QB Brock Purdy Thread

Had Purdy not received that mega extension in the offseason, he would be looking at potentially a new home or fighting for the starting position in 2026. But where they already gave it to him, he will start for the foreseeable future.

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
I get you. Yeah, if that is a limitation than it's not on him. All QB's have them.

The front office should be held accountable for dishing out that contract. He could have played out year 4.

Yes I agree.. they should have been more cautious with the contract.. wishful thinking probably isn't the best way to handle massive deals.

Originally posted by Ajinsc:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

If he can't adjust, that kind of is his fault.

Well I would say more like a limitation.. the nfl is littered with players that had one or two good years.

I think it takes the coach and qb to adjust, and that's not Kyle's strength. Offense looks best when a new qb comes in with new tendencies, or he falls into a Deebo type thing due to injuries or CMC trade. But the offense always goes stale until something like this happens. Right now it's stale and the only thing I see saving him is riding Mac's tendencies until that goes stale

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Had Purdy not received that mega extension in the offseason, he would be looking at potentially a new home or fighting for the starting position in 2026. But where they already gave it to him, he will start for the foreseeable future.

I don't buy that. He won't make it through the year playing like he did on Sunday

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
Had Purdy not received that mega extension in the offseason, he would be looking at potentially a new home or fighting for the starting position in 2026. But where they already gave it to him, he will start for the foreseeable future.

I don't buy that. He won't make it through the year playing like he did on Sunday

No team is touching that contract. Benching him would admit failure. Which I don't think this egocentric HC will do.

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Originally posted by Ajinsc:
so maybe it's not all on Brock, I mean need to give credit to the defensive coordinators they are very good in the nfl. They have three years of tape on Brock now and know his tendencies, his weaknesses etc. the great qbs can adjust maybe Brock just doesn't have that ability.

If he can't adjust, that kind of is his fault.

Yeah, what's with our fans not calling a spade a spade. Somehow it's not his fault because defensive coordinators were able to figure him out? What kind of argument is that?

My own personal humble opinion - some people are way overreacting to Purdy's INTs in the game.

Doesn't take much research to see how many good and great QBs have had multi int games in their career. Even our own Montana.

Now if it continues that would warrant the stronger takes.

Originally posted by Crown:
My own personal humble opinion - some people are way overreacting to Purdy's INTs in the game.

Doesn't take much research to see how many good and great QBs have had multi int games in their career. Even our own Montana.

Now if it continues that would warrant the stronger takes.

How exactly has it not continued? Why are you ignoring the 19 INTs in the last 20 games?

I feel like I'm in a twilight zone where despite a clear pattern some fans act like every new instance is some sort of outlier. It's maddening.

Originally posted by Crown:
My own personal humble opinion - some people are way overreacting to Purdy's INTs in the game.

Doesn't take much research to see how many good and great QBs have had multi int games in their career. Even our own Montana.

Now if it continues that would warrant the stronger takes.

I'm of the same opinion. He has to button it up down the stretch. The defense isn't, yet, good enough to consistently cover up the turnovers.

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
Had Purdy not received that mega extension in the offseason, he would be looking at potentially a new home or fighting for the starting position in 2026. But where they already gave it to him, he will start for the foreseeable future.

I don't buy that. He won't make it through the year playing like he did on Sunday

No team is touching that contract. Benching him would admit failure. Which I don't think this egocentric HC will do.

I'm going to give him starting every game through the end of the year before I make any conclusions. When healthy and protected Brock sees the field well and executes Kyle's system. There will always be fans that want a particular player to stumble, there's even fans here that want Kap back.
Facts are that Brock has the single season passing records for our franchise and he's been good at the intermediate passing game. If you think he stinks watch the playoff games between the Packers and Lions. That's where he separates himself between a system QB and someone that is calm under pressure. Jimmy G, Kap, Darnold all wilted under intense pressure.

Let's protect Brock like other top QBs get, and let's improve our D then become a dominant team every year starting in 2026. I think we might squeak into the playoffs this year but a team will ball control us out is my best prediction.

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Had Purdy not received that mega extension in the offseason, he would be looking at potentially a new home or fighting for the starting position in 2026. But where they already gave it to him, he will start for the foreseeable future.

I don't buy that. He won't make it through the year playing like he did on Sunday

No team is touching that contract. Benching him would admit failure. Which I don't think this egocentric HC will do.

There is not guarantee that they have jobs if it weren't for Brock, so I don't think they have a problem with paying him. Things like Jake Moody and Trey Lance are much bigger blunders than giving a guy that played way over his pay and potentially saved your job a fair market contract

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
No team is touching that contract. Benching him would admit failure. Which I don't think this egocentric HC will do.

Wut? Trading Deadline was weeks ago

Originally posted by mitpdub:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by 49ers9797:
Had Purdy not received that mega extension in the offseason, he would be looking at potentially a new home or fighting for the starting position in 2026. But where they already gave it to him, he will start for the foreseeable future.

I don't buy that. He won't make it through the year playing like he did on Sunday

No team is touching that contract. Benching him would admit failure. Which I don't think this egocentric HC will do.

I'm going to give him starting every game through the end of the year before I make any conclusions. When healthy and protected Brock sees the field well and executes Kyle's system. There will always be fans that want a particular player to stumble, there's even fans here that want Kap back.
Facts are that Brock has the single season passing records for our franchise and he's been good at the intermediate passing game. If you think he stinks watch the playoff games between the Packers and Lions. That's where he separates himself between a system QB and someone that is calm under pressure. Jimmy G, Kap, Darnold all wilted under intense pressure.

Let's protect Brock like other top QBs get, and let's improve our D then become a dominant team every year starting in 2026. I think we might squeak into the playoffs this year but a team will ball control us out is my best prediction.

you bring up those Packers and Lions games... games where THOSE young teams made idiotic mistakes that got us back in the game. In comparison to Kap in the playoffs and "witted under intense pressure"?

Kap went up against Aaron Rodgers in his prime...had to constantly answer to Aaron (and the Refs) in Green Bay in frigid weather. You think Brock can do that?

you think Brock could have handled those Seahawks teams?

He, like Jimmy, had a f**king 10 pt lead in the Super Bowl...and he couldn't put the Chiefs away with a few conversations. With his arms or his legs. Kap had to help bring us back by how many pts against the F'n Ravens? Ray Lewis, Ed Reed, Terrell Suggs, Haloti Nata, etc? They held the Andrew Luck and the Colts to 9pts, held Tom Brady and the Pats to 13pts.

Again yall bring up Kap on your own. It gets ridiculous when yall try to downplay someone else's accomplishments, to defend/prop up someone who is struggling.

Top 7 offense in DVOA for the season despite the injuries and flux. Doesn't indicate a stale offense.

Brock just needs to be better. Cant be late with the ball.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Top 7 offense in DVOA for the season despite the injuries and flux. Doesn't indicate a stale offense.

Brock just needs to be better. Cant be late with the ball.

That because of the easy schedule and getting a new qb in there to mix it up. The Brock offense is just about figured out. He's been picked every game by a roaming player on that dig route and Kyle continues to call it. Either switch it up or use Mac until things start going wrong with him. Then idk what the answer will be for Kyle after that