Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 293 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Absolutely infuriating to watch. But he is no better than Jimmy in my opinion, with the caveat that he has mobility.
He needs to get better with his decision making when there is just nothing there. He's still trying to win the game by himself.
Tonges Mossed 'em. The QB gave his guy a chance to make a play. Good.
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Absolutely infuriating to watch. But he is no better than Jimmy in my opinion, with the caveat that he has mobility.

Youd be completely wrong. Jimmy never makes the Pearsall throw.
I'm pretty convinced that he could literally walk on water and some of you guys would say it's because he can't swim. Led a game winning drive, we are 1-0. It's not like he had a lot to work with today for 4 quarters. Could he have made better decisions? Absolutely, but I would rather have a quarterback out there that lays it all on the line to win rather than one that plays not to lose. It wasn't perfect my any means, but they are far worse qb's in the league than Purdy, enjoy the win, we are 1-0, against a division opponent as well.
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Absolutely infuriating to watch. But he is no better than Jimmy in my opinion, with the caveat that he has mobility.

Youd be completely wrong. Jimmy never makes the Pearsall throw.

Jimmy made plenty of other incredible throws, too. Sure, he didn't have a great deep ball, but he had his fair share of heroics. How quickly people forget…
Originally posted by iowa49er_75:
I'm pretty convinced that he could literally walk on water and some of you guys would say it's because he can't swim. Led a game winning drive, we are 1-0. It's not like he had a lot to work with today for 4 quarters. Could he have made better decisions? Absolutely, but I would rather have a quarterback out there that lays it all on the line to win rather than one that plays not to lose. It wasn't perfect my any means, but they are far worse qb's in the league than Purdy, enjoy the win, we are 1-0, against a division opponent as well.

Some fans only dwell on what wasn't perfect. Brock made some mistakes but he also made some great throws and decisions.
- 1 of the INT was a great play by the LB. he dropped real deep, yo ucan tell he was watching film. lol
- 1 of the INT was a forced play by brock.
- We were missing kittle, which is huge loss, especially when we were down other guys.
- multiple drives with 0 points because of ST.

as a whole, we played an ugly game. brock didn't play his best game, but we won. we won IN seattle. we did a lot to beat ourselves but ultimately didnt. it's a positive. we clean up some things we would of been blowing them out. Seattle has a really good defense.
Originally posted by Furlow:
You guys will never change lol.

Up and down game, love the aggressiveness but he needs to be smarter

i get it, not his fault he only has pearsall and tonges to throw to but still
[ Edited by DonnieDarko on Sep 7, 2025 at 4:54 PM ]
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Originally posted by Yeti:
Im happy we won but I am worried about Purdy. All his ints and the last TD throw were horrible decisions. It wasn't even good defense, just bad qb play.

Hes gotta stop the hero ball.

Worked time and time again in college,...so it's kinda hard I guess.
I have been saying it for a while he's a good quarterback, but far from great. The team he had around him made him appear much better than he is. He's just not the QB that elevates.
He's not getting much help. I think he played well for the most part.
Originally posted by BYisGod:
Jimmy made plenty of other incredible throws, too. Sure, he didn't have a great deep ball, but he had his fair share of heroics. How quickly people forget…

I can't think of one that rivals Purdys 10 best.

I want Purdy to play better but no way is what you said at all accurate.
Originally posted by tankle104:
Originally posted by iowa49er_75:
I'm pretty convinced that he could literally walk on water and some of you guys would say it's because he can't swim. Led a game winning drive, we are 1-0. It's not like he had a lot to work with today for 4 quarters. Could he have made better decisions? Absolutely, but I would rather have a quarterback out there that lays it all on the line to win rather than one that plays not to lose. It wasn't perfect my any means, but they are far worse qb's in the league than Purdy, enjoy the win, we are 1-0, against a division opponent as well.

Some fans only dwell on what wasn't perfect. Brock made some mistakes but he also made some great throws and decisions.
- 1 of the INT was a great play by the LB. he dropped real deep, yo ucan tell he was watching film. lol
- 1 of the INT was a forced play by brock.
- We were missing kittle, which is huge loss, especially when we were down other guys.
- multiple drives with 0 points because of ST.

as a whole, we played an ugly game. brock didn't play his best game, but we won. we won IN seattle. we did a lot to beat ourselves but ultimately didnt. it's a positive. we clean up some things we would of been blowing them out. Seattle has a really good defense.
Lots of people live to complain
Originally posted by tankle104:
Some fans only dwell on what wasn't perfect. Brock made some mistakes but he also made some great throws and decisions.
- 1 of the INT was a great play by the LB. he dropped real deep, yo ucan tell he was watching film. lol
- 1 of the INT was a forced play by brock.
- We were missing kittle, which is huge loss, especially when we were down other guys.
- multiple drives with 0 points because of ST.

as a whole, we played an ugly game. brock didn't play his best game, but we won. we won IN seattle. we did a lot to beat ourselves but ultimately didnt. it's a positive. we clean up some things we would of been blowing them out. Seattle has a really good defense.

I agree with all of this, yeah not all of his throws were pretty but he found a way to win when it mattered.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone