QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by krizay:
Week one he was throwing jump passes and also had bad feet. The issues he had yesterday weren't a product of his injury. It's what it's been for at least a year and a 1/4.

Yes there were drops this game and it did attribute to the loss this game. That doesn't change what Brock has been the past 13 months.

Like SmokeyJoe, NY said I have said, Brock needs to get back to being a game manager like he was in 22/23. Don't worry about that moniker. He needs to just run the offense.

He was an ELITE game manager. He is a mid gunslinger.

.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Furlow:
I mean it's a legitimate point. I haven't really been in this thread in almost a year, and NY is still going on about the same nonsense. He clearly hasn't gotten over his crush on Lance.

Clearly you haven't been here for a yr if you think that's what I've been going on about.

the fact you can't get over this Lance debate is a you problem bud. I haven't talked about him….at this point it's a s**t rebuttal rooted in emotional nonsense. It just shows you're unwilling you are to keep things objective.

Objectively, Brock is not our main issue. Weapons are injured, OL is trash, CMC looks cooked and can't run the ball, WR's dropping balls and running into each other. Purdy's 2nd INT was a bad decision no doubt. The one to CMC batting it up in the air is not on him. Bourne couldn't catch a cold and had he caught that long one on 3rd down, he might have scored. Instead the next play the Jags ran the punt back for a TD. Purdy's fumble was like 2 seconds after the snap - we can't block for 2 seconds? Luke Farrell fumble. Jennings TD drop. And that's not even mentioning the defense's complete inability to generate a pass rush with Bosa out.

Yet you and others are in here crying about Purdy and expect him to overcome all of that. Same group of you, same stupid "arguments."

Originally posted by Montana:
Of course it is real and played a role..did ppl not watch Brock's feet yesterday? Lol they were off, it was obvious. If ya got a bum toe, it's gunna throw stuff off..not an excuse but reality. They probably would have/should have rested him another week but Mac hurt his hammy. They rolled with Brock, it was too early. I hope he heals up asap. The injury bug continues to bite us in the ass lol

Purdy said his foot didnt bother him at all during the game, just at night after the game(Soreness). He didn't indicate it at all to Kyle during the game as well. Per Kyle with his phone call with Purdy last night.

"He didn't indicate it to me at all during the game," Shanahan explained. "I talked to him on the phone last night, and he said it was starting to bother him a little bit last night. But nothing during the game at all."

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Furlow:
I mean it's a legitimate point. I haven't really been in this thread in almost a year, and NY is still going on about the same nonsense. He clearly hasn't gotten over his crush on Lance.

Clearly you haven't been here for a yr if you think that's what I've been going on about.

the fact you can't get over this Lance debate is a you problem bud. I haven't talked about him….at this point it's a s**t rebuttal rooted in emotional nonsense. It just shows you're unwilling you are to keep things objective.

Objectively, Brock is not our main issue. Weapons are injured, OL is trash, CMC looks cooked and can't run the ball, WR's dropping balls and running into each other. Purdy's 2nd INT was a bad decision no doubt. The one to CMC batting it up in the air is not on him. Bourne couldn't catch a cold and had he caught that long one on 3rd down, he might have scored. Instead the next play the Jags ran the punt back for a TD. Purdy's fumble was like 2 seconds after the snap - we can't block for 2 seconds? Luke Farrell fumble. Jennings TD drop. And that's not even mentioning the defense's complete inability to generate a pass rush with Bosa out.

Yet you and others are in here crying about Purdy and expect him to overcome all of that. Same group of you, same stupid "arguments."

Purdy got touched 4 seconds after the snap when he fumbled. His eyes were downfield for a deep shot. His mind was already made up and he was about to get ready to throw it.

I can't judge how Brock has played this season because I've been out of the country for every game so far..haven't seen anything. Will catch up next week when I get back.

But I do know how Brock played late last year. Especially when he was missing some weapons and started to press... trying to do too much.

So can someone objective explain if he's playing similar to late last year? or if there is a different description.

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Furlow:
I mean it's a legitimate point. I haven't really been in this thread in almost a year, and NY is still going on about the same nonsense. He clearly hasn't gotten over his crush on Lance.

Clearly you haven't been here for a yr if you think that's what I've been going on about.

the fact you can't get over this Lance debate is a you problem bud. I haven't talked about him….at this point it's a s**t rebuttal rooted in emotional nonsense. It just shows you're unwilling you are to keep things objective.

Objectively, Brock is not our main issue. Weapons are injured, OL is trash, CMC looks cooked and can't run the ball, WR's dropping balls and running into each other. Purdy's 2nd INT was a bad decision no doubt. The one to CMC batting it up in the air is not on him. Bourne couldn't catch a cold and had he caught that long one on 3rd down, he might have scored. Instead the next play the Jags ran the punt back for a TD. Purdy's fumble was like 2 seconds after the snap - we can't block for 2 seconds? Luke Farrell fumble. Jennings TD drop. And that's not even mentioning the defense's complete inability to generate a pass rush with Bosa out.

Yet you and others are in here crying about Purdy and expect him to overcome all of that. Same group of you, same stupid "arguments."

Now, if you know the OL is trash. You know your WRs are injured. You know you can't run the ball. So why are you forcing s**t and not taking what is there in front of you? That is what I expect.

I for one dont think this loss was solely on Brock. I just think he needs to help himself and the team out but getting back to playing to his strengths.

He definitely isn't the biggest problem.

