rookie QB if there is one worth the pick, but the CB position is a bigger need in my opinion.
Unless we have a shot at Locker, Newton, or Mallett with our #1, better off going w/ CB, then taking a QB in the 2nd or 3rd. Stanzi, Ponder, and Devlin are good pro prospects in the 2nd/3rd.