Originally posted by Fricker:
You took Reggie Wayne wayyy to high... surely there is a RB you could have taken at that spot at 19.. your only RBs are williams, jackson, and daniel thomas.. All 3 share carries with DWill being the only true starter for his team if you even want to say that. I also think you took a TE way to high.. i cant see taking Owen as you already have Andre for the Double Dip , But then u didnt stop there and took Walter.. Sproles will see the field like 1% of the time, and just way to many same team same positions for my liking.. I rated your team a D .. If danny amendola is a free agent i would pick him up instead of Kevin Walter, Amendola is a PPR beast for his team.
I respect your take (I give myself a C+) Here's my reasoning for some of the issues you brought up.
I rate Reggie Wayne at the #6 WR available in PPR. Both the cheat sheets I built from value him in the low 20's (I took him at 19). And his ADP ranges from round two and round four. He was by no means a steal at 19 but I don't feel bad about the pick, and I feel in PPR he was a bigger asset than any of the RBs still on the board.
Daniels was one of the last legit starters left, when I took him. I'm ok with taking a TE in the 6th.
I don't give weight to buy weeks (other than back up QB) or players being on the same team. All other things being perfectly equal then sure I'll use those things as a deciding factor but otherwise I don't let them effect my pick.
I can't argue with you about my RB situation. It's the reason I give myself a C. I will say that I don't think you can say you know how much they're going to use Sproles. And at least at the onset I think Jackson will get the majority of carries. But you're right I need help at RB.
I do appreciate the feedback.