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Purdy said his foot didnt bother him at all during the game, just at night after the game(Soreness). He didn't indicate it at all to Kyle during the game as well. Per Kyle with his phone call with Purdy last night.

"He didn't indicate it to me at all during the game," Shanahan explained. "I talked to him on the phone last night, and he said it was starting to bother him a little bit last night. But nothing during the game at all."

Wagonner clarified there is no soreness. Just that Brock thought it.mightve affected his accuracy.

Gotta stop with the risky throws. Simple as that.

Originally posted by Furlow:
Objectively, Brock is not our main issue. Weapons are injured, OL is trash, CMC looks cooked and can't run the ball, WR's dropping balls and running into each other. Purdy's 2nd INT was a bad decision no doubt. The one to CMC batting it up in the air is not on him. Bourne couldn't catch a cold and had he caught that long one on 3rd down, he might have scored. Instead the next play the Jags ran the punt back for a TD. Purdy's fumble was like 2 seconds after the snap - we can't block for 2 seconds? Luke Farrell fumble. Jennings TD drop. And that's not even mentioning the defense's complete inability to generate a pass rush with Bosa out.

Yet you and others are in here crying about Purdy and expect him to overcome all of that. Same group of you, same stupid "arguments."

It was 100 percent on Purdy. It's an inaccurate ball into the middle of the field and it was a bad decision. You can't throw high balls into the middle of field and expect good results, and again his checkdown was wide open in front of him. It was 1st and 10. This is a recurring issue. He's noted it himself.

Also faulting Jennings for a TD drop is something I've seen multiple people say, including The Sanchize during the broadcast. That was a very poorly placed ball. It was low, which was good, but it was also behind Jennings. Guy had to effectively dive backwards for a chance to catch it. One of many poorly placed balls yesterday, which is unusual for Brock (and why I think he was obviously hurt).

Originally posted by Afrikan:
I can't judge how Brock has played this season because I've been out of the country for every game so far..haven't seen anything. Will catch up next week when I get back.

But I do know how Brock played late last year. Especially when he was missing some weapons and started to press... trying to do too much.

So can someone objective explain if he's playing similar to late last year? or if there is a different description.

Basically the same version from the end of last season

back in 22/23 he had the ultimate game manager as his QB coach, Brian Griese, now that Griese is no longer his QB coach, he has regressed, think about it lol

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by Montana:
Of course it is real and played a role..did ppl not watch Brock's feet yesterday? Lol they were off, it was obvious. If ya got a bum toe, it's gunna throw stuff off..not an excuse but reality. They probably would have/should have rested him another week but Mac hurt his hammy. They rolled with Brock, it was too early. I hope he heals up asap. The injury bug continues to bite us in the ass lol

What about his 16 games as a starter before yesterday?

I agree. His problems are not limited to yesterday.

Originally posted by DRnSFw:
back in 22/23 he had the ultimate game manager as his QB coach, Brian Griese, now that Griese is no longer his QB coach, he has regressed, think about it lol

He can't game manage anymore because there's not enough talent to just dump the ball off.

As far as what I have seen he has played nearly perfect both first halves of both games this year. What ends up happening is we end up with no points even though he is completing nearly all his passes.

This leads to frustration and he ends up slinging it out of frustration. Just my .02 cents.

Look at the first two games start of the game. He's literally played out of his mind both times and come away with no points...

Originally posted by Furlow:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Furlow:
I mean it's a legitimate point. I haven't really been in this thread in almost a year, and NY is still going on about the same nonsense. He clearly hasn't gotten over his crush on Lance.

Clearly you haven't been here for a yr if you think that's what I've been going on about.

the fact you can't get over this Lance debate is a you problem bud. I haven't talked about him….at this point it's a s**t rebuttal rooted in emotional nonsense. It just shows you're unwilling you are to keep things objective.

Objectively, Brock is not our main issue. Weapons are injured, OL is trash, CMC looks cooked and can't run the ball, WR's dropping balls and running into each other. Purdy's 2nd INT was a bad decision no doubt. The one to CMC batting it up in the air is not on him. Bourne couldn't catch a cold and had he caught that long one on 3rd down, he might have scored. Instead the next play the Jags ran the punt back for a TD. Purdy's fumble was like 2 seconds after the snap - we can't block for 2 seconds? Luke Farrell fumble. Jennings TD drop. And that's not even mentioning the defense's complete inability to generate a pass rush with Bosa out.

Yet you and others are in here crying about Purdy and expect him to overcome all of that. Same group of you, same stupid "arguments."

You say CMC looks cooked and can't run but you also say the O line is trash. How you going to run the ball when the O line isn't opening holes and the edge blockers aren't doing their job. Have you been watching? Half the time the defense is on the RB as soon as he gets the ball. All he can do is fight to get whatever yardage he can. I remember when thye were gashng teams and there were holes big enough to drive a truck through. Those aren't there now.

Only Josh Allen is head & shoulders above Brock. This entire League is watered down mediocrity. A play here and mistake is the difference. We won multiple down to wire games and now dropped one.

Bottomline: I see direct problems/mistakes we can & will improve. Onward.

Originally posted by Afrikan:
I can't judge how Brock has played this season because I've been out of the country for every game so far..haven't seen anything. Will catch up next week when I get back.

But I do know how Brock played late last year. Especially when he was missing some weapons and started to press... trying to do too much.

So can someone objective explain if he's playing similar to late last year? or if there is a different description.