QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:

Originally posted by mayo49:
If someone in the family or someone in his representation gets in his ear, is the only way I see him potentially, playing hard ball with negotiations.

Very true!

Jesus tells him $60m

Originally posted by Crown:

Originally posted by random49er:
If only the numbers and situations were this simple and easy.

I get they are not this simple.

Yet that is exactly what a good agent is going to use as the benchmark.

certainly guaranteed is more important than APY.

He can use it, sure. But there's not some judge that gets to decide a final number or anything. He's under contract and without anywhere near the number of years Geno has in the NFL.

Geno's tenured and since LV's coach knows exactly what they're getting out of him (low risk), I'm sure they already had some general number amounts in mind before any trade happened.

Brock's situation is completely different and unique, actually. Can be seen as a high risk/high reward situation. When you make him automatically better than whatever players u so choose, you've obviously put all your chips in towards the "high reward" scenario.

The 49ers know better than any of us just what level that risk is if we're talking longterm contract RIGHT NOW for Purdy,...and that'll be reflected.

There is no "bad look for the 49ers" for the franchise given his '24 year, as I've heard that alot of analysts out there would be nervous about going to far for a player that still has alot to prove. And even if there was,...if they dont wanna take the high risk of a bloated contract, then that's simply their choice.

The owners colluded to come up with this "Franchise Tag" thing for exact scenarios such as this one.

The notion this deal isn't done yet and this is supposed to be the centerpiece of the franchise…goes to show what many fans have kind of been suggesting all along. Brock is a good quarterback but there's no guarantee he can deliver SB 6 unless he has a lot of talent around him. We shouldn't make the same mistake dummy franchises like Cleveland, Dallas, and Jacksonville made. Offer him a fair contract but don't go overboard. If he plays hardball let him ride out his contract and if he's worth it franchise him.

Originally posted by DrEll:

The notion this deal isn't done yet and this is supposed to be the centerpiece of the franchise…goes to show what many fans have kind of been suggesting all along. Brock is a good quarterback but there's no guarantee he can deliver SB 6 unless he has a lot of talent around him. We shouldn't make the same mistake dummy franchises like Cleveland, Dallas, and Jacksonville made. Offer him a fair contract but don't go overboard. If he plays hardball let him ride out his contract and if he's worth it franchise him.

Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

Our FO decided Trey Lance was worth 3 firsts. Did that go to show how valuable Trey is?

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

lol....

1) Brady played out his full contract in NE.

2) Brady had a stipulation in his contract that PREVENTED him from being franchise tagged.

Draft picks on rookie contracts aren't quite this fortunate. They don't get to call the shots.

If NE could have locked him up for 3 more years, though, they would have.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

lol....

1) Brady played out his full contract in NE.

2) Brady had a stipulation in his contract that PREVENTED him from being franchise tagged.

Draft picks on rookie contracts aren't quite this fortunate. They don't get to call the shots.

If NE could have locked him up for 3 more years, though, they would have.

They could have, but they decided he wasn't worth it. Goes to show he wasn't worth it, right?

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

lol....

1) Brady played out his full contract in NE.

2) Brady had a stipulation in his contract that PREVENTED him from being franchise tagged.

Draft picks on rookie contracts aren't quite this fortunate. They don't get to call the shots.

If NE could have locked him up for 3 more years, though, they would have.

They could have, but they decided he wasn't worth it. Goes to show he wasn't worth it, right?

No they couldn't have. There was a stipulation in his contract that prevented it. His contract allowed him to void it and become a FA.

Originally posted by DrEll:
The notion this deal isn't done yet and this is supposed to be the centerpiece of the franchise…goes to show what many fans have kind of been suggesting all along. Brock is a good quarterback but there's no guarantee he can deliver SB 6 unless he has a lot of talent around him. We shouldn't make the same mistake dummy franchises like Cleveland, Dallas, and Jacksonville made. Offer him a fair contract but don't go overboard. If he plays hardball let him ride out his contract and if he's worth it franchise him.

He doesn't need a lot of talent around him, just enough to get the job done.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

lol....

1) Brady played out his full contract in NE.

2) Brady had a stipulation in his contract that PREVENTED him from being franchise tagged.

Draft picks on rookie contracts aren't quite this fortunate. They don't get to call the shots.

If NE could have locked him up for 3 more years, though, they would have.

They could have, but they decided he wasn't worth it. Goes to show he wasn't worth it, right?

