QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Kolohe:
I believe it would've been 75% defense and 25% Shanahan if they lost. I didn't like some of Shanahan's calls today in the redzone, for instance after Drake Jackson intercepted the ball they should've let CMC or Mason punch it in. And in the beginning of the 3rd quarter, I felt they should've opened with the run. But I think they wanted to try and catch them off guard like they did Washington to start the half.

But the 9ers won, so I'm good.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

Originally posted by BoldRedandGold:
He's upset he lead 2 game winning drives without even needing 4th down.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I liked Purdy's ability to stay calm and collected in crunch time. It's something he hasn't had the opportunity to showcase yet, and he definitely passed the test.

On the flipside, he had a bunch of things today that I did not like. He predetermined a lot of throws today, and subsequently missed bigger plays. He was also very inaccurate on multiple deep shots, which we haven't really seen. He also moved to his 2nd and 3rd reads just as his previous read was breaking wide open.

Every one of those complaints are things Jimmy did regularly and Brock did today. While today was the first time I had any of those issues with Brock, I can only hope it was a one off thing and not something we have to worry about moving forward.

Overall, happy with the win and Brock's play in crunch time. But a lot of the game I was getting Jimmy vibes, and that's not a good thing.

Can't disagree with any of this. He's gotten a little worse each game. The numbers, particularly QB rating, show this, but it's pretty evident just from the eye test as well. If he keeps declining each game, it won't be long before it's basically like having Jimmy out there, which is not a good thing whenever it's the playoffs.

Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by BoldRedandGold:

Originally posted by tankle104:
Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

He's upset he lead 2 game winning drives without even needing 4th down.

Nobody is upset about it. It's just a fact that he's gotten worse each game. It's a trend. Part of that is because he started out as hot as he did. Some regression was inevitable.

It doesn't change the fact that what he's doing is impressive. The offense has scored 35 or more points with Purdy as the starter as many times as they have with Jimmy in the last 3 seasons combined.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I liked Purdy's ability to stay calm and collected in crunch time. It's something he hasn't had the opportunity to showcase yet, and he definitely passed the test.

On the flipside, he had a bunch of things today that I did not like. He predetermined a lot of throws today, and subsequently missed bigger plays. He was also very inaccurate on multiple deep shots, which we haven't really seen. He also moved to his 2nd and 3rd reads just as his previous read was breaking wide open.

Every one of those complaints are things Jimmy did regularly and Brock did today. While today was the first time I had any of those issues with Brock, I can only hope it was a one off thing and not something we have to worry about moving forward.

Overall, happy with the win and Brock's play in crunch time. But a lot of the game I was getting Jimmy vibes, and that's not a good thing.

Can't disagree with any of this. He's gotten a little worse each game. The numbers, particularly QB rating, show this, but it's pretty evident just from the eye test as well. If he keeps declining each game, it won't be long before it's basically like having Jimmy out there, which is not a good thing whenever it's the playoffs.

Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

It's one thing to be pessimistic and have a factual basis to your opinion, it's another to just sling meaningless s**t at a wall for the sake of bringing the conversation down to your level. Not even worth a response.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
I believe it would've been 75% defense and 25% Shanahan if they lost. I didn't like some of Shanahan's calls today in the redzone, for instance after Drake Jackson intercepted the ball they should've let CMC or Mason punch it in. And in the beginning of the 3rd quarter, I felt they should've opened with the run. But I think they wanted to try and catch them off guard like they did Washington to start the half.

But the 9ers won, so I'm good.

What about the balls that were dropped and the plays that were missed by the actual players, though?

I mean the defense as a whole is able to get blame (just based on your percentages). Why does every player on offense get a pass?

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
I believe it would've been 75% defense and 25% Shanahan if they lost. I didn't like some of Shanahan's calls today in the redzone, for instance after Drake Jackson intercepted the ball they should've let CMC or Mason punch it in. And in the beginning of the 3rd quarter, I felt they should've opened with the run. But I think they wanted to try and catch them off guard like they did Washington to start the half.

But the 9ers won, so I'm good.

What about the balls that were dropped and the plays that were missed by the actual players, though?

I mean the defense as a whole is able to get blame (just based on your percentages). Why does every player on offense get a pass?

True, agree with you there. The dropped passes were also frustrating, I just look at the two series that could've swung the momentum heavily in the 9ers favor.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I liked Purdy's ability to stay calm and collected in crunch time. It's something he hasn't had the opportunity to showcase yet, and he definitely passed the test.

On the flipside, he had a bunch of things today that I did not like. He predetermined a lot of throws today, and subsequently missed bigger plays. He was also very inaccurate on multiple deep shots, which we haven't really seen. He also moved to his 2nd and 3rd reads just as his previous read was breaking wide open.

Every one of those complaints are things Jimmy did regularly and Brock did today. While today was the first time I had any of those issues with Brock, I can only hope it was a one off thing and not something we have to worry about moving forward.

Overall, happy with the win and Brock's play in crunch time. But a lot of the game I was getting Jimmy vibes, and that's not a good thing.

Can't disagree with any of this. He's gotten a little worse each game. The numbers, particularly QB rating, show this, but it's pretty evident just from the eye test as well. If he keeps declining each game, it won't be long before it's basically like having Jimmy out there, which is not a good thing whenever it's the playoffs.

Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

It's one thing to be pessimistic and have a factual basis to your opinion, it's another to just sling meaningless s**t at a wall for the sake of bringing the conversation down to your level. Not even worth a response.

It's literally factual that he's gotten worse each game.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I liked Purdy's ability to stay calm and collected in crunch time. It's something he hasn't had the opportunity to showcase yet, and he definitely passed the test.

