QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Bay2Bay9erAllday:
This team keeps getting f**ked on contracts and injuries. Should've let him play out the last year of his contract.

Would have been an ultra shrewd move and wildly unpopular among the fanbase.

He's going to have a long leash to prove the contract was worth it. Hopefully that will be the case.

We are paying the price for getting Montana and Young back to back.

Broke Purdy

Sounds like they're going to shut him down for a while which is the right move. No sense in risking letting this injury carry into next season just to get a few more starts out of him this year. It sucks that he's become somewhat injury prone, but forcing him to play hurt isn't going to make it better.

Originally posted by Ajinsc:
So now Brock's toe is worse than they thought "might linger all season". Pretty soon it will be Burrow level (surgery and out for the year).

Who reported this?

Originally posted by Hopper:
Who reported this?

Vic Tafur:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by genus49:
Seriously. It's an absurd idea to ask the QB to constantly throw checkdowns on 1st down as a premise.

How long do you think it will take the opposing teams to clock that as a tendency?

It's one thing to not make bad decisions and take risky throws on 1st and 2nd down. It's another to root for conservative plays constantly. If the CMC play is considered risky then we have a serious problem…

The premise isn't to constantly throw checkdowns on first down. The premise is that the checkdown was the right decision on this specific play.

Really hard to distinguish isn't it?

You already said CMC was open. It was clearly the bigger play in that situation so why would you advocate for a checkdown that isn't wide open?

I realize you're set in your argument but it simply doesn't make sense. That was not a difficult throw to make. It wasn't a tough look or great coverage to beat. It was a high throw.

Originally posted by genus49:
You already said CMC was open. It was clearly the bigger play in that situation so why would you advocate for a checkdown that isn't wide open?

I realize you're set in your argument but it simply doesn't make sense. That was not a difficult throw to make. It wasn't a tough look or great coverage to beat. It was a high throw.

It doesn't make sense because you don't understand the argument regardless of how clearly I spell it out. It doesn't matter how open a player is if the pass rush is going to disrupt the attempt. It's only an easy throw if the QB can get the ball out cleanly. This is how defenses work in the NFL. They disrupt routes, alter pass attempts, etc. Both happened on this play.

We can move on as we're clearly not going to agree.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Vic Tafur:

"Purdy isn't healthy enough to be the team's emergency backup in LA, which underscores that his sprained big toe was worse than it seemed coming out of Sunday's loss and that the 49ers are leery of it becoming a recurring issue this season." ?? https://t.co/IjIuDZ0vat

— Vic Tafur (@VicTafur) October 1, 2025

Jeezus!! Might be a coincidence, but he seemed to stay more healthy before he got married and started line dancing in his cowboy boots while driving his Tacoma.

Originally posted by Patton:
Jeezus!! Might be a coincidence, but he seemed to stay more healthy before he got married and started line dancing in his cowboy boots while driving his Tacoma.

It's definitely not a coincidence. I'll start the petition for him to get a divorce.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by genus49:
Show me another game where his accuracy struggled at that level.

Outside of Bourne that's who Brock had vs Seattle. THIS season and he didn't look anything like that.

You and anyone trying to correlate last year to this one isn't being serious. You literally have a game with this roster to look at and it's nothing like the Jags game.

Brock played well against Seattle, except for the multiple turnovers. That's the problem going back to last season Krizay is referencing. The problem Brock made a point to address this offseason. The problem we've seen zero improvement in through two games. It's a decision making issue, not an accuracy one. Is there a reason you are having trouble recognizing Krizay's obvious point? Is this yet another deflection/minimization tactic?

You of all people talking about deflections is irony that would make Tony Stark jealous.

krizay can talk for himself. All he indicated was Brock has been playing poorly since last year…when we were missing key players as well btw.

My issue is the two games THIS year which to me is a hell of a lot more telling than last year when we were losing games where he was nearly perfect. Those games are not comparable. You're talking about his decisions. They were not a problem in the Jags game. His accuracy was the issue.

His accuracy was not an issue vs Seattle. And his decision making wasn't as bad as I initially thought either…not to mention it was a friggin win vs a tough divisional opponent missing key players.

So all you guys are doing is looking at the box score and refusing to acknowledge what's happening with the team in those games or refusing to acknowledge that Brock's accuracy issues could've been a result of an injury he was clearly not fully healed from.

The Jags game had 3 turnovers. The only questionable decision was the 2nd pick and even on that one we don't know what happens if the ball isn't tipped at the line.

Bringing up last year doesn't do a damn thing. It's a lazy take when you know our offense had guys in and out of it all year long and still Purdy was near the top of many QB metrics.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Patton:
Jeezus!! Might be a coincidence, but he seemed to stay more healthy before he got married and started line dancing in his cowboy boots while driving his Tacoma.

It's definitely not a coincidence. I'll start the petition for him to get a divorce.

Maybe throw in a mistress that makes adult films We need a solid jumpstart to get him back in the groove.

Originally posted by genus49:
You of all people talking about deflections is irony that would make Tony Stark jealous.

krizay can talk for himself. All he indicated was Brock has been playing poorly since last year…when we were missing key players as well btw.

My issue is the two games THIS year which to me is a hell of a lot more telling than last year when we were losing games where he was nearly perfect. Those games are not comparable. You're talking about his decisions. They were not a problem in the Jags game. His accuracy was the issue.

His accuracy was not an issue vs Seattle. And his decision making wasn't as bad as I initially thought either…not to mention it was a friggin win vs a tough divisional opponent missing key players.

So all you guys are doing is looking at the box score and refusing to acknowledge what's happening with the team in those games or refusing to acknowledge that Brock's accuracy issues could've been a result of an injury he was clearly not fully healed from.

The Jags game had 3 turnovers. The only questionable decision was the 2nd pick and even on that one we don't know what happens if the ball isn't tipped at the line.

Bringing up last year doesn't do a damn thing. It's a lazy take when you know our offense had guys in and out of it all year long and still Purdy was near the top of many QB metrics.

My god man. Clearly I don't watch the games.

If I hadn't argued with you before many times I'd wonder where this was coming from. But I have so I don't.

'Nearly perfect', lol.

*by the way. I said more than one time that I thought his general inaccuracy in this last game was likely the result of his injury.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Not just a bad throw, but a bad decision. Had the open checkdown and it was 1st and 10. Another example of him trying to do too much.

I definitely think he was hurt yesterday. I think his accuracy is overrated by his biggest fans, but his placement yesterday was abysmal. Definitely a lack of precision you don't normally see from him, and that is more than likely the result of his injury.

The turnovers have been a continuing issue and I don't think they were injury related. Bad decisions, reckless with the ball etc. He really needs to reel it in. Unfortunately it's been a part of his DNA going back to college.

^^^

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Patton:
Jeezus!! Might be a coincidence, but he seemed to stay more healthy before he got married and started line dancing in his cowboy boots while driving his Tacoma.

It's definitely not a coincidence. I'll start the petition for him to get a divorce.

I want his toyota.