QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Koldo:
Why is a high school level QB who's yet to be activated on game day by the Cowboys still a topic on this forum?

Ask the posters who are still trying to perpetuate the Brock vs. Trey debate.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Nice post. People need to pump the breaks with the emotional responses about Brock. Yeah, he had a chance to come through at the end of the game for us and didnt. I thought he played an A- game for 3+ quarters. Obviously everyone is going to focus on the last 2 possessions, but in no way did Brock lose the game for us IMO.

The ire of that loss is on the Ds pathetic performance.

That said Brock can't have that 1st pick. Learn and get better.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Chance:
Everyone thinks they're objective. Get in line. Your arguments earlier in this thread were trash on occasion. We don't need to rehash it. I've said many times that when things don't go well for Purdy, this place will implode. Guess what? To me, there's no reason to back off Purdy being special. I've seen enough to know that he has traits that are elite and will not not improve in consistency as he plays more games. People tend to forget this is just a kid who's played less than a season worth of games. Pace yourselves.

They're trash comments because why?

What like you were being some "objective fan" and the rest of us aren't HA yeah okay dude.

You see one part of a post that isn't 100% calling Brock amazing and you get all emotional about it…never mind the rest of the post saying good things about him.

There's no reason to debate or have convos with people that act like that

Trash arguments because you were using fallacies like cherry picking to prop up your preconceived opinion. Logical fallacies aren't debateable; either you make sound arguments or you don't. So yeah, some were destined for the waste bin. Sorry.

As for the rest, I never claimed to be objective. I understand we all carry bias and don't pretend to be on a higher plane like you do.

Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Basically a young Drew Brees. He can process well, throw anywhere on the field, is decently mobile, but had not played in any late game pressure situations in the NFL until last week.

Needing a field goal, he's 1/1 on delivering a chance

Needing a touchdown, he's 0/2 if you count both drives.

I think the sky is the limit once he fully figures out NFL defenses and gets used to these situations. Last week was bad throws. This week he had a couple inaccurate throws and one really bad decision. Brock just needs to relax and put the mistakes behind him.

A guy like Allen can throw bombs but man he's probably just as infuriating to Buffalo fans because he has thrown a lot of picks that have cost them multiple games this year. 3 on opening day against the Jets, and a pick in three consecutive games thru this week.

Pretty much agree (minus the Allen stuff). Would also point out he succeeded in a late game situation against the Raiders last year.

Originally posted by Bloodless:
If Brock Lead the Niners to A TD at the end of the game. We are talking about how Purdy Single handed won this gam. And how amazing he is. But instead he threw a bad pass that got Intercepted and now it is somehow all on him we lost and he is no good. Purdy has half the INTs of Mahomes but Purdy throws a couple of picks and he sucks all of a sudden. I get this was a bad time for it as it came after his poor performance against the Browns. But Purdy played extremely well for the vast majority of this game. Not to excuse the bad throw in the big moment but the rest of the team primarily the defense was the reason we were down at that point in the game not Purdy.

Yea, that's kind of how it works.

How to TF is talking about replacing him, saying he's not him, we don't have a QB, not being overly critical of Brock after his first bad stretch in his career?

Brock came back from injury and picked up where he left off. Actually, taking it up another notch. He was being talked about as a top 10 QB. was putting up elite stats. But after his worst game by far, in which he was still pretty good for the majority, and folks talking about he's not it, replacing him, etc.

Seems pretty straightforward, but I guess not.
agree to disagree.

DM if you want to continue this.

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Ask the posters who are still trying to perpetuate the Brock vs. Trey debate.

The best part was is that it never was one in the first place. We just had to stumble through the offseason until peeps were hit in the face with the truth.

love how people are ok with brock playing great for 3 qtrs

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by Bloodless:
If Brock Lead the Niners to A TD at the end of the game. We are talking about how Purdy Single handed won this gam. And how amazing he is. But instead he threw a bad pass that got Intercepted and now it is somehow all on him we lost and he is no good. Purdy has half the INTs of Mahomes but Purdy throws a couple of picks and he sucks all of a sudden. I get this was a bad time for it as it came after his poor performance against the Browns. But Purdy played extremely well for the vast majority of this game. Not to excuse the bad throw in the big moment but the rest of the team primarily the defense was the reason we were down at that point in the game not Purdy.