On the flipside, he had a bunch of things today that I did not like. He predetermined a lot of throws today, and subsequently missed bigger plays. He was also very inaccurate on multiple deep shots, which we haven't really seen. He also moved to his 2nd and 3rd reads just as his previous read was breaking wide open.

Every one of those complaints are things Jimmy did regularly and Brock did today. While today was the first time I had any of those issues with Brock, I can only hope it was a one off thing and not something we have to worry about moving forward.

Overall, happy with the win and Brock's play in crunch time. But a lot of the game I was getting Jimmy vibes, and that's not a good thing.

Can't disagree with any of this. He's gotten a little worse each game. The numbers, particularly QB rating, show this, but it's pretty evident just from the eye test as well. If he keeps declining each game, it won't be long before it's basically like having Jimmy out there, which is not a good thing whenever it's the playoffs.

Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

It's one thing to be pessimistic and have a factual basis to your opinion, it's another to just sling meaningless s**t at a wall for the sake of bringing the conversation down to your level. Not even worth a response.

It's literally factual that he's gotten worse each game.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I liked Purdy's ability to stay calm and collected in crunch time. It's something he hasn't had the opportunity to showcase yet, and he definitely passed the test.

On the flipside, he had a bunch of things today that I did not like. He predetermined a lot of throws today, and subsequently missed bigger plays. He was also very inaccurate on multiple deep shots, which we haven't really seen. He also moved to his 2nd and 3rd reads just as his previous read was breaking wide open.

Every one of those complaints are things Jimmy did regularly and Brock did today. While today was the first time I had any of those issues with Brock, I can only hope it was a one off thing and not something we have to worry about moving forward.

Overall, happy with the win and Brock's play in crunch time. But a lot of the game I was getting Jimmy vibes, and that's not a good thing.

Can't disagree with any of this. He's gotten a little worse each game. The numbers, particularly QB rating, show this, but it's pretty evident just from the eye test as well. If he keeps declining each game, it won't be long before it's basically like having Jimmy out there, which is not a good thing whenever it's the playoffs.

Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

It's one thing to be pessimistic and have a factual basis to your opinion, it's another to just sling meaningless s**t at a wall for the sake of bringing the conversation down to your level. Not even worth a response.

It's literally factual that he's gotten worse each game.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
I believe it would've been 75% defense and 25% Shanahan if they lost. I didn't like some of Shanahan's calls today in the redzone, for instance after Drake Jackson intercepted the ball they should've let CMC or Mason punch it in. And in the beginning of the 3rd quarter, I felt they should've opened with the run. But I think they wanted to try and catch them off guard like they did Washington to start the half.

But the 9ers won, so I'm good.

What about the balls that were dropped and the plays that were missed by the actual players, though?

I mean the defense as a whole is able to get blame (just based on your percentages). Why does every player on offense get a pass?

True, agree with you there. The dropped passes were also frustrating, I just look at the two series that could've swung the momentum heavily in the 9ers favor.

Defense was still disappointing as hell today. I really hope it was overconfidence, partying last night or both. Hands down our worst game since KC, but I'm so proud they pulled it out.

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I liked Purdy's ability to stay calm and collected in crunch time. It's something he hasn't had the opportunity to showcase yet, and he definitely passed the test.

On the flipside, he had a bunch of things today that I did not like. He predetermined a lot of throws today, and subsequently missed bigger plays. He was also very inaccurate on multiple deep shots, which we haven't really seen. He also moved to his 2nd and 3rd reads just as his previous read was breaking wide open.

Every one of those complaints are things Jimmy did regularly and Brock did today. While today was the first time I had any of those issues with Brock, I can only hope it was a one off thing and not something we have to worry about moving forward.

Overall, happy with the win and Brock's play in crunch time. But a lot of the game I was getting Jimmy vibes, and that's not a good thing.

Can't disagree with any of this. He's gotten a little worse each game. The numbers, particularly QB rating, show this, but it's pretty evident just from the eye test as well. If he keeps declining each game, it won't be long before it's basically like having Jimmy out there, which is not a good thing whenever it's the playoffs.

Worse each game? Lol all based off of the QBR? I'm not saying he doesn't have things he needs to get better at but I don't think he's declined at all every game.

he just won a shootout on the road with the second seed on the line. If this is as bad as Purdy is. - then wow! We are in for a great ride.

you can't expect to blow out everyone - which is what we've done for most of his starts. So you're not going to get those beautiful stats every game, hell most games you won't.

49ersRing and his negative vibes, you should've seen him in the gameday. You could change his name to CowboysRing and you wouldn't know the difference.

It's one thing to be pessimistic and have a factual basis to your opinion, it's another to just sling meaningless s**t at a wall for the sake of bringing the conversation down to your level. Not even worth a response.

It's literally factual that he's gotten worse each game.

based off what?

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
I believe it would've been 75% defense and 25% Shanahan if they lost. I didn't like some of Shanahan's calls today in the redzone, for instance after Drake Jackson intercepted the ball they should've let CMC or Mason punch it in. And in the beginning of the 3rd quarter, I felt they should've opened with the run. But I think they wanted to try and catch them off guard like they did Washington to start the half.

But the 9ers won, so I'm good.

What about the balls that were dropped and the plays that were missed by the actual players, though?

I mean the defense as a whole is able to get blame (just based on your percentages). Why does every player on offense get a pass?

True, agree with you there. The dropped passes were also frustrating, I just look at the two series that could've swung the momentum heavily in the 9ers favor.

Defense was still disappointing as hell today. I really hope it was overconfidence, partying last night or both. Hands down our worst game since KC, but I'm so proud they pulled it out.

I wanna believe it was partying/hangover and slept late. They looked out of sync pretty much the whole day.