Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 286 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
BCB due for a big game this week vs CLE

Prepare to be dissapointed then; this is definitely not gonna be the week he has a big game, I'd put money on that. Myles Garrett and that defense is no joke. The bigger issue for Brock will be the weather; those two factors is a recipe for disaster.
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
Originally posted by 49ers808:
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
BCB due for a big game this week vs CLE

Prepare to be dissapointed then; this is definitely not gonna be the week he has a big game, I'd put money on that. Myles Garrett and that defense is no joke. The bigger issue for Brock will be the weather; those two factors is a recipe for disaster.

Yep we are better off running the Ball, maybe schedule some runs with Brock, or if we do have to Pass, keep it quick and near the line of scrimmage. If Purdy starts trying to pass it downfield then we are screwed.
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
They may not be the fastest WRs, but they can be depended on to get open consistently play after play. Our guys don't do that other than maybe Kittle and CMC and not more than a few yards beyond the LOS.

Our offense wasn't good under Mac in terms of scoring. We were in the bottom 3rd of the league offensively in most meaningful metrics (like scoring). That's probably why they benched Mac for Purdy before he was fully healthy. They were hoping that would spark something on offense, but I'm not sure it's going to work when Purdy isn't healthy and his accuracy isn't quite there yet.

No one is calling Mac some stud QB, he ran the offense (And that's without Ricky and Kittle for a lot of the time) and isn't currently 2nd in the NFL in INT% at 5.3
they benched Mac because Brock is the starter and making $265M

Using the injury excuse for Brock is ridiculous at this pt…you can either play or you can't. No one is 100% healthily out there, yet others are making s**t work. His accuracy has never really been some amazing trait.
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Nov 25, 2025 at 10:59 AM ]
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Dude is tossing no look passes every week. He's accurate as f**k. His OL is not great. 5th highest in hits and 9th most pressures this yr for Stafford. They're like 20th in rushing yards per game as well.

you can't toss out made up stats and telling me I have to prove you wrong lol. That's not how it works

Brock threw multiple no look passes last week. Whoa wow!!

Again I think Stafford is playing great ball, but I saw no impressive/ultra tight throws against us or bucs. Just impressive reads and guys being schemed (NFL) wide open
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
If you are going to say Mac Jones IS it, thats where the conversation will end. I have always been of the belief that if you dont have an elite QB, you should never stop looking for one. But at this point, its not a 100% fact that Brock cannot be one. He has played at that level before. Will he get there again? No one knows.

But to say "Purdy aint it" at this point in his career, given everything he has accomplished so far, is ridiculous IMO.

What has he accomplished? I mean we're in Jimmy G territory as far as accomplishments go. I'm not saying he ain't it, but he's been far from consistent for over a season now.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
They may not be the fastest WRs, but they can be depended on to get open consistently play after play. Our guys don't do that other than maybe Kittle and CMC and not more than a few yards beyond the LOS.

Our offense wasn't good under Mac in terms of scoring. We were in the bottom 3rd of the league offensively in most meaningful metrics (like scoring). That's probably why they benched Mac for Purdy before he was fully healthy. They were hoping that would spark something on offense, but I'm not sure it's going to work when Purdy isn't healthy and his accuracy isn't quite there yet.

Definitely not true, lol.

Non-garbage time points per game (arguably the only meaningful offensive metric) was definitely in the bottom 3rd. Points per yard and points per play were all near the bottom, which indicates a very dink and dunk offense that doesn't finish drives.
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Non-garbage time points per game (arguably the only meaningful offensive metric) was definitely in the bottom 3rd. Points per yard and points per play were all near the bottom, which indicates a very dink and dunk offense that doesn't finish drives.

Lmao.
  • jcs
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 39,805
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
They may not be the fastest WRs, but they can be depended on to get open consistently play after play. Our guys don't do that other than maybe Kittle and CMC and not more than a few yards beyond the LOS.

Our offense wasn't good under Mac in terms of scoring. We were in the bottom 3rd of the league offensively in most meaningful metrics (like scoring). That's probably why they benched Mac for Purdy before he was fully healthy. They were hoping that would spark something on offense, but I'm not sure it's going to work when Purdy isn't healthy and his accuracy isn't quite there yet.

Definitely not true, lol.

Non-garbage time points per game (arguably the only meaningful offensive metric) was definitely in the bottom 3rd. Points per yard and points per play were all near the bottom, which indicates a very dink and dunk offense that doesn't finish drives.

According to who's metrics?
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
They may not be the fastest WRs, but they can be depended on to get open consistently play after play. Our guys don't do that other than maybe Kittle and CMC and not more than a few yards beyond the LOS.

