QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Facts...QB, RB, TE, WR, and OL. FB is literally the only position this system doesn't eat through which is super ironic. LOL. As to why that is, there are plenty of theories.

Go get em Brock. You got this.

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

The offense was moving at ease week 2 against the Seahawks when Lance was on the field. The running game worked really well.
And week 3 against that Broncos team, I´m sure the offense would have done better than 10 points with a rusty Jimmy.
But hey maybe the team would have lost at Carolina against all mighty Matt Rhule and Baker Mayfield?

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Facts...QB, RB, TE, WR, and OL. FB is literally the only position this system doesn't eat through which is super ironic. LOL. As to why that is, there are plenty of theories.

The optimistic side to the injury bug (Did I mention I was an eternal optimist? ) is the tremendous depth we have now. Just look at the QB position. Due to Jimmy's injury, we got Bosa, we drafted Trey, and due to injury to Trey and Jimmy, we discovered Brock.

To all the negative ninnies in 49er land! TAKET THAT!

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Facts...QB, RB, TE, WR, and OL. FB is literally the only position this system doesn't eat through which is super ironic. LOL. As to why that is, there are plenty of theories.

The optimistic side to the injury bug (Did I mention I was an eternal optimist? ) is the tremendous depth we have now. Just look at the QB position. Due to Jimmy's injury, we got Bosa, we drafted Trey, and due to injury to Trey and Jimmy, we discovered Brock.

To all the negative ninnies in 49er land! TAKET THAT!

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Facts...QB, RB, TE, WR, and OL. FB is literally the only position this system doesn't eat through which is super ironic. LOL. As to why that is, there are plenty of theories.

The optimistic side to the injury bug (Did I mention I was an eternal optimist? ) is the tremendous depth we have now. Just look at the QB position. Due to Jimmy's injury, we got Bosa, we drafted Trey, and due to injury to Trey and Jimmy, we discovered Brock.

To all the negative ninnies in 49er land! TAKET THAT!

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

You couldn't resist could ya? Once again you're talking out of your ass.

This matchup boils down to a simple game of Brock, paper, scissors. Eagles. Brock always smashes Eagles.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Facts...QB, RB, TE, WR, and OL. FB is literally the only position this system doesn't eat through which is super ironic. LOL. As to why that is, there are plenty of theories.

To be fair, Lance has always been injured -
and I don't blame him for it, it happens. He hurt his finger in august of his rookie year and then later his knee and then his ankle this year. I don't think he would of started much his rookie year even if he was made the starter

I think "Brocky" should actually stuck as this guy's permanent nickname. It fits so well, being an underdog etc... He even slightly resembles a young Stallone.

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

This is such a load of s**t. I'm tired on people extrapolating Lance's ability after playing week one in a monsoon. It's just lazy and agenda driven.

we simply don't have enough info on Lance to make any determinations. Any thoughts in either direction are born out of people who have made up their mind the moment he was drafted. Hey everyone, not sure if you are aware, but you don't need to pick one QB to root for, and then hate the others on the roster. So f**king strange and endlessly annoying.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

This is such a load of s**t. I'm tired on people extrapolating Lance's ability after playing week one in a monsoon. It's just lazy and agenda driven.

we simply don't have enough info on Lance to make any determinations. Any thoughts in either direction are born out of people who have made up their mind the moment he was drafted. Hey everyone, not sure if you are aware, but you don't need to pick one QB to root for, and then hate the others on the roster. So f**king strange and endlessly annoying.

.

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Goatie:
LMFAO there is no chance we would be in the playoffs if Lance did not get injured in week 2. We would have lost the first 6 games and he would have got benched.

Due to Lance's unfortunate injury JG stepped in and stepped up and won 70% of the games he started this year. Then Purdy took over and is undefeated.

Even if we do not win the NFC championship Purdy is starting next year. There will be no QB competition between Purdy and Lance as there does not need to be one. Purdy is so much more advanced than Lance right now that Lance will not even get a look in.

If Purdy wins tomorrow and wins the SB Lance will be looking for another home because he will get zero first team reps for years to come. You need to be more realistic and stop being such a Lance Tragic. That train has left the station and won't be coming back.

I'm super curious how the team and Kyle are going to talk about the starting position for next season once this season is over. I don't think they say anything about it initially.

i am with you that I think Purdy has locked up QB1 for next off season but you never know. It could definitely end up a competition but I feel like Kyle hated splitting reps. Lol

They will use the regular line of "everyone has to compete for their starting job in training camp". But Purdy will be the starter going into training camp and it would have to take extraordinary events for him not to be the starter game 1. That doesn't mean he couldn't lose his job with really poor play in the regular season.

Yeah, I see it similar. Brock is QB1 and Lance is QB2 at the start of the offseason. But the team will announce that it's in the teams interest to develop both QB's, and have that competition in OTA's and pre-season games to make sure QB2 can step in if QB1 can't. They will use the Injury Bug as a reason to give Trey as many reps as possible between the two QB's. Its' too soon to say whether or not Lance can be a starting level NFL QB or not. We just haven't seen much of him due to injuries.

Having said that, durability is and has always been an issue in the Kyle Shanahan offense. The fact that Lance got injured, though no fault of his own, of course -- still gets a ding in my book for his durability dimension. I view it similarly to Jimmy's durability issues. Jimmy's durability issues prompted ShanaLynch to draft Trey in the first place.

Facts...QB, RB, TE, WR, and OL. FB is literally the only position this system doesn't eat through which is super ironic. LOL. As to why that is, there are plenty of theories.

To be fair, Lance has always been injured -
and I don't blame him for it, it happens. He hurt his finger in august of his rookie year and then later his knee and then his ankle this year. I don't think he would of started much his rookie year even if he was made the starter

Agree on that point, however, Brock (knock on wood) has been able to avoid serious injury. So, for now, that's a plus in my book solely on the *durability dimension.* I think ShanaLynch is beginning to learn the lessons of what a durable player can bring to the table. So - again just on the durability dimension - Brock wins against Trey. What good is a rocket arm and Olympic sprinter speed if you are on the bench rehabbing? I think as ShanaLynch focuses more on durability (as well as talent) for the future - I don't see this teams Superbowl window closing any time soon.