No they couldn't have. There was a stipulation in his contract that prevented it. His contract allowed him to void it and become a FA.

They could have repaired the relationship if they really wanted him. They didn't want to because he wasn't worth it

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

lol....

1) Brady played out his full contract in NE.

2) Brady had a stipulation in his contract that PREVENTED him from being franchise tagged.

Draft picks on rookie contracts aren't quite this fortunate. They don't get to call the shots.

If NE could have locked him up for 3 more years, though, they would have.

They could have, but they decided he wasn't worth it. Goes to show he wasn't worth it, right?

No they couldn't have. There was a stipulation in his contract that prevented it. His contract allowed him to void it and become a FA.

They could have repaired the relationship if they really wanted him. They didn't want to because he wasn't worth it

You just switched from "they decided he was washed" to "they decided to not repair a relationship" which has nothing to do with contractual allowances, lol. Trying to compare Brock & his situation to a guy that had 6 rings already was a FAIL waiting to happen.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Front office beliefs do not go to show anything

Patriots FO decided Brady was washed. Didn't mean he was

lol....

1) Brady played out his full contract in NE.

2) Brady had a stipulation in his contract that PREVENTED him from being franchise tagged.

Draft picks on rookie contracts aren't quite this fortunate. They don't get to call the shots.

If NE could have locked him up for 3 more years, though, they would have.

They could have, but they decided he wasn't worth it. Goes to show he wasn't worth it, right?

No they couldn't have. There was a stipulation in his contract that prevented it. His contract allowed him to void it and become a FA.

They could have repaired the relationship if they really wanted him. They didn't want to because he wasn't worth it

You just switched from "they decided he was washed" to "they decided to not repair a relationship" which has nothing to do with contractual allowances, lol. Trying to compare Brock & his situation to a guy that had 6 rings already was a FAIL waiting to happen.

There's a reason they decided not to repair that relationship….because they thought he was washed. Belichick thought it was time to move on when Jimmy G was ready to start. Oops

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The notion this deal isn't done yet and this is supposed to be the centerpiece of the franchise…goes to show what many fans have kind of been suggesting all along. Brock is a good quarterback but there's no guarantee he can deliver SB 6 unless he has a lot of talent around him. We shouldn't make the same mistake dummy franchises like Cleveland, Dallas, and Jacksonville made. Offer him a fair contract but don't go overboard. If he plays hardball let him ride out his contract and if he's worth it franchise him.

He doesn't need a lot of talent around him, just enough to get the job done.

Every qb needs help. Mahomes needed a dominant defense to get the team to the Super Bowl. He sure needed help against the Eagles too. I love Burrow, but he has one the best receiving corps in the nfl. This idea that qbs can lift up teams on their own is a pipe dream. Purdy certainly needs help. He is also pretty darn good. it doesn't mean the team should make a bad deal e.g. the cowboys, fins, and jags, but the team should give him a deal Commensurate with his talent.

Originally posted by SD49er:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by DrEll:
The notion this deal isn't done yet and this is supposed to be the centerpiece of the franchise…goes to show what many fans have kind of been suggesting all along. Brock is a good quarterback but there's no guarantee he can deliver SB 6 unless he has a lot of talent around him. We shouldn't make the same mistake dummy franchises like Cleveland, Dallas, and Jacksonville made. Offer him a fair contract but don't go overboard. If he plays hardball let him ride out his contract and if he's worth it franchise him.

He doesn't need a lot of talent around him, just enough to get the job done.

Every qb needs help. Mahomes needed a dominant defense to get the team to the Super Bowl. He sure needed help against the Eagles too. I love Burrow, but he has one the best receiving corps in the nfl. This idea that qbs can lift up teams on their own is a pipe dream. Purdy certainly needs help. He is also pretty darn good. it doesn't mean the team should make a bad deal e.g. the cowboys, fins, and jags, but the team should give him a deal Commensurate with his talent.

He's the point guard of the team. His job is to handoff or throw the ball. If he doesn't have his compliments of players it won't work. That's why they call it a team sport.

Originally posted by mayo49:
He's the point guard of the team. His job is to handoff or throw the ball. If he doesn't have his compliments of players it won't work. That's why they call it a team sport.

If he's just a point guard, then find another one. He's gotta be more than that if he's gonna get paid elite money. Thats the whole debate.

It's hard to have a QB making elite money and have elite players all around him making elite money.