Rate My Team

Originally posted by lakers27:
QB Cutler
RB Chris Johnson/Ryan Matthews
RB/WR Jamaal Charles
WR Hakeem Nicks/Crabtree
TE Witten
K nedney
DEF Niners

Bench
Forsett
Hardesty
Knox
Kolb

I was going too then I realized you're starting Cutler with Kolb on the bench

you fail

Originally posted by vrabbit:

Originally posted by lakers27:
QB Cutler
RB Chris Johnson/Ryan Matthews
RB/WR Jamaal Charles
WR Hakeem Nicks/Crabtree
TE Witten
K nedney
DEF Niners

Bench
Forsett
Hardesty
Knox
Kolb

I was going too then I realized you're starting Cutler with Kolb on the bench

you fail

Cutler is playing against Detroit week 1.

Nicks/Crabtree/Knox as your WR could use work IMO.

Originally posted by vrabbit:

Originally posted by lakers27:
QB Cutler
RB Chris Johnson/Ryan Matthews
RB/WR Jamaal Charles
WR Hakeem Nicks/Crabtree
TE Witten
K nedney
DEF Niners

Bench
Forsett
Hardesty
Knox
Kolb

I was going too then I realized you're starting Cutler with Kolb on the bench

you fail

uh.....no its not. he threw 27 TD's in a horrible O last year, now he has Martz....stats wise, Cutler is nothing but win.

You have to give us more info. Is this PPR? 12 team league?


Anways, if it's a 12 team PPR league, then you have a borderline playoff team.

If you want to be a true contender though, you're going to need to trade one of your running backs for a real #1 receiver. Crabtree and Nicks will be great #2 WR in fantasy, but not #1 fantasy receivers.

[ Edited by crzy on Aug 2, 2010 at 06:36:47 ]

Originally posted by ninerlifer:

Originally posted by vrabbit:

Originally posted by lakers27:
QB Cutler
RB Chris Johnson/Ryan Matthews
RB/WR Jamaal Charles
WR Hakeem Nicks/Crabtree
TE Witten
K nedney
DEF Niners

Bench
Forsett
Hardesty
Knox
Kolb

I was going too then I realized you're starting Cutler with Kolb on the bench

you fail

uh.....no its not. he threw 27 TD's in a horrible O last year, now he has Martz....stats wise, Cutler is nothing but win.

And 26 interceptions ....

You can't tell me Martz changes that plus he still doesn't have a #1 WR.

IMO Kolb>Cutler though I don't know the latest on the Desean Jackson injury which certainly affects Kolb's value

Originally posted by vrabbit:

Originally posted by ninerlifer:

Originally posted by vrabbit:

Originally posted by lakers27:
QB Cutler
RB Chris Johnson/Ryan Matthews
RB/WR Jamaal Charles
WR Hakeem Nicks/Crabtree
TE Witten
K nedney
DEF Niners

Bench
Forsett
Hardesty
Knox
Kolb

I was going too then I realized you're starting Cutler with Kolb on the bench

you fail

uh.....no its not. he threw 27 TD's in a horrible O last year, now he has Martz....stats wise, Cutler is nothing but win.

And 26 interceptions ....

You can't tell me Martz changes that plus he still doesn't have a #1 WR.

IMO Kolb>Cutler though I don't know the latest on the Desean Jackson injury which certainly affects Kolb's value

http://www.49erswebzone.com/forum/thread.php?num=143380

Im not gonna argue this again with Cutler, refer to this instead...

If you are in a league that gives 6pts per TD pass and a point for 25 yards passing, and only -2 for INTs, then Cutler is a great pick. I will tell you this...fantasy wise, he will outscore Kolb barring injuries, because he is will be in a more high octane O....doesent matter who Cutler throws to, Martz systems make the journeyman into fantasy stars....after all this is fantasy. Thats all Im saying about Cutler.

Oops! Jamaal Charles is actually supposed to be Pierre Thomas....with all the RBBC in the NFL i wanted to get 3 RBs who would get consistent touches, so i drafted 3 in a row...Crabtree at 48 and Nicks at 49, i expect both to explode, and i got witten at 72/ and Cutler at 73, i expect Cutler to be a monster w/Martz offense, what strategy do you guys suggest with 1st pick??

12-team league (standard)

QB- Kolb/ Cutler
RB- Chris Johnson
RB- Ryan Matthews
RB/WR- Arian Foster
WR- Brandon Marshall
WR- Jeremy Maclin
TE- Jermichael Finley

Bench- Knox, Hardesty, Cadillac, Jacoby Jones, (Cutler)

I like foster. You took some risk with Kolb and Culter, but who am I to judge I took Stafford, Big Ben and Alex Smith.

B-/C+

Your WR2 situation is shaky. Not sold on Maclin as a WR2.

Originally posted by crzy:
B-/C+

Your WR2 situation is shaky. Not sold on Maclin as a WR2.

Lol C+ because one position is shaky?

Originally posted by lakers27:

Originally posted by crzy:
B-/C+

Your WR2 situation is shaky. Not sold on Maclin as a WR2.

Lol C+ because one position is shaky?

I think your QB's speak for the grade. IMO neither will be good in FF.

Great Rb's, good TE, mediocre QB's, bad WR's.