QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

How come Green Bay hasn't had to pay that price? They have had 3 now

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

How come Green Bay hasn't had to pay that price? They have had 3 now

Yeah but they didn't win 5 Super Bowls like the Niners did (should have been 7)

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

How come Green Bay hasn't had to pay that price? They have had 3 now

You like Love huh? I'm still not sure on him.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

How come Green Bay hasn't had to pay that price? They have had 3 now

You like Love huh? I'm still not sure on him.

So typical of this fanbase. They need to see 160 amazing games from Brock before they believe in him but they race to the podium like a propellor to call Love or Strout or Caleb Williams the next Brady after 3 good games lmao

Originally posted by genus49:
Show me another game where his accuracy struggled at that level.

Outside of Bourne that's who Brock had vs Seattle. THIS season and he didn't look anything like that.

You and anyone trying to correlate last year to this one isn't being serious. You literally have a game with this roster to look at and it's nothing like the Jags game.

My problem with Brock isn't necessarily his accuracy. My reference to issues last year is him not taking what the play is telling him to take. Instead passing up plays either trying to hit a big play or trying to target (or not target) certain receivers. Even the CMC play that is getting beaten to death CMC wasn't even supposed to be in the route. It was a fake screen to him booting the other way. The over was covered (which i mistakenly posted was open a day or two ago) with Either Juice or the 2nd TE as his outlet. Had he hit Juice immediately after seeing the overwasn't open it's an easy 5 yards. CMC didn't release until he seen Brock holding the ball.

In 22/23 he played in rythm and took what was there. The past 16 months he's holding the ball passing up plays looking for the bigger play or possibly his preferred targets. Even on the sack/fumble watching it live he had a couple options but didn't pull the trigger (I say this without the benefit of seeing replays going off what I think i saw)

This is my issue with Brock.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by MBNINER90266:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by MBNINER90266:
They rushed him back into that Jacksonville game and he probably maintained he was fine. Should have started Jones last week; if so we win that game.

Mac Jones was more hurt than Purdy, and also isnt as good of a QB. So I reject your conclusion.

He's 2-0

Quarterbacks dont have win-loss records. The fact that this is your reply to me says all that needs to be said.

Purdy was hurt and they played him. All that needs to be said. And has played better than Purdy this year. All that needs to be said. Coming from a Purdy supporter.

So dumb to let Brock play the jags game. Ridiculous. I knew it was dumb at the time and now it looks ridiculous.

I hope we win but man this rams game can get real ugly with no one to throw ro

Originally posted by tankle104:
So dumb to let Brock play the jags game. Ridiculous. I knew it was dumb at the time and now it looks ridiculous.

I hope we win but man this rams game can get real ugly with no one to throw ro

Agreed. Should have just played Martinez & saved Purdy for the division game

Originally posted by krizay:
My problem with Brock isn't necessarily his accuracy. My reference to issues last year is him not taking what the play is telling him to take. Instead passing up plays either trying to hit a big play or trying to target (or not target) certain receivers. Even the CMC play that is getting beaten to death CMC wasn't even supposed to be in the route. It was a fake screen to him booting the other way. The over was covered (which i mistakenly posted was open a day or two ago) with Either Juice or the 2nd TE as his outlet. Had he hit Juice immediately after seeing the overwasn't open it's an easy 5 yards. CMC didn't release until he seen Brock holding the ball.

In 22/23 he played in rythm and took what was there. The past 16 months he's holding the ball passing up plays looking for the bigger play or possibly his preferred targets. Even on the sack/fumble watching it live he had a couple options but didn't pull the trigger (I say this without the benefit of seeing replays going off what I think i saw)

This is my issue with Brock.

Nah.

These simps are gonna tell you that you don't know what you're talking about because Brock is great no matter what he does because they like him and they'll find an universe of excuses to justify his bad play since the Baltimore game.

It doesn't matter if in 2022-23 Brock was a mid-tier QB propelled by a pletora of playmakers and since last year he has been exposed as the bad decision-maker he has been since college.

All that matter is that they like Brock on a personal level and that's why if you don't agree with them you know nothing about football.

Originally posted by krizay:
My problem with Brock isn't necessarily his accuracy. My reference to issues last year is him not taking what the play is telling him to take. Instead passing up plays either trying to hit a big play or trying to target (or not target) certain receivers. Even the CMC play that is getting beaten to death CMC wasn't even supposed to be in the route. It was a fake screen to him booting the other way. The over was covered (which i mistakenly posted was open a day or two ago) with Either Juice or the 2nd TE as his outlet. Had he hit Juice immediately after seeing the overwasn't open it's an easy 5 yards. CMC didn't release until he seen Brock holding the ball.

In 22/23 he played in rythm and took what was there. The past 16 months he's holding the ball passing up plays looking for the bigger play or possibly his preferred targets. Even on the sack/fumble watching it live he had a couple options but didn't pull the trigger (I say this without the benefit of seeing replays going off what I think i saw)

This is my issue with Brock.

I'm clearly not going to convince folks here who have their opinions which is fine. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

I will just say rewatching some of these plays may be a good idea cuz it may change that opinion from what you remember in game. I know that's the case for me sometimes.

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

Paying the price for the Giants beating the Royals in the World Series. Ever since that win, the Chiefs have absolutely owned the 49ers. 5-0 including two SB wins. I know it's different sports. But I still believe a curse got put on the Niners.

In hindsight, I'd take a game 7 loss in exchange for two more SB titles.

But I agree with your point too. Every SB loss, the QB just could never make that clutch play. Plays great ones make. And it always felt like we had the lesser QB going in. Which ultimately would cost us. The 49ers have never truly had a great QB since Young retired.

Oh well. Maybe someday.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by dj43:
Good point.

Now imagine the uneasiness Purdy feels when he looks around and sees Bourne, Moore, and Tonges, trying to run patterns that he can trust.

Bourne, Moore and Tonges wasn't even on the team when his issues started. This game was not a one off.

It's ridiculous

That's my concern. He's having more of these "one off's", to the point where they are not looking like one offs anymore. Yes, the personnel issues are playing a role, but he's not making things easier on himself with the mental lapses. I want Brock to be the guy, but his play over the last few games is concerning.

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

How come Green Bay hasn't had to pay that price? They have had 3 now

Love? Lol nah, he's not on Favre and Rodgers level

When in doubt, listen to the best film guy in the business.

Originally posted by swoosh6996:

Originally posted by ninersrule4:

Originally posted by Patton:
We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

How come Green Bay hasn't had to pay that price? They have had 3 now

Love? Lol nah, he's not on Favre and Rodgers level

but Love's ahead of both Favre and Rodgers at this stage of their career... lets at least wait til after his 5th year as a starter...