Our offense wasn't good under Mac in terms of scoring. We were in the bottom 3rd of the league offensively in most meaningful metrics (like scoring). That's probably why they benched Mac for Purdy before he was fully healthy. They were hoping that would spark something on offense, but I'm not sure it's going to work when Purdy isn't healthy and his accuracy isn't quite there yet.

No one is calling Mac some stud QB, he ran the offense (And that's without Ricky and Kittle for a lot of the time) and isn't currently 2nd in the NFL in INT% at 5.3
they benched Mac because Brock is the starter and making $265M

Using the injury excuse for Brock is ridiculous at this pt…you can either play or you can't. No one is 100% healthily out there, yet others are making s**t work. His accuracy has never really been some amazing trait.

You can't not take injuries into account. They impact a players performance all the time. Look at Puni for example. He looked awful while recovering from his knee injury and a lot of people here were ready to write him off as a bust despite his strong rookie season. Now that he's healthier, he's back to playing at a high level.

Brock is still clearly injured, but they were desperate for answers on offense, so they decided to put him back in before he was fully healthy.
Originally posted by jcs:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
They may not be the fastest WRs, but they can be depended on to get open consistently play after play. Our guys don't do that other than maybe Kittle and CMC and not more than a few yards beyond the LOS.

Our offense wasn't good under Mac in terms of scoring. We were in the bottom 3rd of the league offensively in most meaningful metrics (like scoring). That's probably why they benched Mac for Purdy before he was fully healthy. They were hoping that would spark something on offense, but I'm not sure it's going to work when Purdy isn't healthy and his accuracy isn't quite there yet.

Definitely not true, lol.

Non-garbage time points per game (arguably the only meaningful offensive metric) was definitely in the bottom 3rd. Points per yard and points per play were all near the bottom, which indicates a very dink and dunk offense that doesn't finish drives.

According to who's metrics?

https://www.teamrankings.com/nfl/

It's not hard to calculate the numbers yourself though.
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Brock threw multiple no look passes last week. Whoa wow!!

Again I think Stafford is playing great ball, but I saw no impressive/ultra tight throws against us or bucs. Just impressive reads and guys being schemed (NFL) wide open

Stafford runs the offense at an elite level, he throws the ball accurately and with touch OR velocity when it needs to be there. There's no wasted movements in his drop back or a bunch of hitches. He plays with anticipation. He can throw the ball from every damn angle and make every throw you want…acting like he not making any tight window throws is straight up hating at this point.

imo we'd have a SB if they could have traded for him.

You act like Kyle hasn't schemed up guys open for any of our QBs, which is just silly.

Brock needs to be a point guard and distribute, he doesn't need to be Mahomes or Allen tossing balls on the run 20 yards downfield, that had lead to bad things.
  • Sickaa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,734
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Sickaa:
Agreed.

Kittle, Pearsall, JJ and CMC Is more than enough talent for Brock to work with Imo

This would be among the worst WR corps in the NFL. Bottom 10 at the absolute best.

It's still more than what Mac had to work with for the most part
Originally posted by 49ersRing:
You can't not take injuries into account. They impact a players performance all the time. Look at Puni for example. He looked awful while recovering from his knee injury and a lot of people here were ready to write him off as a bust despite his strong rookie season. Now that he's healthier, he's back to playing at a high level.

Brock is still clearly injured, but they were desperate for answers on offense, so they decided to put him back in before he was fully healthy.

Brock said his foot is fine, you're making excuses because you can't admit he simply has not played consistent for a while.

They didn't have to play Brock vs AZ or the panthers if he couldn't play. Mac showed he can put the offense in a place to win games vs trash teams.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Brock threw multiple no look passes last week. Whoa wow!!

Again I think Stafford is playing great ball, but I saw no impressive/ultra tight throws against us or bucs. Just impressive reads and guys being schemed (NFL) wide open

Stafford runs the offense at an elite level, he throws the ball accurately and with touch OR velocity when it needs to be there. There's no wasted movements in his drop back or a bunch of hitches. He plays with anticipation. He can throw the ball from every damn angle and make every throw you want…acting like he not making any tight window throws is straight up hating at this point.

imo we'd have a SB if they could have traded for him.

You act like Kyle hasn't schemed up guys open for any of our QBs, which is just silly.

Brock needs to be a point guard and distribute, he doesn't need to be Mahomes or Allen tossing balls on the run 20 yards downfield, that had lead to bad things.

This is all true, and yet his qb rating was below the league average each of the last 3 seasons.
  • Sickaa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,734
Kyle basically had to have him manage the game In the 2nd half In fear of Brock throwing another costly Interception
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone