Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 293 users in the forums

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Originally posted by bigpete50:
Originally posted by Eli_23:
My God. What was he thinking on that redzone INT

He's going to come back down to earth a tad only because he's so young and inexperienced. But for the most part, I thought he played well today.

He wasn't the reason why we lost today.

He's definitely a reason why we didn't win today.

Yeah I agree. Love Purdy but the truth is he was a big part of us losing today. Defense was the other part.
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
Originally posted by raywm3:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by raywm3:
My god, some of the dumbass takes on here. Purdy's the best thing we've had since Jeff Garcia or even Young and if he isn't f**king perfect or god forbid has a turnover then he's a "noodle" with no ability to take us anywhere. Unbelievable. This loss is on Wilks, period. Even if Purdy made zero mistakes he still would've lost a shootout.
it wasn't a shoot out, we lost cause we suck on offense throw INTs

LOL. THAT'S why we lost? You should actually watch the game before you comment.

He should. Yup.
Originally posted by Montana:
Anyone who says BP is not HIM has premature ej......lol...

He is likely feeling effects from the concussion still..which is why I was kinda wanting Sam to play have BP rest. I think they pushed it....and hello..how many times so we have to say our D sucks until Wilks it bye bye?
This isn't normal for Brock, so maybe he has time to heal after the bye and get back to his enlarged self. He will return to full BCB status..I believe lol.
Our D, however..SOS lol

KS was asked. Reality is, if he was still feeling any effect, he doesn't play. Period. That's what the protocol is about. He is 100% beyond the concussion. It was an excuse last week, and I question how valid an excuse, as he made the same errors today as he did last week. Concussions, you can get hit, and not feel any adverse effect until a while after, that's how it was described last week. He did his postgame last week and seemed fine.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by raywm3:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by raywm3:
My god, some of the dumbass takes on here. Purdy's the best thing we've had since Jeff Garcia or even Young and if he isn't f**king perfect or god forbid has a turnover then he's a "noodle" with no ability to take us anywhere. Unbelievable. This loss is on Wilks, period. Even if Purdy made zero mistakes he still would've lost a shootout.
it wasn't a shoot out, we lost cause we suck on offense throw INTs

LOL. THAT'S why we lost? You should actually watch the game before you comment.

He should. Yup.

Defense played bad in the first half but player better in the 2nd. Offense played fine in the first half but played bad in the 2nd half. We played a poor game on both sides of the ball.
Watching the game, it seemed like Shanahan is letting Brock try difficult throws and is giving him the opportunity to learn and grow as a quarterback, rather than playing it very safe. Seems like he believes Brock can become much better.

He did not reign Brock in to play it safe.

Brock had a number of very good throws that a game manager QB would not have thrown.

He did contribute to the defeat but the defense completely sucked. Better defensive play and we would have won.
Originally posted by Montana:
Anyone who says BP is not HIM has premature ej......lol...

He is likely feeling effects from the concussion still..which is why I was kinda wanting Sam to play have BP rest. I think they pushed it....and hello..how many times so we have to say our D sucks until Wilks is bye bye?
This isn't normal for Brock, so maybe he has time to heal after the bye and get back to his enlarged self. He will return to full BCB status..I believe lol.
Our D, however..SOS lol

Lulz he made some beautiful pinpoint deep passes but because he threw two bone headed jimmy-like ints it's cause his head is still sore
[ Edited by 49erKing on Oct 29, 2023 at 8:52 PM ]
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,497
Originally posted by LivingInExile:
Watching the game, it seemed like Shanahan is letting Brock try difficult throws and is giving him the opportunity to learn and grow as a quarterback, rather than playing it very safe. Seems like he believes Brock can become much better.

He did not reign Brock in to play it safe.

Brock had a number of very good throws that a game manager QB would not have thrown.

He did contribute to the defeat but the defense completely sucked. Better defensive play and we would have won.

You aren't winning many games scoring 17 points
Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by raywm3:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by raywm3:
My god, some of the dumbass takes on here. Purdy's the best thing we've had since Jeff Garcia or even Young and if he isn't f**king perfect or god forbid has a turnover then he's a "noodle" with no ability to take us anywhere. Unbelievable. This loss is on Wilks, period. Even if Purdy made zero mistakes he still would've lost a shootout.
it wasn't a shoot out, we lost cause we suck on offense throw INTs

LOL. THAT'S why we lost? You should actually watch the game before you comment.

He should. Yup.

Defense played bad in the first half but player better in the 2nd. Offense played fine in the first half but played bad in the 2nd half. We played a poor game on both sides of the ball.

It wasn't great on either side. I agree.
I didn't catch the whole game. Travel day for me. Son spoiled it for me so I didn't want to watch yet. Were we running the ball well at any point? How bad was the oline?

I saw the int's on the news...after a Brock Purdy Tundra commercial no less LOL and well they sucked. All interceptions do though. Not jumping ship yet, not like we can anyway!

Crimson and gold till I'm dead and cold!
[ Edited by ninerfan818 on Oct 29, 2023 at 9:03 PM ]
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by LivingInExile:
Watching the game, it seemed like Shanahan is letting Brock try difficult throws and is giving him the opportunity to learn and grow as a quarterback, rather than playing it very safe. Seems like he believes Brock can become much better.

He did not reign Brock in to play it safe.

Brock had a number of very good throws that a game manager QB would not have thrown.

He did contribute to the defeat but the defense completely sucked. Better defensive play and we would have won.

You aren't winning many games scoring 17 points
Purdy is pushing because the defense can't stop a nosebleed.

yes he's making mistakes and had costly ones but the defense literally does nothing. If not for a fumble and a missed field goal (which are mistakes on the Bengals account), cincy was scoring on every single drive.

I haven't seen the defense this bad in a long long time. Chip Kelly era.
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I didn't catch the whole game. Travel day for me. Son spoiled it for me so I didn't want to watch yet. We're we running the ball well at any point? How bad was the oline?

I saw the int's on the news...after a Brock Purdy Tundra commercial no less LOL and well they sucked. All interceptions do though. Not jumping ship yet, not like we can anyway!

Crimson and gold till I'm dead and cold!

OL sucked, Brendel shoved into Juice on a 3rd and short.. lil tired of KS trying Juice runs on 3rd and short into packed fronts. With no push up front.

BP was our leading rusher lol, I think 56 non BP rush yds, as a team, that's poop
Originally posted by 49erKing:
Lulz he made some beautiful pinpoint deep passes but because he threw two bone headed jimmy-like ints it's cause his head is still sore

Lol I think he may be overthinking things and 2nd guessing his instincts after that 1st loss? Sure seems like that 1st loss may have affected him mentally idk
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I didn't catch the whole game. Travel day for me. Son spoiled it for me so I didn't want to watch yet. We're we running the ball well at any point? How bad was the oline?

I saw the int's on the news...after a Brock Purdy Tundra commercial no less LOL and well they sucked. All interceptions do though. Not jumping ship yet, not like we can anyway!

Crimson and gold till I'm dead and cold!

OL sucked, Brendel shoved into Juice on a 3rd and short.. lil tired of KS trying Juice runs on 3rd and short into packed fronts. With no push up front.

BP was our leading rusher lol, I think 56 non BP rush yds, as a team, that's poop

Yikes! I think McCaffrey is more injured than we know and that sucks. That's another thread though! I hear he scored again though! Yah om not jumping ship yet!

Kid needs his confidence back. He'll be fine. He isn't Elite, and I still want the team to get an Elite QB. Haven't won a SB since we had one, says something, ya know
[ Edited by ninerfan818 on Oct 29, 2023 at 9:08 PM ]
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,497
Originally posted by NinerPrideinNJ:
Purdy is pushing because the defense can't stop a nosebleed.

yes he's making mistakes and had costly ones but the defense literally does nothing. If not for a fumble and a missed field goal (which are mistakes on the Bengals account), cincy was scoring on every single drive.

I haven't seen the defense this bad in a long long time. Chip Kelly era.

A bad Brock INT directly lead to 7 points for Cincy in a close game. The defense wasn't great but the QB was just as bad in the 2nd half.
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
I didn't catch the whole game. Travel day for me. Son spoiled it for me so I didn't want to watch yet. We're we running the ball well at any point? How bad was the oline?

I saw the int's on the news...after a Brock Purdy Tundra commercial no less LOL and well they sucked. All interceptions do though. Not jumping ship yet, not like we can anyway!

Crimson and gold till I'm dead and cold!

OL sucked, Brendel shoved into Juice on a 3rd and short.. lil tired of KS trying Juice runs on 3rd and short into packed fronts. With no push up front.

BP was our leading rusher lol, I think 56 non BP rush yds, as a team, that's poop

Yikes! I think McCaffrey is more injured than we know and that sucks. That's another thread though! I hear he scored again though! Yah om not jumping ship yet!

Kid needs his confidence back. He'll be fine. He isn't Elite, and ainstill want the tr to get an Elite QB. Haven't won a SB since we had one, says something, ya know

I think CMC is healthy, he looked spry on the TD last week, had a TD again this week, but the yards are tough to come by between the tackles, then we get behind schedule and ultimately behind in the game, and that's when bad Purdy comes out
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone