QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
We have to go through Dak and Hurts. I believe Trey can be better than both guys given a chance to really play. Now if Purdy beats both these guys pretty soundly then I might be able to see why we should move Trey quickly but otherwise we keep both cheap franchise QBs and let the offseason determine who the starter is in 2023

Originally posted by Crown:
We absolutely need to keep both, I think it would be foolish to trade Trey.

While I respect Jimmy's contributions, it's not worth resigning him if you keep Trey

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Brockstar.

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Crown:
We absolutely need to keep both, I think it would be foolish to trade Trey.

While I respect Jimmy's contributions, it's not worth resigning him if you keep Trey

Good thing we have a front office that knows this. We keep both and we don't worry about a QB injury for two or three seasons while we focus our efforts elsewhere while continuing to develop both guys cheaply. We are talking about guys that are both 22 and 23 years old!

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
brock osweiller > brock purdy

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Crown:
We absolutely need to keep both, I think it would be foolish to trade Trey.

While I respect Jimmy's contributions, it's not worth resigning him if you keep Trey

Good thing we have a front office that knows this. We keep both and we don't worry about a QB injury for two or three seasons while we focus our efforts elsewhere while continuing to develop both guys cheaply. We are talking about guys that are both 22 and 23 years old!

Seriously. Thank God the front office isn't stupid enough to trade Trey Lance. It's like people forget we are on our 3rd string QB this year due to injuries.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Crown:
We absolutely need to keep both, I think it would be foolish to trade Trey.

While I respect Jimmy's contributions, it's not worth resigning him if you keep Trey

Good thing we have a front office that knows this. We keep both and we don't worry about a QB injury for two or three seasons while we focus our efforts elsewhere while continuing to develop both guys cheaply. We are talking about guys that are both 22 and 23 years old!

Seriously. Thank God the front office isn't stupid enough to trade Trey Lance. It's like people forget we are on our 3rd string QB this year due to injuries.

The "Trade Trey" group dont want him traded for any reason that would benefit the team. It's just personal problems they have with him.

Originally posted by Ezekiel38:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Brockstar.

If he beats Dallas and Philly and continues to impress maybe.

If not....yeah no on that nickname - far too premature.

Damn people let him earn these accolades against by beating top teams since he hasn't really played one yet. (SEAx2, AZ, LV, WSH, TB, MIA are not good)

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Originally posted by Furlow:
The bolded assumes that the two QB's have the same ability to play QB in the NFL. That's not looking like the case right now.

If the project that was Hurts is winning in the NFL I have zero doubt Lance can develop with Shanahan. The only thing is we ain't just gonna give him the gig with Purdy playing like this

Originally posted by Furlow:
I like Trey a lot. But if we can get a first for him, and use that to draft a RT who we pay $8-$9m/year rather than pay McGlinchey $18-$20m/year, and use the rest to help re-sign Bosa and Aiyuk, it's a win. Plus it gives Trey a chance to develop rather than sit, which is better for him, so it's win/win. If you're truly a fan of Trey then you don't want him sitting the bench for the Niners.

Originally posted by Furlow:
I like Trey a lot. But if we can get a first for him, and use that to draft a RT who we pay $8-$9m/year rather than pay McGlinchey $18-$20m/year, and use the rest to help re-sign Bosa and Aiyuk, it's a win. Plus it gives Trey a chance to develop rather than sit, which is better for him, so it's win/win. If you're truly a fan of Trey then you don't want him sitting the bench for the Niners.