I Had a Suspicion About the 49ers Injury Woes This Season and Let AI Analyze It

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by sick9erfan:
The reality his that the Chiefs have a first ballot HOF coach and QB. They have had a ton of turnover and injury,yet they keep winning. This is a Montana Walsh or Belichik Brady situation, so its Apples to Oranges.

Several playoff teams had worse injuries than us so that excuse should be several items down. A team like the bills trotted out no name WRs. The reason they are and always will be in the hunt is they have an elite QB. Same as you said with the chiefs.

We have a good QB, probably in the range of 10-15 at best. When you have that, you need a much better defense, better playcalling, etc. unfortunately we didn't have that this year and purdy isn't good enough to overcome this year's deficiencies

no team has had the same amount nor to the same injuries to impact players

Mahomes will go as far as the refs take them and Allen is his own worst enemy

Our QB has shown he can get it done in less than 3 seasons worth of games

Honestly I give you props for trying to tear down the two best QBs in the game to prop up our guy.

So what will the excuses be next year when this team is well rested and have a soft as charmin schedule and they still choke?

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by sick9erfan:
The reality his that the Chiefs have a first ballot HOF coach and QB. They have had a ton of turnover and injury,yet they keep winning. This is a Montana Walsh or Belichik Brady situation, so its Apples to Oranges.

Several playoff teams had worse injuries than us so that excuse should be several items down. A team like the bills trotted out no name WRs. The reason they are and always will be in the hunt is they have an elite QB. Same as you said with the chiefs.

We have a good QB, probably in the range of 10-15 at best. When you have that, you need a much better defense, better playcalling, etc. unfortunately we didn't have that this year and purdy isn't good enough to overcome this year's deficiencies

no team has had the same amount nor to the same injuries to impact players

Mahomes will go as far as the refs take them and Allen is his own worst enemy

Our QB has shown he can get it done in less than 3 seasons worth of games

Honestly I give you props for trying to tear down the two best QBs in the game to prop up our guy.

it's not about tearing down.. Pat last year and this year hasn't been the same Pat and Allen screws it up when it counts..

And not sure why Brock get the short end of the stick.. dude was amazing. He won those comeback wins in the playoffs. he wasn't just sitting back enjoying the ride

Respect

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
no team has had the same amount nor to the same injuries to impact players

Mahomes will go as far as the refs take them and Allen is his own worst enemy

Our QB has shown he can get it done in less than 3 seasons worth of games

Get what done? Brock hasn't won a championship.

Originally posted by eric_anthony:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
no team has had the same amount nor to the same injuries to impact players

Mahomes will go as far as the refs take them and Allen is his own worst enemy

Our QB has shown he can get it done in less than 3 seasons worth of games

Get what done? Brock hasn't won a championship.

get what done?.. guy got us to the SB and put us ahead in OT

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
no team has had the same amount nor to the same injuries to impact players

Mahomes will go as far as the refs take them and Allen is his own worst enemy

Our QB has shown he can get it done in less than 3 seasons worth of games

Yeah, absolutely the lions have. Worse than us. Who did we even lose this season on defense lol. And don't say greenlaw. The team knew a year ago he wouldn't be around until the end of the season.

We were extremely healthy on defense. On offense, we were mostly healthy and the guys who were hurt weren't good this year anyways (Trent, cmc & aiyuk were all average at best when healthy this year).

Brock has shown this year he CANNOT get it done when we need him to elevate. Time & again this season we have needed 1 drive from home at the end of the game to bail us out and he has failed every time

I like Brock, think he's a good QB. Not great and certainly not elite.

Originally posted by frenchmov:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
no team has had the same amount nor to the same injuries to impact players

Mahomes will go as far as the refs take them and Allen is his own worst enemy

Our QB has shown he can get it done in less than 3 seasons worth of games

Yeah, absolutely the lions have. Worse than us. Who did we even lose this season on defense lol. And don't say greenlaw. The team knew a year ago he wouldn't be around until the end of the season.

We were extremely healthy on defense. On offense, we were mostly healthy and the guys who were hurt weren't good this year anyways (Trent, cmc & aiyuk were all average at best when healthy this year).

Brock has shown this year he CANNOT get it done when we need him to elevate. Time & again this season we have needed 1 drive from home at the end of the game to bail us out and he has failed every time

I like Brock, think he's a good QB. Not great and certainly not elite.

incorrect in ever point.

I think our injuries this year stem from 2 factors..... offseason hold outs and poor offensive line play.

Hold outs - Trent and Aiyuk missing the entire offseason is likely the reason why they were not performing great at the start and the reason why they got injured. Bodies need that prep before the regular season. Our FO has got to be straight-up with players and their agents.... we will not allow hold outs. If a player misses camp and OTAs, they should not make any contract offers until after the season. If the player wants to sit out the season and incur fines and lost wages, go ahead.

Poor OL play - When your OL doesn't get any push in the running game there is no room for anyone to operate between the tackles. Guys fall into each other more and get ankle and knee injuries. IIRC, that is how all of our RB and OL injuries occurred. Also, both of Brock's missed games are a result of taking hits/sacks.

As I said before, performance enhancing drugs.

You think the kicker and punter get injured from long flights? This is silly.