Yea, that's kind of how it works.

Yeah, if you're a hay seed that blows in whatever direction the weather vane points. Small mindedness.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Nice post. People need to pump the breaks with the emotional responses about Brock. Yeah, he had a chance to come through at the end of the game for us and didnt. I thought he played an A- game for 3+ quarters. Obviously everyone is going to focus on the last 2 possessions, but in no way did Brock lose the game for us IMO.

The ire of that loss is on the Ds pathetic performance.

That said Brock can't have that 1st pick. Learn and get better.

I think that first pick was slightly inaccurate, but it wasnt as terrible of a throw as it seemed. Jennings got bumped off of his route, and he didnt get to where Brock thought he was going to be. It was an anticipation throw. Granted, I still think the pass would have been slightly ahead of Jennings even if he didnt get bumped off of his route. Brock took full responsibility for it, and said Jennings was exactly where he was supposed to be (being a great leader that he is and not making excuses).

Brock is still really young. Would I have preferred he come through last night at the end? Of course. But as long as he is learning, it is what it is.

Originally posted by Chance:
Yeah, if you're a hay seed that blows in whatever direction the weather vane points. Small mindedness.

Nailed it.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Nice post. People need to pump the breaks with the emotional responses about Brock. Yeah, he had a chance to come through at the end of the game for us and didnt. I thought he played an A- game for 3+ quarters. Obviously everyone is going to focus on the last 2 possessions, but in no way did Brock lose the game for us IMO.

The ire of that loss is on the Ds pathetic performance.

That said Brock can't have that 1st pick. Learn and get better.

I've seen nothing from Brock that proves he can't win a SB. People are overreacting.

That being said, he needs to bounce back quickly if we have any chance of getting a top seed.

I also worry that his arm strength after the surgery will get worse as the season goes on. Maybe it will get better? Any doctors want to chime in? lol

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I think that first pick was slightly inaccurate, but it wasnt as terrible of a throw as it seemed. Jennings got bumped off of his route, and he didnt get to where Brock thought he was going to be. It was an anticipation throw. Granted, I still think the pass would have been slightly ahead of Jennings even if he didnt get bumped off of his route. Brock took full responsibility for it, and said Jennings was exactly where he was supposed to be (being a great leader that he is and not making excuses).

Brock is still really young. Would I have preferred he come through last night at the end? Of course. But as long as he is learning, it is what it is.

Looked like he might have thrown* it blind. Really hard to see his eyes though. His head never moved in Jennings direction. That would be concerning for me.

Originally posted by Waterbear:
I've seen nothing from Brock that proves he can't win a SB. People are overreacting.

That being said, he needs to bounce back quickly if we have any chance of getting a top seed.

I also worry that his arm strength after the surgery will get worse as the season goes on. Maybe it will get better? Any doctors want to chime in? lol

We got bigger fish to fry in terms of getting the 1 seed, though Brock can definitely play better.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by OnTheClock:

Basically a young Drew Brees. He can process well, throw anywhere on the field, is decently mobile, but had not played in any late game pressure situations in the NFL until last week.

Needing a field goal, he's 1/1 on delivering a chance

Needing a touchdown, he's 0/2 if you count both drives.

I think the sky is the limit once he fully figures out NFL defenses and gets used to these situations. Last week was bad throws. This week he had a couple inaccurate throws and one really bad decision. Brock just needs to relax and put the mistakes behind him.

A guy like Allen can throw bombs but man he's probably just as infuriating to Buffalo fans because he has thrown a lot of picks that have cost them multiple games this year. 3 on opening day against the Jets, and a pick in three consecutive games thru this week.

Pretty much agree (minus the Allen stuff). Would also point out he succeeded in a late game situation against the Raiders last year.

True, though I was only looking at a pressure situation while trailing late.