What is your SF 2025 draft grade?

Grade our draft and discuss..

i say A cuz i wanted defense

B-

Dug the first three picks. Thought we should have been more aggressive afterwards. Outside of CJ West, which I loved, not a fan of the rest of day 3 (including UDFAs where we usually do well) and the disregard for OL. Overall, excited about our new front.

B.

I love that we went after defense aggressively after it fell off a cliff last season and they all seem to fit scheme. I don't like that we barely addressed O-Line but D was for sure more important because a worse D means Brock makes more mistakes. If the D clamps down Brock can play with less pressure to be a hero and come back to 2023 form before the elbow. I just hope we pick up some form of a FA to beef up the O-Line

B-
I initially was between B and B-, but after Mustapha news came out its definitely a B-

Run D was horredous so we can check that box.

Pass rush should be better with an improve DL - check.

I like the safety pick. Another massive issue on this team. - check.

I like Martin, we need more speed and intuitive play. Massive upgrade over s**t for brains Campbell - check.

Wholy f**k what are you doing draft a QB, RB and WR. I lole James but you drafted a RB early last year and you extended CMC.

No OL....i get it was not strong draft.....SO WHY DIDNT YOU DRAFT THEM in 2024!

B- The Niners s**t the bed on day 3.

C..was great until it wasn't

It started out as a A, then ended overall as a C+ to me. They say, hit rate is 50% in the draft, after the CJ pick, seems like they were filling the other 50% out.

Originally posted by TD49ers:
Run D was horredous so we can check that box.

Pass rush should be better with an improve DL - check.

I like the safety pick. Another massive issue on this team. - check.

I like Martin, we need more speed and intuitive play. Massive upgrade over s**t for brains Campbell - check.

Wholy f**k what are you doing draft a QB, RB and WR. I lole James but you drafted a RB early last year and you extended CMC.

No OL....i get it was not strong draft.....SO WHY DIDNT YOU DRAFT THEM in 2024!

B- The Niners s**t the bed on day 3.

The RB pick was a real head scratcher, we even picked up Abenikanda towards the end of last year and he is a great fit for the system. They also picked up Corey Kiner, who reminds me a lot of a young Frank Gore running the ball. I guess we aren't taking chances of being caught short handed on the position.

I don't really like grading drafts until we see how they pan out. I like most of the players, some surprised me, kinda surprised we took a flyer on a qb. Overall I am not upset with this draft, I just hope we can get some offensive line help. That kid from Iowa looked pretty good on the film I have seen so far.

I was between a B- and a C+, settled on C. I've said enough about Mykel Williams, I'm hopeful with expecting that he becomes a decent pass rusher.

That said I do love the obvious intent to shore up our run D and I love Collins, but I was mocking him at #75, not sure he'd have made it all the way there, but I'd have liked us to be a bit more aggressive moving up and down we had a lot of capital and got sniped a lot.

I think we should have got another and spent some higher capital on our O-Line, didn't even try to replace Moore as a swing Tackle, I get the draft wasn't great for them, but we shave got it done.

Jordan James was my second love, I started getting heavily into watching Harmon when the clamour was growing to draft him, and while doing that I fell in love with James. Love the lateral movement, vision and decent contact balance.

C

A lot of projects and again injured players

How can you grade a draft when they haven't played yet? I can tell you that the 1981 49er draft was an A+

Originally posted by Memphis9er:

Originally posted by TD49ers:
Run D was horredous so we can check that box.

Pass rush should be better with an improve DL - check.

I like the safety pick. Another massive issue on this team. - check.

I like Martin, we need more speed and intuitive play. Massive upgrade over s**t for brains Campbell - check.

Wholy f**k what are you doing draft a QB, RB and WR. I lole James but you drafted a RB early last year and you extended CMC.

No OL....i get it was not strong draft.....SO WHY DIDNT YOU DRAFT THEM in 2024!

B- The Niners s**t the bed on day 3.

The RB pick was a real head scratcher, we even picked up Abenikanda towards the end of last year and he is a great fit for the system. They also picked up Corey Kiner, who reminds me a lot of a young Frank Gore running the ball. I guess we aren't taking chances of being caught short handed on the position.

I don't really like grading drafts until we see how they pan out. I like most of the players, some surprised me, kinda surprised we took a flyer on a qb. Overall I am not upset with this draft, I just hope we can get some offensive line help. That kid from Iowa looked pretty good on the film I have seen so far.

Good point on the RBs.

A+

O line doesn't matter. Just throw more screens and do toss plays

C