QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by DrEll:

Originally posted by swayze:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The question is how long before this statement gets old….if my opinion, ten years is a long time…

The error in your logic is that by dumping Kyle we'd be far more likely to have another ten years of cycling through Erickson-Nolan-Singletary-Tomsula-Kelly types than to find a guy who you "know" can win it. I've seen that movie, I'll stick with the guy who we know can climb the mountain, and trust that he'll figure out how to make it to the summit.

Indefinitely?

You're not accurately assessing the downside risk. If we get another guy there's a remote chance he's got both all of the good qualities we like about Kyle and also has the gas to get over the hump where Kyle has come up short. Apropos of nothing we're talking single digit probability here.

The probability that the coach we hire isn't as good as Kyle is very, very high. It isn't easy to win in the NFL. It isn't easy to make deep playoff runs consistently. It is very easy and very common to hire a guy who flails about for a few years and gets canned, and that's the most likely outcome.

Originally posted by Fanaticofnfl:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by DrEll:
Purdy and Stafford are not on the same stratosphere. Purdy is playing great and is on the hottest QB streak going into the playoffs, but Stafford is a HOF QB with many years of success and a SB ring. Without Stafford the Rams probably don't make the playoffs. Without Purdy the Niners probably would with Mac albeit not as good.

You sure do love to make points based on nothing but hyperbole.

Guess with better skill players, OL, defense and health Sean McVay wouldn't be able to coach his Rams to the playoffs with a terrible QB like Jimmy G?

lol, doctorelle has really backed himself into a corner here. The Rams clearly have a better defense, and better skill position players, so it comes down largely to coaching and QB play. Which is the reason the Rams have a worse record?

Is Shanny better than McVay?

or

Is Purdy better than Stafford?

You're forgetting schedule.

This narrative that the 49ers played a cupcake schedule needs to go away already.

When the season ends, the 49ers will finish with a SOS of .490.

That's really not a ridiculously easy schedule. That's actually a pretty average schedule for a playoff team (you're going to win more games than lose and thus knock your SOS down a bit)

That's cuz rams and seahawks. Between us rams seahawks we are 1 2 3 in the nfc.

We played last place team in several divisions.

We still have one more game to play.

IDK. Maybe I'm biased as a 49er fan but the broadcast by the NBC crew Sunday night seemed very disrespectful against Purdy. Specifically, the off hand and slights by Collingsworth. Yet Purdy has more victories against the number one overall selected QBs then they have cumulatively against him.

Originally posted by 1ovydog:
IDK. Maybe I'm biased as a 49er fan but the broadcast by the NBC crew Sunday night seemed very disrespectful against Purdy. Specifically, the off hand and slights by Collingsworth. Yet Purdy has more victories against the number one overall selected QBs then they have cumulatively against him.

Collingsworth is a certified Niner hater. he's still bitter his pedophile ass got handed to him in SB XVI and XXIII.

Originally posted by 1ovydog:
IDK. Maybe I'm biased as a 49er fan but the broadcast by the NBC crew Sunday night seemed very disrespectful against Purdy. Specifically, the off hand and slights by Collingsworth. Yet Purdy has more victories against the number one overall selected QBs then they have cumulatively against him.

Collinsworth and NBC is extremely biased against us. They spent the entire 4th quarter of the Falcons game talking about how amazing Bijan is and how he was the best player in the stadium that night. The Falcons scored 10 points and led for 0 seconds of the 2nd half.

Nothing tops the 2022 (correctly called) non-touchback against the Chargers though and how absolutely insanely butthurt the whole NBC crew was over it.

If we make the Super Bowl prepare to mute your TV.

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
That's cuz rams and seahawks. Between us rams seahawks we are 1 2 3 in the nfc.

We played last place team in several divisions.

We still have one more game to play.

We only play 3 games a year based off of your previous year's standings. This year was NYG, CLE and CHi. CHI isn't a cellar dweller this year. So really only 2 games this year you can claim as playing last place teams.

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
That's cuz rams and seahawks. Between us rams seahawks we are 1 2 3 in the nfc.

We played last place team in several divisions.

We still have one more game to play.

We only play 3 games a year based off of your previous year's standings. This year was NYG, CLE and CHi. CHI isn't a cellar dweller this year. So really only 2 games this year you can claim as playing last place teams.

We didn't really benefit much at all from the difference in opponents this season.

Seattle played Vikings (with Max Brosmer), Commanders, and Steelers. Rams played Ravens (with Cooper Rush), Eagles, and Lions. Is either of those slates significantly more difficult than Bears, Browns, and Giants?

Originally posted by tankle104:

WHOLESOME: San Francisco #49ers star quarterback Brock Purdy's wife posted a video of Brock reading a bedtime story with his baby daughter.

❤? pic.twitter.com/1VdRJhjqah

— MLFootball (@MLFootball) December 30, 2025

after he balls out infront of the world, and we are all orgasming over it, bro is doing this. Lol gotta love it.

It is concerning that he cant take that story to the next level unless he has all those great books before it. You can see he's rushing through the pages and not bringing it home when the cow doesn't moo as expected. Watch the #1 reader pick, Mrs Purdy, take the stage... the difference is night and day

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
We didn't really benefit much at all from the difference in opponents this season.

Seattle played Vikings (with Max Brosmer), Commanders, and Steelers. Rams played Ravens (with Cooper Rush), Eagles, and Lions. Is either of those slates significantly more difficult than Bears, Browns, and Giants?

Rams one is. Seahawks one is not.

Seahawks always seem to draw the backup or weakened qbs year after year.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
We didn't really benefit much at all from the difference in opponents this season.

Seattle played Vikings (with Max Brosmer), Commanders, and Steelers. Rams played Ravens (with Cooper Rush), Eagles, and Lions. Is either of those slates significantly more difficult than Bears, Browns, and Giants?

I agree

Originally posted by RonMexico:

Different.

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
We didn't really benefit much at all from the difference in opponents this season.

Seattle played Vikings (with Max Brosmer), Commanders, and Steelers. Rams played Ravens (with Cooper Rush), Eagles, and Lions. Is either of those slates significantly more difficult than Bears, Browns, and Giants?

I agree

Even if they played the exct same schedules it doesn't matter. One team could win big while the other striuggled against the same team. So what? Every game in the NFL takes on a different tone so comparing results of games between common opponents doesn't really mean a lot. Look how different the Niners 2 games against the Rams played out.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Even if they played the exct same schedules it doesn't matter. One team could win big while the other striuggled against the same team. So what? Every game in the NFL takes on a different tone so comparing results of games between common opponents doesn't really mean a lot. Look how different the Niners 2 games against the Rams played out.

Week to week league… seemingly more than ever before.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Week to week league… seemingly more than ever before.

Yup. It's not who you play, it's when you play them.