Second annual pick 3 you want pick 3 you don't | Page 4

Esco · 2010-04-18T11:19:53-07:00

Okay we did this last year and it's a really simple concept. Pick 3 players that you want with our 2 first round picks and 3 that you don't want. These are the players who you feel will be the best pros not the player you think will get picked. This thread will be saved so that we can revisit it at a later date and you armchair GM's can gloat or eat crow.

Apr 22, 2010 at 6:40 AM

#46

seanh
Veteran
Posts: 41

Want: Graham, Spiller, Haden

Don't: JPP, Cambell, Tebow

Apr 22, 2010 at 7:36 AM

#47

ninertico
Veteran
Posts: 10,259

Want(Realistically of course):

CJ Spiller--Sure we have Ginn and Gore, but Spiller is the playmaking Threat for TDs that we sorely need. Sub 4.3 speed on the field is unheard of and he, VD and Ginn would allow us to place three weapons of speed on the field at the same time...

I want elite and dominant in their respective positions to be used on our first two picks.

M. Iupati
Here's the other elite and dominant one at his position. And don't give my this Pouncey argument either. In no way shape or form is Pouncey the LOG that Iupati is, not even close. Versatility is another argument, but he stays at LOG and will become Baas replacement, will compete immediately against him. He will be able to be a Pro Bowl LOG like Larry Allen within two years.

B. Graham
Another dominant player especially in a defunct defense at Michigan, sometimes triple teamed. That's amazing. Kindle doesn't even come close to that. He dominated SB practices. He was the MVP of the SB. He just knows how to get into the back field. IMO, he could challenge and even surpass Haralson and Manny as a rookie. Given Manny's ?s, I see Graham as our next 49er.

Don't want at all

J. Clausen
Not with next year's rich QB draft. Period!

J. Haden
Too many very good CBs especially in the second. Does he fit our scheme? There is not much separating him from Wilson or McCourty based on what I have read.

S. Kindle
Reminds me of Manny 2.0 I would much rather have the bigger stockier and meaner pass rusher in Graham!

And the odd one:
A. Davis
WTH? Yup, I see him just like Brooks. He needs the right environment to succeed, develop and focus on football while maturing, quickly. Singletary knew immediately whether this cat would fit or not. Character aside, he is the best pure LT pass protector hands down, even better than Okung based on the pros out there. He is not as good at run blocking, but show potential. When he's on, he's absolutely dominant. That is why I am hoping his inconsistencies land him at #13. I am sure Brown could mold him and mentor him...seems like a perfect fit.

Apr 22, 2010 at 7:40 AM

#48

ninerlifer
Veteran
Posts: 17,237

Want:

Bulaga, Thomas, Lupati

Dont Want:

Clausen, Clausen, and Clausen

Apr 22, 2010 at 7:50 AM

#49

NeeJ49er
Veteran
Posts: 9,580

Want .. T.Williams, Mike Iupati, Jahvid Best

Dont Want ....Jimmy Clausen, Taylor Mays, Anthony Davis

Apr 22, 2010 at 7:58 AM

#50

DynastyChile
Veteran
Posts: 14,808

Want

Earl Thomas
Any Tackle
Jimmy dilfer, palmer, pickett, smith, weinke, rattay, dorsey have been our last qbs and you all still dont want Clausen?

Don't

Haden
Kindle
Tebow

Apr 22, 2010 at 8:40 AM

#51

Syxton
Veteran
Posts: 102

Originally posted by Reckless:
Want:

Anthony Davis
Kyle Wilson
Trent Williams

Don't:

Iupati
Graham
Kindle

How could you put Graham and Iupati on your Don't list? They are both studs.

My Want List:
Berry
Iupati
(any of the top 4 tackles - Davis being last)
Graham - ok he is #4 so sue me

Don't Want:
Clausen - we will know for sure next year what we have and what we don't have
Haden - big slow corner...watch the tape. Wilson is a play maker. or Akwasi Owusu-Ansah
Brown OT - he is a bottom round 1 guy, stop being local hero homers

[ Edited by Syxton on Apr 22, 2010 at 8:42 AM ]

Apr 22, 2010 at 8:42 AM

#52